This topic is locked from further discussion.
[QUOTE="Philokalia"]- Mary did not consort with God, despite what the quran might tell you.worlock77
Pretty sure the Qur'an does not claim anything of the sort.
This and us muslims hold her as one of the most blessed women to walk the earth and there is even an entire chapter in the quran named after her so stop believing nonsense on the internet designed to spread hatred.[QUOTE="GummiRaccoon"]I said he's not too far off, but noted he wasn't correct. Also given the way Catholics believe saints and martyrs work asking them for a favor is essentially a prayer. Look up intercession. Not to mention Prayer is in effect asking something for a favour. Prayer can be done for many reasons.....it is after all just a communication. Nonetheless Catholics don't worship saints nor Mary. They hold them as holy people and ask for help. He was totally wrong....They are using fluttery speech to ask mary for a favor.
Ace6301
Worship/ Extreme adoration of Mary is heretical. Mary was just an ordinary woman and unlike Jesus she was not sinless. Furthermore, praying to or through Mary is pointless because she is dead (i.e. she does not exist). Until the Day of Judgment when everyone who has lived is resurrected, she will remain dead. That's that.
You really need to 1...understand the religions in questions and 2....learn what heresy is. Thus far you use it improperly. We get it...you hate religion. Learn some tolerance and quite being a tool about it.Worship/ Extreme adoration of Mary is heretical. Mary was just an ordinary woman and unlike Jesus she was not sinless. Furthermore, praying to or through Mary is pointless because she is dead (i.e. she does not exist). Until the Day of Judgment when everyone who has lived is resurrected, she will remain dead. That's that.
BluRayHiDef
You as well need to educate yourself first......It is a Catholic teaching, not biblical. As I've stated in another post, the Catholic Church, promotes all sorts of things that are not biblical, hence the issue with the Catholic Church and the negative outlook on Christianity in general.
lowkey254
[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]You really need to 1...understand the religions in questions and 2....learn what heresy is. Thus far you use it improperly. We get it...you hate religion. Learn some tolerance and quite being a tool about it.Worship/ Extreme adoration of Mary is heretical. Mary was just an ordinary woman and unlike Jesus she was not sinless. Furthermore, praying to or through Mary is pointless because she is dead (i.e. she does not exist). Until the Day of Judgment when everyone who has lived is resurrected, she will remain dead. That's that.
LJS9502_basic
I hate only false religion. The true religion is that of the Bible.
[QUOTE="lowkey254"]You as well need to educate yourself first......It is a Catholic teaching, not biblical. As I've stated in another post, the Catholic Church, promotes all sorts of things that are not biblical, hence the issue with the Catholic Church and the negative outlook on Christianity in general.
LJS9502_basic
He speaks the truth.
You really need to 1...understand the religions in questions and 2....learn what heresy is. Thus far you use it improperly. We get it...you hate religion. Learn some tolerance and quite being a tool about it.[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]
Worship/ Extreme adoration of Mary is heretical. Mary was just an ordinary woman and unlike Jesus she was not sinless. Furthermore, praying to or through Mary is pointless because she is dead (i.e. she does not exist). Until the Day of Judgment when everyone who has lived is resurrected, she will remain dead. That's that.
BluRayHiDef
I hate only false religion. The true religion is that of the Bible.
Considering the text chosen to be put in the Bible came from organized religion....that seems rather a silly statement.You as well need to educate yourself first......[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="lowkey254"]
It is a Catholic teaching, not biblical. As I've stated in another post, the Catholic Church, promotes all sorts of things that are not biblical, hence the issue with the Catholic Church and the negative outlook on Christianity in general.
BluRayHiDef
He speaks the truth.
Considering he's ignorant of Catholic teachings seems rather foolish to hold him up as an authority and more like you just want someone to side with your ignorance and intolerance.[QUOTE="ferrari2001"]I don't know of any religion that worships Mary. Catholics honor Mary for being the mother of God, and one role model to which we can model our lives but they certainly don't worship her. tenaka2
Hail Mary, full of grace.
