Navigating your way through open-city races takes some getting used to, but Burnout Paradise is still an addictive rush.
Fast forward the clock to 2011, and I felt like I needed to give this game a second chance, so in I dove. It's remarkable how well the game's core driving mechanics and presentation still hold up. Cruising through Paradise City still looks gorgeous. It's especially impressive how many different types of geography -- dense downtown, beachy seasides, rural backroads, mountainous overpasses -- Criterion managed to squeeze into the land mass without it sprawling way too large or losing the feeling of a unified city. It's a large environment, to be sure, but all of it is purposely designed. You're never in a dull spot of the map as each area has something interesting to drive through, around or past.
That said, after you've been playing the game for a week or two, repetition does set in. The city isn't so monstrously large that you won't become familiar with all its areas within a week of steady play. Add to that the limited variety of race options over the same terrain, and it's easier to feel repetition fatigue from Paradise, compared to other racing games.
It also calls into the question the whole notion of an open-city. While it's interesting, in theory, to navigate through races yourself using shortcuts, backroads and alleys, in practice I can't honestly say it's "more fun" than a traditional racer on defined tracks. In fact, as you progress to faster and faster cars with your A license, you'll be racing through the city so quickly, it becomes next to impossible to take your eyes off the road for half a second to glance at the minimap in the corner of the screen to see whether you're going anywhere near where you're supposed to. At this point, the normal racing events become much more challenging with tougher opponents, on top of the navigation issues. While I'm sure some people relish the challenge, the game quickly became tiresome for me at this point. Non-race events are fun as ever, and free driving at breakneck speeds throughout the city is still fun -- but trying to handle pure races becomes a real chore because of the open format.
The overall experience in Burnout Paradise is still fantastic, all map griping aside. While I can't say I hope Criterion does another open-city format racer in the future, I'll still always look forward to whatever racing experiment they come up with next.