@Jamoid @NateDaddy112278 Good point, I just think Jonny has more potential to make a better show and he missed the point. But I respect your opinion and think there is some truth to what you have said.
@Warful @NateDaddy112278 I think you are confused. I wasn't complaining about the length of the review and I did read it. Maybe you should read my comment again.
Jonny, I respectfully think you missed the point here. It isn't about the score for many of us, an 8 out of 10 is respectable and I'm all for a reviewer having an opinion. What I found lacking was the content of the review. It just wasn't done with the caliber that I have come to expect from Gamespot and therefore didn't give me proper information to make an informed purchase as a consumer (which is why many of us read/watch reviews). I applaud you on the idea and delivery of Feedbackula but I think there is room for growth with your presentation. I would like to see you create something a bit more intelligent, rather than appeal to the masses. You come across as angry in this show and I believe you have more wit and creativity than that. I would also like to say I respect you for having loyalty and sticking up for your coworker. Keep up the good work Gamespot and don't be afraid to step it up a bit.
I doubt it, watch Adam Sessler's review. He goes into almost too much detail, yet I walked away from that review thinking, "exceptional review." My reaction might have been pronounced due to the fact that this one was so lacking. Watching the review as opposed to reading it helps but still...very disappointing from a site that I have trusted time and time again over the years. I blame management on this one, where were the editors? There is a lot of talent on this site but it isn't being managed well. I hope a strong man or woman takes the stern and steers Gamespot back into top shelf waters.
Everyone has an off day or does a poor job from time to time. I would be open minded enough to give him another chance. However, I do admit that this review was weak!
This review was a let down and didn't provide important decision making consumer information. For the first time ever, I went to IGN to get a proper review. Tom Mc Shea, I think you had an off day when you made this review and it should be redone.
Way to dodge the questions Phil Spencer. Microsoft doesn't seem to be in touch with the gaming community and this saddens me greatly. Whoever is at the helm needs to be thrown overboard.
NateDaddy112278's comments