The Lord is with thee.
Blessed art thou amongst women,
and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus.
Holy Mary, Mother of God,
pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our death.
Amen.
We had to pray to Mary a lot, are you sure that isn't worship?
You said the words yet you don't even know what they're saying.[QUOTE="tenaka2"][QUOTE="ferrari2001"]I don't know of any religion that worships Mary. Catholics honor Mary for being the mother of God, and one role model to which we can model our lives but they certainly don't worship her. Chutebox
Hail Mary, full of grace.
The Lord is with thee.
Blessed art thou amongst women,
and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus.
Holy Mary, Mother of God,
pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our death.
Amen.
We had to pray to Mary a lot, are you sure that isn't worship?
You said the words yet you don't even know what they're saying. There's a lot of that going around when ever the Catholic Church gets mentioned....[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="tenaka2"]You said the words yet you don't even know what they're saying. There's a lot of that going around when ever the Catholic Church gets mentioned....Hail Mary, full of grace.
The Lord is with thee.
Blessed art thou amongst women,
and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus.
Holy Mary, Mother of God,
pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our death.
Amen.
We had to pray to Mary a lot, are you sure that isn't worship?
LJS9502_basic
I am just saying it was a very common prayer in Ireland, pretty big on Mary there, I never thought to think about it but prayer seemed like worship to me.
There's a lot of that going around when ever the Catholic Church gets mentioned....[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="Chutebox"] You said the words yet you don't even know what they're saying.tenaka2
I am just saying it was a very common prayer in Ireland, pretty big on Mary there, I never thought to think about it but prayer seemed like worship to me.
Oh well it's not. She is considered an important person what with being the Mother of God and all...yes Jesus is God....and it's basically just a prayer asking for her intercession or her prayers to God as it were. Catholics certainly don't worship her. Several Catholics have answered this question in this thread....and I'd think that should be enough. I realize not everyone is knowledgeable but they need not continue to believe the skewed view that is presented about Catholics..no?Do people actually think the term Theotokos (Mother of God) attributes divinity unto Mary? And if asking intercession of Mary makes her God does that then make all the saints God?
People don't understand Catholics at all. I've been called a cannibal and a vampire. Also told I worship Mary etc etc. It's odd how comfortable people are with being sheep and not looking into things for themselves.Do people actually think the term Theotokos (Mother of God) attributes divinity unto Mary? And if asking intercession of Mary makes her God does that then make all the saints God?
Philokalia
People don't understand Catholics at all. I've been called a cannibal and a vampire. Also told I worship Mary etc etc. It's odd how comfortable people are with being sheep and not looking into things for themselves.LJS9502_basic
Ah fundamentalists. I am curious as to why the atheists are siding with them in this argument despite not knowing anything or little about the topic.
[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"] People don't understand Catholics at all. I've been called a cannibal and a vampire. Also told I worship Mary etc etc. It's odd how comfortable people are with being sheep and not looking into things for themselves.Philokalia
Ah fundamentalists. I am curious as to why the atheists are siding with them in this argument despite not knowing anything or little about the topic.
Religion is the last thing you can be intolerant about and spew hate.[QUOTE="Philokalia"]People don't understand Catholics at all. I've been called a cannibal and a vampire. Also told I worship Mary etc etc. It's odd how comfortable people are with being sheep and not looking into things for themselves.Do people actually think the term Theotokos (Mother of God) attributes divinity unto Mary? And if asking intercession of Mary makes her God does that then make all the saints God?
