So for a Dark Souls game a punishing difficulty is a positive, but here it's a negative?

I just don't get it

This is what I hate about most gamespot reviews. You can tell what the opinion is going to be within first few seconds. Gametrailer reviews are by far the best ones. After Yahtzee of course :-)

I give this "review" a 2/10

I haven't played either of these games, but looking at the screenshots, it's as if the they got mixed up and GoW got labeled GoW and vice versa. The first one looks better by a long shot!