a FAIR game comparison of ps3 vs xbox 360 game wise

wouldn't the fair comparison be what the consumer can get now for both systems?Ontain

xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

Compearing a game like Perfect Dark Zero..that came out in early 2005 i think

To R:FOM which came out later 2006

Is not fair

The only thing that can be fair is

Comparing Elder scrolls Obvilivon

Which consoles version will be better ?????

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!Felix_120192

read my first post.

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

EDIT: Don't blame me, the title was first call "PS3 vs Xbox".:P

xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

Compearing a game like Perfect Dark Zero..that came out in early 2005 i think

To R:FOM which came out later 2006

Is not fair

The only thing that can be fair is

Comparing Elder scrolls Obvilivon

Which consoles version will be better ?????

Norg

I'm perfect for the job.:P

(PS3) Fall of Man:

(Xbox) Halo:

Kev_Unreal

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!BloodTorment1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

[QUOTE="Kev_Unreal"]

I'm perfect for the job.:P

(PS3) Fall of Man:

(Xbox) Halo:

Felix_120192

it is, but what about your thread title?:P PS3 vs Xbox

[QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

[QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="Kev_Unreal"]

I'm perfect for the job.:P

(PS3) Fall of Man:

(Xbox) Halo:

Kev_Unreal

it is, but what about your thread title?:P PS3 vs Xbox

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!Felix_120192

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

This is a cut and paste but I think it's still up to date. I will check to make sure and edit it if needed...

360: 2 AAA and 11 AA titles. 5 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (8.8 )

Kameo (8.7)

DOA 4 (8.8 )

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Burnout Revenge (8.8 )

Ridge Racer 6 (8.1)

Condenmed (8.0)

FNR 3 (8.3)

NBA 2K6 (8.3)

King Kong (8.2)

NFS: MW (8.4)

PS3: 11 AA games. 2 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

Ridge Racer 7 (8.0)

NHL 2K7 (8.3)

FNR 3 (8.2)

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (8.2)

NBA 2K7 (8.2)

Tiger Woods (8.2)

COD 3 (8.2)

NBA Street Homecourt (8.0)

Def Jam: Icon (8.1)

[QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!BloodTorment1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

what games did xbox 360 have first 4 month of release... post'em here

what games did ps3 have first 4 months of release.... post'em here.



point proven.
Felix_120192

This is a cut and paste but I think it's still up to date. I will check to make sure and edit it if needed...

360: 2 AAA and 11 AA titles. 5 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (8.8 )

Kameo (8.7)

DOA 4 (8.8 )

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Burnout Revenge (8.8 )

Ridge Racer 6 (8.1)

Condenmed (8.0)

FNR 3 (8.3)

NBA 2K6 (8.3)

King Kong (8.2)

NFS: MW (8.4)

PS3: 11 AA games. 2 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

Ridge Racer 7 (8.0)

NHL 2K7 (8.3)

FNR 3 (8.2)

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (8.2)

NBA 2K7 (8.2)

Tiger Woods (8.2)

COD 3 (8.2)

NBA Street Homecourt (8.0)

Def Jam: Icon (8.1)

Idonomeus

What's the point of comparing the 360's first year to the PS3's first year? The 360 launched without any competition.DaysAirlines

[QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

Yeah but the truth is, the devs can only work with what they've got. And the ps3 is considerably harder to make games for, thus the delays. But as long as Lair and Heavenly Sword is good I'm fine:P

This is a cut and paste but I think it's still up to date. I will check to make sure and edit it if needed...

360: 2 AAA and 11 AA titles. 5 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (8.8 )

Kameo (8.7)

DOA 4 (8.8 )

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Burnout Revenge (8.8 )

Ridge Racer 6 (8.1)

Condenmed (8.0)

FNR 3 (8.3)

NBA 2K6 (8.3)

King Kong (8.2)

NFS: MW (8.4)

PS3: 11 AA games. 2 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

Ridge Racer 7 (8.0)

NHL 2K7 (8.3)

FNR 3 (8.2)

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (8.2)

NBA 2K7 (8.2)

Tiger Woods (8.2)

COD 3 (8.2)

NBA Street Homecourt (8.0)

Def Jam: Icon (8.1)

Idonomeus

Take this list minus the lameness and it looks about like this

360: 2 AAA and 3 AA titles. 3 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Kameo (8.7)

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Condenmed (8.0)

PS3: 3 AA games. 1 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

COD 3 (8.2)

[QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

he means 360. not the first one. cause personally atleast the xbox one had halo to start of with. 360 did have a AAA in perfect dark zero. im sorry its your opinion that resistance is better. but if we just go on ratings then yeah PDZ is better (its system wars, we are only aloud to argue with gamespot reviews, personally i use gamerankings, so really resistance is way better than PDZ). 360 also had call of duty 2, dead or alive 4, and kameo. also by the end of march 360 had oblivion. which is a really good game for people who like rpgs. so the 360 lineup for the first 4 months was a little better than PS3s. in my opinion. personally i dont want a PS3 anytime soon(atleast not until MGS4). but if u want it, its a great system with alot of good franchises coming to it. MGS4, DMC4, FF13, god of war 3(i hate it, but others love it), socom, gran turismo.. i might get all 3 systems this gen. thats the only way IMO that you dont miss out on great games. jg4xchamp

[QUOTE="Idonomeus"]

This is a cut and paste but I think it's still up to date. I will check to make sure and edit it if needed...

360: 2 AAA and 11 AA titles. 5 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (8.8 )

Kameo (8.7)

DOA 4 (8.8 )

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Burnout Revenge (8.8 )

Ridge Racer 6 (8.1)

Condenmed (8.0)

FNR 3 (8.3)

NBA 2K6 (8.3)

King Kong (8.2)

NFS: MW (8.4)

PS3: 11 AA games. 2 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

Ridge Racer 7 (8.0)

NHL 2K7 (8.3)

FNR 3 (8.2)

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (8.2)

NBA 2K7 (8.2)

Tiger Woods (8.2)

COD 3 (8.2)

NBA Street Homecourt (8.0)

Def Jam: Icon (8.1)

Norg

Take this list minus the lameness and it looks about like this

360: 2 AAA and 3 AA titles. 3 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Kameo (8.7)

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Condenmed (8.0)

PS3: 3 AA games. 1 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

COD 3 (8.2)

GRAW doesnt really count since if the PS3 was out at the time, it would have gone to PS3. Call of duty is last gen, so i wont bother talkin about that but same with GRAW, if the PS3 was out at the time it would have been on PS3 as well.

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]he means 360. not the first one. cause personally atleast the xbox one had halo to start of with. 360 did have a AAA in perfect dark zero. im sorry its your opinion that resistance is better. but if we just go on ratings then yeah PDZ is better (its system wars, we are only aloud to argue with gamespot reviews, personally i use gamerankings, so really resistance is way better than PDZ). 360 also had call of duty 2, dead or alive 4, and kameo. also by the end of march 360 had oblivion. which is a really good game for people who like rpgs. so the 360 lineup for the first 4 months was a little better than PS3s. in my opinion. personally i dont want a PS3 anytime soon(atleast not until MGS4). but if u want it, its a great system with alot of good franchises coming to it. MGS4, DMC4, FF13, god of war 3(i hate it, but others love it), socom, gran turismo.. i might get all 3 systems this gen. thats the only way IMO that you dont miss out on great games. Felix_120192

That's funny because I have been playing HD shooters for years on PC :|

[QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]he means 360. not the first one. cause personally atleast the xbox one had halo to start of with. 360 did have a AAA in perfect dark zero. im sorry its your opinion that resistance is better. but if we just go on ratings then yeah PDZ is better (its system wars, we are only aloud to argue with gamespot reviews, personally i use gamerankings, so really resistance is way better than PDZ). 360 also had call of duty 2, dead or alive 4, and kameo. also by the end of march 360 had oblivion. which is a really good game for people who like rpgs. so the 360 lineup for the first 4 months was a little better than PS3s. in my opinion. personally i dont want a PS3 anytime soon(atleast not until MGS4). but if u want it, its a great system with alot of good franchises coming to it. MGS4, DMC4, FF13, god of war 3(i hate it, but others love it), socom, gran turismo.. i might get all 3 systems this gen. thats the only way IMO that you dont miss out on great games. Idonomeus

That's funny because I have been playing HD shooters for years on PC :|

[QUOTE="Norg"][QUOTE="Idonomeus"]

This is a cut and paste but I think it's still up to date. I will check to make sure and edit it if needed...