LJS9502_basic
I am no longer religious but when I was Catholic I heard very similar things from the Protestants at my high school, they made fun of us so much for "worshipping" Mary as well. It's strange how people can call themselves Christians without knowing any of the actual differences between the different subsects of Christianity
People don't understand Catholics at all. I've been called a cannibal and a vampire. Also told I worship Mary etc etc. It's odd how comfortable people are with being sheep and not looking into things for themselves.[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="Philokalia"]
Do people actually think the term Theotokos (Mother of God) attributes divinity unto Mary? And if asking intercession of Mary makes her God does that then make all the saints God?
Bane_09
I am no longer religious but when I was Catholic I heard very similar things from the Protestants at my high school, they made fun of us so much for "worshipping" Mary as well. It's strange how people can call themselves Christians without knowing any of the actual differences between the different subsects of Christianity
Most differences aren't major. I find them interesting nonetheless...and I'd not put down their beliefs because they aren't exactly mine. Odd how ignorant people can still be in 2012 though....Most differences aren't major. I find them interesting nonetheless...and I'd not put down their beliefs because they aren't exactly mine. Odd how ignorant people can still be in 2012 though....LJS9502_basic
Yes, studying religion can be very interesting. I just always thought it was basic stuff that most people would have learned in sunday school but maybe they don't do that anymore
[QUOTE="Ace6301"][QUOTE="GummiRaccoon"]I said he's not too far off, but noted he wasn't correct. Also given the way Catholics believe saints and martyrs work asking them for a favor is essentially a prayer. Look up intercession. Not to mention Prayer is in effect asking something for a favour. Prayer can be done for many reasons.....it is after all just a communication. Nonetheless Catholics don't worship saints nor Mary. They hold them as holy people and ask for help. He was totally wrong.... He said that they give prayer to Mary. They do. You even admit that. He was not totally wrong, he was wrong in parts and which parts I pointed out. I myself never said they worship Mary. The only time I even mentioned worship was jokingly when someone said a Hail Mary was comparable to hailing a taxi. If you want to get upset over a joke then by all means be my guest.They are using fluttery speech to ask mary for a favor.
LJS9502_basic
According to Catholic belief, Mary ascended into Heaven alive.Worship/ Extreme adoration of Mary is heretical. Mary was just an ordinary woman and unlike Jesus she was not sinless. Furthermore, praying to or through Mary is pointless because she is dead (i.e. she does not exist). Until the Day of Judgment when everyone who has lived is resurrected, she will remain dead. That's that.
BluRayHiDef
Where in the Bible says Christians to worship Mary ? Isn't it a heretic teaching ?
jackfruitchips
my observation is if you hold still for a few mins those dudes will worship you.
there is an entire plethora of demi gods that are in charge of different shyt.
lets say you are a gardener with an std.
then st. fiacre has your back.
want your fireworks display to go well? then pray to st. barbara.
don't know who to pray to?
then pray to this dog.
monotheism is for suckers.;)
Please educate yourself before spouting this. We do not worship her or pray to her. Never. And there is Holy Mass on Saturday's too (evening). I think there is Mass on weekdays as well and pretty much everyday except for Good Friday and Holy Saturday. Yes there is mass on weekdays, I go everyday. In fact it is necessary for a priest to say mass everyday.[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="jackfruitchips"] Yes they name a lot of churches after her, they say paryers to her, they have hymns to praise her, they worship her on Saturdays (Sndays are for God and Jesus, they even have 1 month each year (May) to worship her ... whipassmt
[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]According to Catholic belief, Mary ascended into Heaven alive. Actually alive or dead is not stated in any doctrine. The belief simply states that she was assumed into heaven body and soul. She could have been dead or alive, it isn't stated either way.Worship/ Extreme adoration of Mary is heretical. Mary was just an ordinary woman and unlike Jesus she was not sinless. Furthermore, praying to or through Mary is pointless because she is dead (i.e. she does not exist). Until the Day of Judgment when everyone who has lived is resurrected, she will remain dead. That's that.
harashawn
[QUOTE="ferrari2001"]I don't know of any religion that worships Mary. Catholics honor Mary for being the mother of God, and one role model to which we can model our lives but they certainly don't worship her. Bane_09
This^
It's a fairly basic teaching and most people should know this with a simple google search
I WAS a Catholic. I know that Catholics say they don't worship Mary, they just honor, devote or venerate her but in my view that's just a lie. They worship Mary.[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"]they even have 1 month each year (May) to worship her ... worlock77
No. The month of May is named after Maia, a Greek/Roman fertility goddess, not after Mary.
