The Witcher 2.... not that Great...?

[QUOTE="Cloud567kar"]

Personally I liked the combat.

SapSacPrime

Some people just have trouble dealing with it.

I can waste time prowling random reviews for qoutes too...but I don't think I care about this discussion or what reviewers like Jim Sterling have to say.

GeneralShowzer

[QUOTE="Moriarity_"][QUOTE="millerlight89"]Yea the locations are nice to look at, but boring other wise. What really killed it for me was the completely TERRIBLE 3rd act. I mean absolutely dreadful that act is. Nothing to do, nothing to see, it's short and the final boss battle if you so choose to do is a complete letdown. Let's not forget the ending and how pitiful that is. It's a good game and I wouldn't bag on this game so much if it didn't disappointment oh so much.FelipeInside

I liked everything about TW2 :roll:

Awesome game and definitely the best RPG this genereation.

The combat is awesome and looks to be even better with Tomorrow's patch.

Guess RPG gamers prefer the slow, dice-based combat.

The combat is awesome and looks to be even better with Tomorrow's patch.

Guess RPG gamers prefer the slow, dice-based combat.

Theguy56

The combat is awesome and looks to be even better with Tomorrow's patch.

Guess RPG gamers prefer the slow, dice-based combat.

Theguy56

[QUOTE="Theguy56"]

The combat is awesome and looks to be even better with Tomorrow's patch.

Guess RPG gamers prefer the slow, dice-based combat.

Inconsistancy

[QUOTE="Theguy56"]

The combat is awesome and looks to be even better with Tomorrow's patch.

Guess RPG gamers prefer the slow, dice-based combat.

KalDurenik

Cosign, usually I like slower tactical combat more then action combat for my rpgs but man I really do enjoy Witcher2's combat. Cant wait to see how its improved in 2.0 also.

Well I can say I agree with you on some of those points and noticed them too but imo those ones are minor issues that don't detract it from being a great game like you say.

I am surprised though of all those points you didn't mention the targeting system.

I don't think there is anything wrong with points you raised, its nice to see an honest opinion of a game even if it differs from someone else who doesn't agree with them. You can like a game but still able to spot its flaws. I'd rather take this than a completely one sided view like a game being completely terrible with no redeeming qualities or being the best game ever with no issues at all.

[QUOTE="GeneralShowzer"]

Some people just have trouble dealing with it.

I can waste time prowling random reviews for qoutes too...but I don't think I care about this discussion or what reviewers like Jim Sterling have to say.

cfstar

You bumped the thread for this? Go to bed Skyward.

Besides I'm not the one that started laughing at other peoples oppinions. Played all the noteworthy ones (PC and Console) and I think it's the best RPG this gen ( For me)

Dealdo with it.

while the story and quests so far are great, the controls, combat and menus have really turned me off, I've tried with a keyboard and controller, but it still seems wierd. perhaps I'll gve it another try after a few more patches or the console release.

clunky to the extreme.

while the story and quests so far are great, the controls, combat and menus have really turned me off, I've tried with a keyboard and controller, but it still seems wierd. perhaps I'll gve it another try after a few more patches or the console release.

clunky to the extreme.

BlackDevil99

[QUOTE="BlackDevil99"]

while the story and quests so far are great, the controls, combat and menus have really turned me off, I've tried with a keyboard and controller, but it still seems wierd. perhaps I'll gve it another try after a few more patches or the console release.

clunky to the extreme.

Advid-Gamer

[QUOTE="Advid-Gamer"][QUOTE="BlackDevil99"]

while the story and quests so far are great, the controls, combat and menus have really turned me off, I've tried with a keyboard and controller, but it still seems wierd. perhaps I'll gve it another try after a few more patches or the console release.

clunky to the extreme.

Theguy56

[QUOTE="BlackDevil99"]

while the story and quests so far are great, the controls, combat and menus have really turned me off, I've tried with a keyboard and controller, but it still seems wierd. perhaps I'll gve it another try after a few more patches or the console release.

clunky to the extreme.

Advid-Gamer

I haven't gotten that far, so can't coment

[QUOTE="Theguy56"][QUOTE="Advid-Gamer"] I actually think the story fell off after the 2nd chapter, and seemed to start a whole new story with the kings curse crap, I lost interest at that point and have never finished the game. Seems to be no more of a rpg then ME2, which gets bashed here all the time by everyone, at least it had fantastic gameplay, playing as a Vanguard was awesome and very fun, cant say the same for the witchers combat, it wasnt bad, just not that funAdvid-Gamer

Also, I don't really see ME2 being hated here.