Why have all the major review sites given this a mediocre score? Why are actual gamers saying it's a lot more?
My opinion on how this game is so unfairly reviewed is that this game is hard. Not only is it hard but that it's physically hard. You can't play this game and relax at the same time or youll be creamed. You're boxing and it expects you to be. You break a sweat and definitely get your blood going. There's no other way to play the game. This must be why the reviewers got it wrong. They probably had the wrong mindset or didn't want to put too much physical effort in.
Now it's not the best game ever either, but a dame good one it is. Give it a go if you have a move. Given the field of move games available this is the only one that isn't aimed at the wii crowd.