You misundertood. I didn't say May is named after Mary. May is dedicated to Mary in the Catholicism. http://www.catholicculture.org/culture/liturgicalyear/overviews/months/05_1.cfm[QUOTE="Bane_09"][QUOTE="ferrari2001"]I don't know of any religion that worships Mary. Catholics honor Mary for being the mother of God, and one role model to which we can model our lives but they certainly don't worship her. jackfruitchips
This^
It's a fairly basic teaching and most people should know this with a simple google search
I WAS a Catholic. I know that Catholics say they don't worship Mary, they just honor, devote or venerate her but in my view that's just a lie. They worship Mary. So you didn't understand the premise of Catholicism and made this thread to troll because you're a cool teenaged atheist with a keyboard?[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"][QUOTE="Bane_09"]I WAS a Catholic. I know that Catholics say they don't worship Mary, they just honor, devote or venerate her but in my view that's just a lie. They worship Mary. So you didn't understand the premise of Catholicism and made this thread to troll because you're a cool teenaged atheist with a keyboard? So someone having different view means he didn't understand and troll ? How you know I'm a teenage atheist ? Fail :lol:This^
It's a fairly basic teaching and most people should know this with a simple google search
LJS9502_basic
[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]So you didn't understand the premise of Catholicism and made this thread to troll because you're a cool teenaged atheist with a keyboard?LJS9502_basicSo someone having different view means he didn't understand and troll ? How you know I'm a teenage atheist ? Fail :lol:You didn't share a different view....you flat out lied about a religious tenet. WTF are you talking ? I did stated that Catholics worship Mary via hyms, prayers, rosary, churches named after her, the whole month of May each year is devoted to Mary, Saturdays are dedicated to her ... These are FACTS. I was a devout Catholic, I know catholic doctrines much more than you little kid, I used to defend my faith agianst atheists and Protestants ... so I lol'd at you and other guys who laughed at me since you fools assumes I don't know a sh1t about Catholicism. So I flat lied just because I have a different view from Catholics ? Cool
[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]You didn't share a different view....you flat out lied about a religious tenet.LJS9502_basicWTF are you talking ? I did stated that Catholics worship Mary via hyms, prayers, rosary, churches named after her, the whole month of May each year is devoted to Mary, Saturdays are dedicated to her ... These are FACTS. I was a devout Catholic, I know catholic doctrines much more than you little kid, I used to defend my faith agianst atheists and Protestants ... so I lol'd at you and other guys who laughed at me since you fools assumes I don't know a sh1t about Catholicism. So I flat lied just because I have a different view from Catholics ? CoolCatholics don't worship Mary. It's that simple. Little kid?:lol: I was a practicing Catholic while you were still wetting your pants junior. Yeah Catholics don't worship Mary because that's what the Catholic Church tell you right ? You kid like other Catholics are brainwashed by Catholic Church and you're uable to think for yourself.
