My vote went to Bloodborne because I'm a Dark Souls nut, but I can see why Witcher 3 won, it's a great game- though personally I had more than a few issues with it`s control scheme.

Partially thanks to the mandatory updates....

I have it on my laptop and it's alright.... Don't like it enough to put it on my main system. I foresee myself sticking with W7 for a long long time.

@SoulScribe: Haha, same here :)

For gaming it's a close call between my N64 and first PC. Obviously the PC has been immeasurably more valuable in the long run.

Awesome, looking forward to it.

@bbq_R0ADK1LL: Yup ;)

Here's my extremely biased point based breakdown of my top 3 games this year.

#3 Witcher3 (5,500 points)
Very impressive: 3000
Gorgeous visuals and a vast, detailed world: 5000
Clunky controls, even after the update -3000
Decent to excellent storytelling: 500

#2 MGSV (7,900 points)
Surprisingly fun emergent gameplay and combination of great stealth and great action: 5000
Kinda lame story (from a newcomers perspective): -100
Extremely polished, bug free PC version: 3000

#1 Bloodborne (19,000 points)
Exclusive: -5000
Low framerate and bad aliasing due to hardware limitations: -2000
Great Horror Setting: 1000
Incredible 'Souls' gameplay: 15,000
Enigmatic, Deep, Beautiful: 10,000

I'm with Mike and Eric for #1

Rocket League :/

@masterkushh: At first, I thought it was a great game held back by terrible controls and annoying combat.. kept me from really getting into it. Nowadays (at least on PC) it's quite a bit better. Still feels clunky but it's a worthy game. A solid 3rd place after Bloodborne and MGSV.