I'm completely ignoring this review. You get to play as Tim Drake! I'm such a Robin fanboy that I'll love it anyway. I didn't even like playing the challenge rooms as Batman, yet I bought the Robin DLC anyway and play the challenge rooms as him all the time. Now give us an entire Robin (or Red Robin) game, please!
Is a 6 worth playing? Probably. But is it worth buying, especially when it costs 60 bucks? Not likely. You (GameSpot) have to take into account that we don't get to play these games for free...
Due to various promotions, I bought Borderlands: Game of the Year Edition on OnLive for \$3.50, and Batman: Arkham Asylum for $0.69 (that's not a typo). Neither of them would run on my computer without OnLive. Needless to say, I'm quite happy with it.
JediKnightJace's comments