Ocarina of Time, Majora's Mask, The Wind Waker, Phantom Hourglass, or Twilight?

I'm sorry but i dont see how this is even a vote, ocarina of time is by far the best zelda game of all time. Revolutionary, epic and compelling. nothing can compare.bluntmastaslaya

1. ocarina of time

2. The Wind Waker

3. Twilight Princess

4. Phantom Hour Glass

5. Majoras Mask.......(ugh)

Ocarina of Time - Completely epic.

Majora's Mask - Not as good as the above, but a lot of extra missions that I just LOVED (Fierce Diety, anyone?)

Wind Waker - Wonderful art style, a bit easy, and boring near the end, but I had a lot of fun with this game. Also, the way Hyrule is depicted is truely awesome.

Twilight Princess - Didn't live up to hype, was dull for the most part.

Phantom Hourglass - The controls were fantastic, but the dungeons were repetitive.

Out of those games, Ocarina of Time (although I haven't gotten around to playing my copy of Twilight Princess, and I haven't touched PH or WW).

But I think Link to the Past is the best Zelda game to date, OoT follows closely though.

Ocarina of Time hands down. Though I haven't played Phantom Hourglass, but I doubt its better than Oot.

1. Ocarina Of Time (10)

2. Wind Waker (9.6)

3. Majora's Mask (9.4)

4. Twilight Princess (9)

5. Phantom Hourglass (8.3)

1. Ocarina of Time

2. Twilight Princess

3. Wind Waker

4. Majora's Mask

5. Phantom Hourglass (only because I haven't played it)

Now, if Nintendo would make Ocarina of Time for the Wii with Twilight Princess graphics, we would have a better Zelda. Of course Nintendo would also need to put in better physics and mechanics, along with better sounds and cinematics, but if Ocarina of Time was totally revamped, that to me would be the best Zelda to date.

Voted Ocarina of Time, even though I was stuck for a long frickin time in the water part... stuck so long that I still wake up in the middle of the night sometimes hearing that dang music. Anyone else get the forest melody popping into their head randomly too? or the suns song? I haven't played Phantom Hourglass, and actually just bought an old copy of Wind Waker which I'm currently playing through... so far I'm enjoying it, trying not to forget where I'm at while I rock Brawl. Never got to try Majora's Mask either... honestly though A Link To The Past on SNES was the best Zelda so far in my opinion.Mack2D2

OMG! That Water Temple was the only one I spent running around frustrated looking for a key. They put it at the bottom of the tower in the middle of the temple. I'll never forget it.

There are 2 types of action/adventure games. Games that ARE OoT, and games that aren't.

Majora's Mask and Wind Waker are, in my opinion, the best Zelda games out there. Both Ocarina of Time and Twilight Princess are great games, but they're so Zelda-ish. It's like you can guess what's going to happen next or which temple lies ahead. Majora's Mask and Wind Waker are also very unique -- MM with it's time and WW with it's ocean, I just love them. =)OniStrat

I agree, this is why those two are my favorites as well. I also really like the art design in WW.

ive never played majoras mask...how does it compare with OoT?BeanTownBrown86

they are very different games. MM deals with time (as in you have 3 days to save the world, but everyone in the world has a set time schedule and it starts over when you go back to the first day) whereas OoT doesnt. Its hard to compare them really. But MM has been criticized for straying away form the zelda formula whereas its praise coes from the same place

this is a tought one for me as i have really enjoyed every Zelda game i've played

never got to pick up WW but as far as the others go its close VERY close

i guess it would have to be OOT since it's the first Zelda game i picked up and was amazing start to finish as was MM and TP so i guess

OOT wins just because of the fond memories attached to it

and for those of you on the fence about TP or MM i enjoyed them both just as much TP's finall fight with Ganondorf was remarkably fun i guess owning TP on the Wii made it that way

and with MM i enjoyed all the mask collecting it provided a nice challange that was far more enjoyable than teidous in my opinion

so now ill probably put down my SSBB (no ones online =/), dust off my N64 and start OOT over and maybe even MM afterwards

I couldn't fit Twilight Princess in.

So, out of these five Zelda games, (The 3D ones.) which one is your favorite? Mine goes like this:

1. Twilight Princess (9.9)

2. Majora's Mask (9.6)

3. Ocarina of Time (9.4)

4. The Wind Waker (9.3)

5. Phantom Hourglass (9.2)

The two Cel-shaded Zelda games could've been so much better if they took away the tedious sailing aspect. Overall, all five of these titles are AAA to me, and I love each and every one of them.

