I didn't get to play it much but I loved it!
The first match i played was a TLC match to see what the hype was all about. I played as Edge and was a bit disappointed with his hair and face but hes better than he was in the last game. One of the first things I noticed was the new physics system. I sent opponents flying through tables without even meaning to! (a bit annoying but still pretty cool) And when i was tipped off the ladder i was unfortunate enough to land with the ropes between my legs and then fall out of the ring. This just reminded me of the Money in the Bank matches where people are flying everywhere off the ladders. Also at one point my partner was thrown off the ladder just to slam his head into the turnbuckle. Honestly I think the way the tables burst into bits is a bit overdone but its better than a table splitting in half when you've just done a lift up throw onto it. This match is one I would love to play again.
The next match I played was an Extreme Rules match. These matches are basically the same as the last game but with the new physics thrown in. At one point my opponent was lying on the announce table and I did a moonsault off the turnbuckle onto them which collapsed the announce table. This was a nice feature.
I also like the way they have let you do a finisher in more than one way. Like Edge can now also do a running spear (which i like better) along with his ground one.
Everyone seems to be complaining about the new controls (which haven't really changed that much) and I can see why but they do take a while to get use to. Just give them a chance.
Overall this game has some faults but the good stuff outweighs the bad for once and I wouldn't hesitate to get this game. Though I can't speak for all of us.