How is it immersion if I have to twist my hand in unnatural positions and adjust angles every 5 seconds and rage? Zelda fans have a terrible perception of "immersion".

Eponique

all I hear is wahwahwah too hard. learn to play before you criticize

And there is a world of room for improvement.

mmmwksil

and? the wright brothers werent insulted for creating a new form of transportation with much room for improvement. they were praised for innovation like skyward sword should

I don't deny that. Never have.

But SS wasn't exactly a perfect take.

mmmwksil

perfection is unattainable. skyward sword was great and the best we have yet for motion

LOL no. The sword fighting motion controls were great (though inaccurate), but the rest of it was tacked on and made everything 1000x more annoying than it is supposed to be. The only reason you'd find them good is because it's the only game to use motion for everything. That itself makes it a gimmick.Eponique

its called immersion :roll:

but have fun pressing buttons while zelda fans enjoy the future of gaming

Excuse me for offending you. :roll:

Just because a gimmick is implemented "well" doesn't stop it from being a gimmick.

mmmwksil

trying to downplay innovation by calling it a gimmick is fanboyish. nintendo is doing is what others dont and pushing gaming forward

My issues with the game were pacing and fluff text. I didn't find the motion controls very intuitive, either.

I hope the next game doesn't try the motion gimmick again.

mmmwksil

skyward sword is the best use of motion controls on the wii . gimmick, dont make me laugh :roll:

Didn't read all the pages here, but isn't Skyward Sword just a remake of Twilight princess? Which itself was a remake of Majora's Mask? That was just a 3D re-envisioning of Link to the Past? Zelda games are just like Capcom re-releasing Street Fighter or MvC3, only better disguised.

AdobeArtist

ironic coming from a mass effect fan. whats it like, playing the same shooter three times?

I don't get it. Skyward Sword is the best Zelda game ever created...no, the greatest GAME ever created.

ActionRemix

nonono majora's mask is the best. but skyward sword is top 3 material

consoles only

and ew ponies. please, lets not taint a zelda thread by making it a haven for pedophiles

I only know so many moves! My trainer keeps making me forget them for **** HMs!

Badosh

youre the hm whore of the team? now I feel bad