Best Sonic game of All time

Simple question what is your favourite Sonic game of all time. Mine is Sonic the Hedgehog 2

Sonic CD for me, preferably with the JP/European soundtrack

Never played Sonic CD but I vote for Sonic 3. To me, it did the Sonic 2 thing of taking everything its predecessor did and making it better in every way imaginable. Up until Sonic Colors it was also the last Sonic game that was better than the one before it.

I still think its Sonic 2 and actually I haven't played it in a couple of years now so I may have to have a shoot through it :).

If it counts... Sonic 3 & Knuckles

If it doesn't count... Sonic 2

Sonic 2, though I never really got the chance to get too involved in Sonic CD. However I'm still going to say Sonic 2 was the best. I feel that after that game, the art direction started to feel very un-sonic like.

Sonic 2 was my favorite. Then Sonic and Knuckles.

for me it's sonic 2, multiplayer game was good, and to control tails (player 2) in one player game great, that fox many times died

Sonic CD for me, preferably with the JP/European soundtrack

Darkman2007

I loved Sonic Adventure for the Dreamcast. Becoming Super Sonic at the end and fighting Chaos's final form was awesome!!!

Sonic 1 for me :D

Sonic CD for me, preferably with the JP/European soundtrack

Darkman2007

[QUOTE="Darkman2007"]

Sonic CD for me, preferably with the JP/European soundtrack

jakandsig

Sonic CD for me, preferably with the JP/European soundtrack

Sonic 3 and Knuckles is the best Sonic game.

Sonic 3 and Knuckles is the best Sonic game.

Seabas989

[QUOTE="Darkman2007"][QUOTE="jakandsig"] Sonic CD with the superior U.S. Soundtrack that actually matches the game.jakandsig

[QUOTE="jakandsig"][QUOTE="Darkman2007"] I disagree, I feel the European soundtrack is better, though the US soundtrack has its merits :PDarkman2007

The original Sonic the Hedgehog for Sega Genesis for me. Mostly because it's the game I got with my Genesis back in the day, so I have the most nostagia attached to it. I played the heck out of that game. That, and I really didn't like the addition of the sidekicks. Definetly bearable considering how great the Genesis sequels were, and you even had the option to take Tails out the game (which a lot of people I know didn't even know about until they saw me do it because they kind of hid the options menu on the title screen of Sonic 2). But still, I thought it was stupid. It just made Sonic lose some of that edginess and go more towards the cutesy side. Which unfortunately, the cutesiness got worse as the years went on. Stupid Chaos.

The original Sonic the Hedgehog for Sega Genesis for me. Mostly because it's the game I got with my Genesis back in the day, so I have the most nostagia attached to it. I played the heck out of that game. That, and I really didn't like the addition of the sidekicks. Definetly bearable considering how great the Genesis sequels were, and you even had the option to take Tails out the game (which a lot of people I know didn't even know about until they saw me do it because they kind of hid the options menu on the title screen of Sonic 2). But still, I thought it was stupid. It just made Sonic lose some of that edginess and go more towards the cutesy side. Which unfortunately, the cutesiness got worse as the years went on. Stupid Chaos.

Emerald_Warrior

I like Sonic 1 for Gen/MD best but I think Sonic 2 is the best.

[QUOTE="Seabas989"]

Sonic 3 and Knuckles is the best Sonic game.

jakandsig

Well those two "inferior: games stiull hold up well on there own against most Sonic games. Only Sonic 2 and maybe Sonic CD are better then those two seperately. However these days you can find the full game in many compilations so I don't see the problem anymore.

Sonic 2 was the best one. It seemed to lose its way after that.

For me i think it was Sonic an Knuckles

Me and my bro got loads of hours clocked for this, too bad we dont play it anymore :\

Tie between Sonic 3 and Sonic Adventure.

Tie between Sonic 3 and Sonic Adventure.

LankyKong

This is hard to decide, but I think that I will go with Sonic CD.

The correct answer is:

Most people would probably choose one of the first 3 Sonic games on the Genesis, but that's only because they have angst against 3D Sonic games and are stuck in the past. Nostalgia gets the best of them. Sonic Adventure on the Dreamcast is the best Sonic game, of every Sonic game I've ever played I had the most fun playing Sonic Adventure.

The correct answer is:

Most people would probably choose one of the first 3 Sonic games on the Genesis, but that's only because they have angst against 3D Sonic games and are stuck in the past. Nostalgia gets the best of them. Sonic Adventure on the Dreamcast is the best Sonic game, of every Sonic game I've ever played I had the most fun playing Sonic Adventure.

GeoffZak

I have no issue with 3D Sonic games (at least not the crappy ones), I actually think Sonic Adventure 1, 2, and Heroes all work really well with the Sonic formula.

[QUOTE="GeoffZak"]

The correct answer is:

Most people would probably choose one of the first 3 Sonic games on the Genesis, but that's only because they have angst against 3D Sonic games and are stuck in the past. Nostalgia gets the best of them. Sonic Adventure on the Dreamcast is the best Sonic game, of every Sonic game I've ever played I had the most fun playing Sonic Adventure.

AcidSoldner

I have no issue with 3D Sonic games (at least not the crappy ones), I actually think Sonic Adventure 1, 2, and Heroes all work really well with the Sonic formula.

I like Sonic Adventure as well, its certainly the best 3D sonic game Ive played.

I thought Sonic Adventure was very average. Even Rayman 2 beat it imo. I also don't agree that Sonic did a good jump into 3D. Sonic Generations is hyped because it will let you play as classic Sonic in 2.5D and that tells something about how successful Sonic's transition into 3D was.

For me, Sonic 3 followed by Sonic Adventure.

Sonic the Hedgehog 2

The correct answer is:

Most people would probably choose one of the first 3 Sonic games on the Genesis, but that's only because they have angst against 3D Sonic games and are stuck in the past. Nostalgia gets the best of them. Sonic Adventure on the Dreamcast is the best Sonic game, of every Sonic game I've ever played I had the most fun playing Sonic Adventure.

GeoffZak

No, it's because those three games actually aged well and are examples of exemplary platforming game design.

Sonic Adventure, on the other hand, was the beginning of the end, bringing in horrible alternative gameplay **** (like the treasure hunting, mech and the fishing), bringing in an overall lack of polish, camera issues, an uneccesary overworld, etc. Sure, it might have seemed great at the time, but time has not been kind to it.

Sonic Adventure 2 Battle, or Sonic Mega Collection.... mainly cause they were all amazing

sonic 2 for me.