Call me nostalgic, but the best Call of Duty is still the first one. It set out to do what made Call of Duty so unique, you were just a soldier in a war much bigger than yourself. All of the modern COD games make you feel like you're some hero saving the world. It just isn't that cool.
The thing with Infinite was that it had great presentation, it made you think it was better than it really was. This worked great come first reviews time but if you actually play the game and let it sink in a bit I think I might not quite go as low as a 4 but definitely along the 6 or 7 range of the scale.
@DinoBuster Back in the day, you got new maps for free, made by the community! Sure, some weren't so good but others were good. And always there would be a few that were creative enough only amateur minds could make it happen.
The only way Grand Theft Auto 4 can be great is if it's online, that would be fresh and exciting. Imagine a World Of Warcraft minus the queer. Man, I wish I had a 360... and that the said above is true ;)
Kev_Boy's comments