God of War vs Uncharted. Which do you find better?

Dead Space 2 was a better 3rd person action shooter game... and it wasn't even an action shooter game

@bigcheesen

You really need to broaden your horizons and play more games....

When you look at PURE TPS games,

Uncharted has some of the best gameplay of any pure third person shooter out there,

Unlike the Playstation/Uncharted haters, I will actually back up my claims with legitimate reasons!

I present to you ladies and gentleman

Exhibit 1:

Look at the way you can freely move upon the environment, from the ground or from atop vertically

You can take the high ground at any time to get the drop on ememies

Or you can sneak around and stealth kill Etc etc etc

Now here is that same segment but played differently

By the way, look at how smooth and responsive everything is too. You can approach enemies how ever way you want to in levels like that, and in many other levels in Uncharted etc

Uncharted in those instances has the most sand box like gameplay of any other pure mainstream TPS you can think of.

You can stay ground level or go atop vertically, stealth or go all out rambo in style.

Uncharted has always had some of the best PURE gameplay of any TPS (especially part 2 and 3) Gears of War could never touch what Uncharted offers up in just that gameplay segment alone,

Nor can Gears (and Halo) get within even a fraction of touching Uncharted's cinematic gameplay , presentation, and story elements etc But wait.......

Apparently it was all just an elaborate illusion by Naughty Dog because random trolls on the internet say Uncharted is a QTE movie, is on rails, and has "meh" gameplay

So how is this even possible! Damn you Naughty Dog for tricking us into LOVING the gameplay in Uncharted! Bunch of level 100 wizards you are you Naughty Dog!

I haven't watched either movie, so I can't pass judgement.

No, judging by some of the ridiculous "comments" in this thread Uncharted IS VASTLY UNDER-rated now.

BOTH Uncharted and Last of Us are amazing in their own ways! APPRECIATE BOTH for what they are.

Uncharted is light hearted in nature. Its NOT to be taken too seriously. Its easy going- more action orientated gameplay serves the kind of game it is very well etc

The Last of Us is a lot darker in tone, a lot more mature, and tackles very serious life issues etc. The gameplay in Last of Us is a lot more tense, dire, dynamic, and open etc.

Uncharted IS utilmately a SHOOTER while the Last of Us is NOT your typical AAA shooter in any sense of the word lol

BUT having said all of that, it should NOT be a knock on Uncharted's gameplay (Uncharted has some of the best TPS gameplay of the TPS genre)

...The Last of Us simply has more open, dynamic, engaging, and thoughtfull gameplay then 100% of all current games do.....PLUS when playing Last of Us I have never experienced combat that intense before PERIOD.....Gameplay fits the game that Last of Us is perfectly..... and actually Last of Us doesnt have the dissonance that Uncharted and other games have etc

All though BOTH have the Naughty Dog story telling magic....The Last of Us is obviously an evolution of everything Naughty Dog has learned in the past. Think of it like this. Naughty Dog is the best trainer in boxing but before they got to that point where they molded the pound for pound king (Last of Us) they had to gain the experience training regional champs in order to grow and learn (Uncharted)

That should still not be a knock on Uncharted. Uncharted was revoultionary for its time (Naughty Dog is still improving too and will only get better) Last of Us does everything better in every way and im sure Naughty Dogs next game after Last of Us will even blow The Last of Us away as Naughty Dog keeps honing their craft

The fact that Naughty Dog in one gen created both Uncharted 2 AND last of Us ( 2 of the greatest games of the past gen)...thats...well words cant describe how amazing that is

That is what we should be talking about. Naughty Dog is simply on another level of game development

-Uncharted 2 rated at 96 on MC

-Last of Us rated at 96 on MC

NO developer has ever creted 2 NEW IPS in one gen that have both scored higher then 95.

Naughty Dog has broken all kinds of developer record and they will continue to break records as developers

Naughty Dog with Uncharted revolutionzed this generation of gaming(by creating cinematic gamplay and taking story+presentation to new heights)....Look at how many have tried to copy Naughty Dog's patented Uncharted gameplay formual but of course to no avil

Then with the Last of Us, Naughty Dog goes and does it all over again ...but with another genre.

They have flipped the survival horror genre on its head this time (with Uncharted it was the action adventure genre)

Naughty Dog sets the trends, others copy them while Naughty Dog moves on and always stays one step ahead of their MANY immitators. Im speechless....we are witnessing game developmemt history with what Naughty Dog is doing

Naughty Dog is the BEST developer of all time. There is no questioning it (talent wise, their versatility, their creativity, ability to make such engaging charcters in interesting worlds whom you care about while giving you top notch gameplay all wraped up in great well told stories)

Thing is Naughty Dog is still in their PRIMES too.

THANK you for creating many of my favorite games of all time Naughty Dog! (The Crash games, The Jak & Daxter games, Last of Us, Uncharted 2, Uncharted 3) Words cant describe how much I love you Naughty Dog and how grateful i am for your hard work and the passion you put into gaming for us

If anyone from Naughty Dog is readimg this, YOU guys(Naughty Dog) are proving to critics why GAMES can be amazing interactive pieces of art, gameplay, and story telling, as your games are

From the bottom of my heart, Thank you for the Last of Us Naughty Dog:) The Last of Us is the greatest game i have ever played. It moved me on an emotional level that i tought wasnt possible from games

All i could think about was the Last of Us whem I wasnt playing it. It was a monumental gaming achivement

You are amazing Naughty Dog:) And thank you Sony for always supporting Naughty Dog and always letting Naughty Dog do their thing!

Sony+Naughty Dog is like peanut butter+jelly.

Naughty Dog games make me proud to be a gamer:)