I'm not quite convinced the score reflects the review, but it is still a decent title. I wish it offered slightly more as a game, but these episodic Telltale features are usually really short. It did a better job than with BTTF (imo); the choice element and extremely well crafted narrative are really gripping. (also, slight editorial error in paragraph 6 you might want to correct)
I don't necessarily agree a lot with Tom, but I think he's right on the money on this one. There's a scoring range for a reason; to fully use it. Especially the last part: Games with a 6 or a 5 still have a very specified audience. Hell, I've even bought multiple 4 games on a budget, because they catered specifically to my interests, homed in to what I'd find enjoyable in a game. If a review comes back unfavorable and you weren't really piqued, then sure, you can pass; you don't need to buy every game. But if a game really has you pumped and it doesn't come back with a perfect rating, you can still actually read (or watch) if the parts that apply to you are done right. If so, chances are you'll still enjoy the game greatly.
Daavpuke's comments