DeathScape666

I have been educated to respect other people opinions but wtf are u joking how can a game almost 100% copied from another be better than the original, TP is a joke it hasn't made any changes on the formula but the transformation to a wolf and let's face it the worst part of the game was that, and link lacks any kind of emotions he is a robot the only thing he does is opening his eyes in surprice coping what he did on OoT

when the crowd start to get bored they do a few minor changes to make them happy and then when the realise the changes suck the go back to the original formula and the people are happy again

My list:

1. Ocarina of Time
2. Wind Waker
3. Twilight Princess
4. Majora's Mask
5. Phantom Hourglass

i love all the zelda games, but TP is definetly the best

1. Twilight princess

2.Phantom Hourglass

3. Wind waker

4. Ocarina of time

5.Majoras mask

sorry but I still fancy LOZ: Link to the past(SNES) the best...Death_Masta187

1) Twilight Princess

2) Ocarina Of Time

3) Majora's Mask

4) Wind Waker(never played)

5) Phantom Hourglass(never played)

ehh its not bad but my order would go something like this...

1) TP

2) OOT

3) WW

4) Majora's Mask

5) Phantom Hourglass

I couldn't fit Twilight Princess in.

So, out of these five Zelda games, (The 3D ones.) which one is your favorite? Mine goes like this:

1. Twilight Princess (9.9)

2. Majora's Mask (9.6)

3. Ocarina of Time (9.4)

4. The Wind Waker (9.3)

5. Phantom Hourglass (9.2)

The two Cel-shaded Zelda games could've been so much better if they took away the tedious sailing aspect. Overall, all five of these titles are AAA to me, and I love each and every one of them.

DeathScape666

My order

1. Ocarina of Time

2. Majora's Mask

3.Wind Waker

4. Phantom Hourglass

5. Link to the past

I would put TP in 6th since it does nothing new compared to the other 5 which have had MAJOR game-play changes done to them rather than just graphics. Also TP has the worst Zelda music I have ever heard in a Zelda game. I mean could anyone tell the difference between the wolf songs or even rm the music form the game? The story was also the most predictable. Characters felt like sign posts, none of the characters really stood out either or felt alive. Only improvement seen was graphics and horse combat other than that it's a clone of OOT with easier game-play and boring dungeons. Majora's Mask makes TP look like two steps backwords in the Zelda franchise. Majora's Mask has 4 playable versions of Link(not including the unique powers of the other masks). The unique game-play of controlling time and every npc having their own schedule which made each of them unique.

This is also why TP is the lowest rated Zelda game because it lacks the uniqueness and quality the others had.

1. Ocarina of Time ( great music, gameplay, story)

2. A Link to the Past ( first Zelda game played)

3. Majora's Mask ( Best sidequests in a Zelda game)

4. Wind Waker ( Refreshing new look to Zelda series, graphics were great cell shaded)

5. TP ( Too much sucking up to Ocarina, trying to please everyone, no secrets except heart pieces, bad music, still a great game though.)

6. PH (Fun for a handheld, WW clone)

I think either wind waker or majoras mask were the best. OOT was great dont get me wrong, but it had the most bland/cliche story of all of them and was probably overall the least creative...D-ice3000

[QUOTE="D-ice3000"]I think either wind waker or majoras mask were the best. OOT was great dont get me wrong, but it had the most bland/cliche story of all of them and was probably overall the least creative...PoweredByHonda

im glad i could relaly make you laugh!!

phantom hourglass definatley is the most fun to play. (amazing controls)

but ocarina was just.... amazing.

1. Twilight Princess
2. Wind Waker
3. Ocarina of time
4. Phantom Hourglass

Twilight Princess was my first Zelda and it absolutely blew me away. Incredible game and my second favourite game of all time next to GTA San Andreas. I downloaded Ocarina of Time after I completed TP and it was very disappointing. Its by no means a bad game but going from Twilight Princess to Ocarina of Time made it seem alot worse than it actually is. Plus it being hailed by many as the greatest game of all time made me have high expectations. Its an outstanding game but quite a bit overrated imo. The next Zelda I played was Phantom Hourglass and I loved it. Yes its the worst Zelda game I've played, but at the same time its the most flawless. Its a top down handheld game so its obviously not going to be as good as full 3D adventure games. I only recently finished Wind Waker and I loved it. Much more fun than Ocarina of time but it was lacking in difficulty and lacked quite a few things oot had. It was hard to choose which I preferred out of oot and ww. Since I dont ever really remember being bored with ww unlike oot I put that above it.

1) OOT - because its legendary and truly revolutionary

2) MM - so much fun with the masks

3) TP - it was basically ocarina of time with a new haircut

4) WW - to tedious but fun as hell

5) PH - dont have a ds lol

I think tp or ph is the best tp was actually fun, I played tp before oot and I honestly say that although it was revoulutionary for people who have been playing since the first legend of zelda my first zelda game was wind waker so when I played oot it felt down graded. ph was not as good if it was on a consule but as a handheld it was amazing.

1. tp (oot meets awsome controls and good gameplay) 9.8

2.ph(great for a handheld) 9.6

3.oot 9.6

4.ww 9.0

TP is thye one I enjoyed the most. Probably because I was older and quite a bit better then when I played OoT