@mrbojangles25 said:
@MirkoS77 said:
Ugh, not earned. IT 2 was awful, I ended up walking out.
Wow, that bad!?
And IT part 1 was so good, too.
What was so terrible about it?
I wrote a review on IMDB about it, I'll just repost it here. Kind of long:
"Look, I don't mind being entertained at the movies, but there does come the expectation with such an adaptation of one of the best and most beloved horror novels ever written that it accord some respect while remaining true to the source material.
Frankly, I don't think I've ever seen a film that's so tonally inconsistent as I have here. I could never tell if it was attempting to set a somber, threatening, foreboding feeling, or create an atmosphere conducive towards a lighthearted, hilarious jump-scare filled marathon. In one moment it hangs heavy in emotional gravitas (the opening scene is especially brutal and difficult to watch, and Stanley's suicide is also fairly dark), and the next, it's so ludicrously over the top and in your face in its execution of its so-called "horror" elements that it produces a jarring sense of extreme tonal discord. What exactly is this film attempting to accomplish? The horror was so absurdly comedic both in explicitness and execution (not helped by questionable effects work) that I'm forced to assume that was the intent. Yet in taking such an approach, it effectively nullified the entire foundation that the movie required to establish and help foment the dreadful tension, atmosphere, and tone necessitated by the narrative (and of which the book was so dependent on and made it so stellar), and further relegated all the work by the actors and all other aspects of the film that had helped establish it up to that point void. If it wasn't intentional, then it does nothing so well as to demonstrate how the filmmakers hold a fundamental misunderstanding of what true horror really entails.
"IT Chapter Two" spends much of its time going through a brainless, by the numbers checklist of the characters recovering their artifacts from their youths, to the same tired, brainless, by the numbers predictable jump scares thrown at you one after the other which you can see coming from a million miles off, which further robbed them of all their potency. I literally fell asleep at one point. How am I supposed to care at all about the protagonists' plight when their antagonist and its supposedly evil forms are stripped of all of their malevolence and are instead displayed in such a formulaic, repetitive, explicit, and laughable manner? I know "IT" manifests itself also as a clown, but that doesn't mean Pennywise (and the fear tactics he used on his victims) weren't terrifying. They were in the novel, and here they're not in the slightest. A little subtlety, suggestion, imagination, minimalism and unpredictability goes a long way and would've done this film wonders, as that's where the real core of any effective horror resides. It would've not only have helped maintain tonal consistency, it would've made it genuinely unsettling. Less is more. My theatre was howling in laughter at every turn, and I'm completely left at a loss as to whether that was what the director intended.
This film was boring, inconsistent, predictable, ludicrously (and unintentionally?) hilarious, overly drawn out, and a downright insult to King, who I'm shocked made the cameo he did in tacit approval of this screen adaptation abomination of his finest work. The abysmal execution robbed me of all interest in witnessing The Losers' Club finally confront this ultimate evil terrorizing a small Maine town every 27 years, because in the end, it wasn't an ultimate evil at all......it was a goddamn mockery of one.
And as such, I walked out. Truly, truly awful."
That's essentially my problem with it. I didn't feel it knew what type of film it really wanted to be, and due to that, it invalidated each that it tried to be. At points it tried to play serious, and at all others it was stupidly absurd. This was present in the first film, but not as much. You can't have it both ways....either make it a comedy like Army Of Darkness, or make it a horror, like King intended it. You try to please everyone, and you please no one.
/rant.
Log in to comment