360: 2 AAA and 11 AA titles. 5 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (8.8 )

Kameo (8.7)

DOA 4 (8.8 )

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Burnout Revenge (8.8 )

Ridge Racer 6 (8.1)

Condenmed (8.0)

FNR 3 (8.3)

NBA 2K6 (8.3)

King Kong (8.2)

NFS: MW (8.4)

PS3: 11 AA games. 2 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

Ridge Racer 7 (8.0)

NHL 2K7 (8.3)

FNR 3 (8.2)

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (8.2)

NBA 2K7 (8.2)

Tiger Woods (8.2)

COD 3 (8.2)

NBA Street Homecourt (8.0)

Def Jam: Icon (8.1)

Felix_120192

Take this list minus the lameness and it looks about like this

360: 2 AAA and 3 AA titles. 3 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Kameo (8.7)

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Condenmed (8.0)

PS3: 3 AA games. 1 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

COD 3 (8.2)

GRAW doesnt really count since if the PS3 was out at the time, it would have gone to PS3. Call of duty is last gen, so i wont bother talkin about that but same with GRAW, if the PS3 was out at the time it would have been on PS3 as well.

That is a list of all the AA and AAA games on Gamespot in the given time period. So if you want to take anything out because of your opinion that's too bad because we go by Gamespot scores here. Those are the rules. Also GRAW is not listed as an exclusive because it is on PC. The exclusives are PGR3, PDZ, DOA 4, RR6 and Kameo.

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!Felix_120192

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

[QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1

i dont get you... :?
Felix_120192

I dont get how a topic about which console has better games after 4 months turned  into a technical argument...

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!Felix_120192

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

[QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!Felix_120192

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

[QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!Felix_120192

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P

By this point, we already had PGR3, Call of Duty 2, Ghost Recon, and Oblivion. Motorstorm stacks up well against PGR3, and Resistance is sort of comparable with Call of Duty 2, but nothing on PS3 is as good as Ghost Recon or Oblivion. Oblivion is arriving at roughly the same point in the PS3's life as it did in the 360's, but where's Ghost Recon 2 on PS3?lowe0

[QUOTE="Idonomeus"]

This is a cut and paste but I think it's still up to date. I will check to make sure and edit it if needed...

360: 2 AAA and 11 AA titles. 5 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (8.8 )

Kameo (8.7)

DOA 4 (8.8 )

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Burnout Revenge (8.8 )

Ridge Racer 6 (8.1)

Condenmed (8.0)

FNR 3 (8.3)

NBA 2K6 (8.3)

King Kong (8.2)

NFS: MW (8.4)

PS3: 11 AA games. 2 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

Ridge Racer 7 (8.0)

NHL 2K7 (8.3)

FNR 3 (8.2)

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (8.2)

NBA 2K7 (8.2)

Tiger Woods (8.2)

COD 3 (8.2)

NBA Street Homecourt (8.0)

Def Jam: Icon (8.1)

Norg

Take this list minus the lameness and it looks about like this

360: 2 AAA and 3 AA titles. 3 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Kameo (8.7)

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Condenmed (8.0)

PS3: 3 AA games. 1 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

COD 3 (8.2)

[QUOTE="lowe0"]By this point, we already had PGR3, Call of Duty 2, Ghost Recon, and Oblivion. Motorstorm stacks up well against PGR3, and Resistance is sort of comparable with Call of Duty 2, but nothing on PS3 is as good as Ghost Recon or Oblivion. Oblivion is arriving at roughly the same point in the PS3's life as it did in the 360's, but where's Ghost Recon 2 on PS3?Felix_120192

This is a cut and paste but I think it's still up to date. I will check to make sure and edit it if needed...

360: 2 AAA and 11 AA titles. 5 exclusives.

GRAW (9.2)

Project Gotham Racing 3 (8.8 )

Kameo (8.7)

DOA 4 (8.8 )

PDZ (9.0)

COD 2 (8.8 )

Burnout Revenge (8.8 )

Ridge Racer 6 (8.1)

Condenmed (8.0)

FNR 3 (8.3)

NBA 2K6 (8.3)

King Kong (8.2)

NFS: MW (8.4)

PS3: 11 AA games. 2 exclusives.

Resistance (8.6)

Virtua Fighter 5 (8.1)

Ridge Racer 7 (8.0)

NHL 2K7 (8.3)

FNR 3 (8.2)

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (8.2)

NBA 2K7 (8.2)

Tiger Woods (8.2)

COD 3 (8.2)

NBA Street Homecourt (8.0)

Def Jam: Icon (8.1)

Idonomeus

[QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!daveg1

read my first post.

[QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="Felix_120192"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"][QUOTE="daveg1"][QUOTE="BloodTorment1"]

[QUOTE="daveg1"]xbox was the first console for ms and the ps3 is the third so this is a no brainer to anyone with a shred of inteligence!Felix_120192

How did you go to last gen to next gen??? Keep it in the same timline, 360 is the 2nd console for ms, ps3 third for sony.

lol sorry I see it now. I thought you were a rabid fanboy for a second:P