[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="jackfruitchips"] WTF are you talking ? I did stated that Catholics worship Mary via hyms, prayers, rosary, churches named after her, the whole month of May each year is devoted to Mary, Saturdays are dedicated to her ... These are FACTS. I was a devout Catholic, I know catholic doctrines much more than you little kid, I used to defend my faith agianst atheists and Protestants ... so I lol'd at you and other guys who laughed at me since you fools assumes I don't know a sh1t about Catholicism. So I flat lied just because I have a different view from Catholics ? CooljackfruitchipsCatholics don't worship Mary. It's that simple. Little kid?:lol: I was a practicing Catholic while you were still wetting your pants junior. Yeah Catholics don't worship Mary because that's what the Catholic Church tell you right ? You kid like other Catholics are brainwashed by Catholic Church and you're uable to think for yourself. I know we don't worship her because 1....we haven't been told to do so and 2...I know I don't. But hey if your insecurities must manifest themselves by bashing the faith of others who am I to stop you. But don't expect me to take you seriously when you spout untruths......
troll thread
Yeah Catholics don't worship Mary because that's what the Catholic Church tell you right ? You kid like other Catholics are brainwashed by Catholic Church and you're uable to think for yourself. I know we don't worship her because 1....we haven't been told to do so and 2...I know I don't. But hey if your insecurities must manifest themselves by bashing the faith of others who am I to stop you. But don't expect me to take you seriously when you spout untruths......[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Catholics don't worship Mary. It's that simple. Little kid?:lol: I was a practicing Catholic while you were still wetting your pants junior.LJS9502_basic
troll thread
You think you don't worship her because you haven't been to do so. Right. Because the Catholic Church tells you it's just veneration, not worship. And you believe whatever she says. It's like a father tell his son to steal, and say it's not stealing, it's just borrowing and the son thinks it's actually not stealing. :lol: Oh, sharing a different view means bashing other faith and it's a troll thread ? So every religions thread in OT is troll thread right ? Tbh, who give a f*** if you don't take me seriously ? GTFOI know we don't worship her because 1....we haven't been told to do so and 2...I know I don't. But hey if your insecurities must manifest themselves by bashing the faith of others who am I to stop you. But don't expect me to take you seriously when you spout untruths......[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]
[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"] Yeah Catholics don't worship Mary because that's what the Catholic Church tell you right ? You kid like other Catholics are brainwashed by Catholic Church and you're uable to think for yourself.jackfruitchips
troll thread
You think you don't worship her because you haven't been to do so. Right. Because the Catholic Church tells you it's just veneration, not worship. And you believe whatever she says. It's like a father tell his son to steal, and say it's not stealing, it's just borrowing and the son thinks it's actually not stealing. :lol: Oh, sharing a different view mean bashing other faith and it's a troll thread ? So every religions thread in OT is troll thread right ? Tbh, who give a f*** if you don't take me seriously ? GTFO You are totally clueless....troll elsewhere.Yeah Catholics don't worship Mary because that's what the Catholic Church tell you right ? You kid like other Catholics are brainwashed by Catholic Church and you're uable to think for yourself. I know we don't worship her because 1....we haven't been told to do so and 2...I know I don't. But hey if your insecurities must manifest themselves by bashing the faith of others who am I to stop you. But don't expect me to take you seriously when you spout untruths......[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Catholics don't worship Mary. It's that simple. Little kid?:lol: I was a practicing Catholic while you were still wetting your pants junior.LJS9502_basic
troll thread
According to this it is quite common for Catholics to worship Saints.
http://www.albatrus.org/english/religions/pagan/italy_pagan_country.htm
[QUOTE="jackfruitchips"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]You didn't share a different view....you flat out lied about a religious tenet.thegergWTF are you talking ? I did stated that Catholics worship Mary via hyms, prayers, rosary, churches named after her, the whole month of May each year is devoted to Mary, Saturdays are dedicated to her ... These are FACTS. I was a devout Catholic, I know catholic doctrines much more than you little kid, I used to defend my faith agianst atheists and Protestants ... so I lol'd at you and other guys who laughed at me since you fools assumes I don't know a sh1t about Catholicism. So I flat lied just because I have a different view from Catholics ? Cool This man is telling you that he doesn't worship Mary, and you're trying to tell him that he does? What kind of idiotic argument are you trying to make? I showed some of the reasons why I think they worship, not venerate Mary. How is that idiotic argument ?
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment