Which of these games has best chance of a 10/10 from GS?

Teh contenders with no pretenders...

Batman AC... 9.0

RAGE.... 8.0 Flopzers

FM4... 8.5 Flopzers

Gears 3... 9.5 but no 10 :?

BF3.. 8.5 flopzers

UC3...9.0

Deus Ex: HR... 8.5 Flopzers

Diablo 3 looks like next year so, out of the running. :P

Skyrim... 9.0

Skyward Sword... 7.5 Mega flopzers !! :P

Dark Souls... 9.5 but no 10

Guild Wars 2 ... looks like next year 2012 TBA :P

And just for fun ... 8.0 eh, shoulda been a 9.0. :P

I'm going with RAGE and or FM4 how about you ?

For extra credit ( optional :P ) which is teh most likely to flop ? :o

No poll, just chime in.

Non of them, but deus ex HR might due to it being a MSG clone and MSG4 [is it?] got a 10/10

[spoiler] :P [/spoiler]

I didn't see an none of the above option.

Skyrim.

Rage - 9
Gears 3- 9.5
BF3- 9(PC), 8(Console).
UC3- 8.5 (Flop)
Deus EX- 8.5 (Flop)
Diablo 3- 9.5
Skyrim- 10

Why is Skyward Sword not in that list?charizard1605

Because it uses motion controls, duh.

In all seriousness, Rage is the one game coming out that is looking more and more impressive to me. I can see Rage, UC3, DE:HR, (and Skyward Sword) all scoring a ten.

Probably skyrim. Though I don't think that game will be very good for me.

Why is Skyward Sword not in that list?charizard1605

[QUOTE="charizard1605"]Why is Skyward Sword not in that list?SecretPolice

If Street Cleaning Sim couldn't get a 10, then these games don't stand a chance in hell. :P

Until I saw that Diablo 3 picture the first thing that came to my mind was "damn, there's a lot of brown in these screens"

How hard is it to add color? Halo does it. Even in Reach with the darker environments they were able to add in lots of color.

If Street Cleaning Sim couldn't get a 10, then these games don't stand a chance in hell. :P

BigBoss154

Until I saw that Diablo 3 picture the first thing that came to my mind was "damn, there's a lot of brown in these screens"

How hard is it to add color? Halo does it. Even in Reach with the darker environments they were able to add in lots of color.

Wasdie

I'd like to believe Skyward Sword is capable of a 10. Based on everything I've heard, it seems to be going in a new, and much more awesome direction.

I'd say Gears 3 is most likely of a flop, it did drop in score from 1 to 2.

I'd like to believe Skyward Sword is capable of a 10. Based on everything I've heard, it seems to be going in a new, and much more awesome direction.

I'd say Gears 3 is most likely of a flop, it did drop in score from 1 to 2.

110million

What sets it apart from the rest? To me it looks like just a more simplified version of TP gameplay wise.

Skyrim in my opinion.

RAGE - Maybe

Gears of War 3 - Nope

Battlefield 3 - Maybe

Uncharted 3 - Nope

Deus Ex: HR - Maybe

Diablo 3 - Nope

Skyrim - Nope

Skyward Sword - Maybe

Halo: Anv. - Nope

---------------------------------

Out of the list, I would say Battlefield 3 or Skyward Sword. RAGE and Deus Ex will be nice but, Gamespot tends to go a tad below the curve compared to first off reviews. 9.4 and 10. I'm expected a 9/10.

Skyrim or possibly Skyward Sword (Hey, SMG2 got a 10).

I could see a few of these getting a 10/10, but I'm rooting more for SS since it has less of a chance just because it is on Wii and Gamespot likes its 8.5's for Wii. ANd I would have said a more detailed version of Twilight Princess when comparing SS. I don't remember being able to gain items to be used for updating weapons, or the detailed/technical ways of defeating enemies in any other Zelda. I think its awesome that instead of just waiting for a skullta to turn around we will have to cut them down and then flip them on their backs.

Also, is there a reason Arkham City isn't on this list?

WTH, TC, how could you forget the one which just may have the best shot.. Forza 4 ? :shock:

:oops: Sorry, I'll add that saweeetness rght now. :P

:twisted:

I don't think any game this fall is getting a PERFECT 10, but here goes...

My Wish:

• Batman: Arkham City
• King of Fighters XIII

From that List:

• RAGE
• Skyrim

I'd like to believe Skyward Sword is capable of a 10. Based on everything I've heard, it seems to be going in a new, and much more awesome direction.

I'd say Gears 3 is most likely of a flop, it did drop in score from 1 to 2.

110million

You cant take the previous games as example since Gears 3 beta alone was funner than the Gears 1 and 2 put together! Both were AAA here and in meta anyway.

Noone noticed how the OP asks which game of these will score a 10 ON GAMESPOT then proceeds to post pics with IGN watermarks? :lol:

On a serious note, I think none of these games has a chance to score a 10 here.

[QUOTE="110million"]

I'd like to believe Skyward Sword is capable of a 10. Based on everything I've heard, it seems to be going in a new, and much more awesome direction.

I'd say Gears 3 is most likely of a flop, it did drop in score from 1 to 2.

PAL360

You cant take the previous games as example since Gears 3 beta alone was funner than the Gears 1 and 2 put together! Both were AAA here and in meta anyway.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="110million"]

I'd like to believe Skyward Sword is capable of a 10. Based on everything I've heard, it seems to be going in a new, and much more awesome direction.

I'd say Gears 3 is most likely of a flop, it did drop in score from 1 to 2.

campzor

You cant take the previous games as example since Gears 3 beta alone was funner than the Gears 1 and 2 put together! Both were AAA here and in meta anyway.

Yep, i used to be terrible at Gears competitive mp and play them just for their campaign and coop modes aswell.

[QUOTE="110million"]

I'd like to believe Skyward Sword is capable of a 10. Based on everything I've heard, it seems to be going in a new, and much more awesome direction.

I'd say Gears 3 is most likely of a flop, it did drop in score from 1 to 2.

Wasdie

What sets it apart from the rest? To me it looks like just a more simplified version of TP gameplay wise.

Crafting system, various shields, etc, breaking up formula of dungeon -> boss, there are supposed to be dungeons without bosses and bosses without dungeons, no ganon, town like in majora's mask with important NPCs that are part of the story, zelda isn't a princess, air travel is cooler than boats, orchestra soundtrack, art style is a nice mix of TP and WW.

It isn't all new, but it seems to be some of the best aspects of other Zeldas, along with some new stuff.

MW3 would have the biggest shot since Activision got some big dollars

I hope Skyrim will flop.

Laharl5

Why would anyone want a game to flop? Please explain

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

[QUOTE="110million"]

I'd like to believe Skyward Sword is capable of a 10. Based on everything I've heard, it seems to be going in a new, and much more awesome direction.

I'd say Gears 3 is most likely of a flop, it did drop in score from 1 to 2.

110million

What sets it apart from the rest? To me it looks like just a more simplified version of TP gameplay wise.

Crafting system, various shields, etc, breaking up formula of dungeon -> boss, there are supposed to be dungeons without bosses and bosses without dungeons, no ganon, town like in majora's mask with important NPCs that are part of the story, zelda isn't a princess, air travel is cooler than boats, orchestra soundtrack, art style is a nice mix of TP and WW.

It isn't all new, but it seems to be some of the best aspects of other Zeldas, along with some new stuff.

[QUOTE="Laharl5"]

I hope Skyrim will flop.

fueled-system

Why would anyone want a game to flop? Please explain

A flop by SW standards =/= a flop in the real world.

I'd like it to flop here just because of teh lulz it will bring. :P

Noone noticed how the OP asks which game of these will score a 10 ON GAMESPOT then proceeds to post pics with IGN watermarks? :lol:

On a serious note, I think none of these games has a chance to score a 10 here.

QQabitmoar

[QUOTE="110million"]

Crafting system, various shields, etc, breaking up formula of dungeon -> boss, there are supposed to be dungeons without bosses and bosses without dungeons, no ganon, town like in majora's mask with important NPCs that are part of the story, zelda isn't a princess, air travel is cooler than boats, orchestra soundtrack, art style is a nice mix of TP and WW.

It isn't all new, but it seems to be some of the best aspects of other Zeldas, along with some new stuff.

Nintendo_Ownes7

We'll have to see about the difficulty thing, I want to believe, but TP was just so easy. :P

Though I could see them having made TP easier to sell Wiis early on, and now that a lot of more "hardcore" gamers own them, they are free to make it harder, the way they did for Galaxy 2, NSMB Wii and DKCR.

[QUOTE="QQabitmoar"]

Noone noticed how the OP asks which game of these will score a 10 ON GAMESPOT then proceeds to post pics with IGN watermarks? :lol:

On a serious note, I think none of these games has a chance to score a 10 here.

SecretPolice

They do fit pretty well, gamespot does not do images very nicely so it makes sense.

[QUOTE="Laharl5"]

I hope Skyrim will flop.

fueled-system

Why would anyone want a game to flop? Please explain

Read again my edited post. Oblivion was my 1st game on my 360 coz i thought the game is awesome. And guess what? It's garbage. I just don't support these kinda games. That's why I want it to flop.

Battlefield 3 8)

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

[QUOTE="QQabitmoar"]

Noone noticed how the OP asks which game of these will score a 10 ON GAMESPOT then proceeds to post pics with IGN watermarks? :lol:

On a serious note, I think none of these games has a chance to score a 10 here.

110million

They do fit pretty well, gamespot does not do images very nicely so it makes sense.

I just found it kinda lulzy. Just sayin~