@Messiahbolical- said:
@starwolf474 said:
While it is a huge improvement over the piece of crap PS3 controller, the left analog stick is still in an unnatural position for most modern games. The PS4 controller might be the best controller ever for 2D games, but for 3D games, the Xbox 360 controller is still the king and the Xbox One controller is in second place.
When the only complaint you can come up for it is that the "analog stick is in an UNNATURAL place", then yeah... the controller is pretty much perfect. I mean really now? An UNNATURAL place?! As if analogs sticks are natural things that you were programmed to use a specific way at birth? lmao. If anything, having your hands/thumbs/anything in symmetrical positions when controlling things is about as close as you can get to saying that it's "natural".
Just because your Xbot brain can't handle the grueling task of having your thumb rest an inch and a half further to the right compared to usual doesn't make it a flaw. It makes YOU flawed.
On the other hand, you can actually point out legitimate flaws with the Xbox One controller compared to the PS4 controller such as taking AA batteries, having way less features, and having a stupid ass proprietary mic port that your old gaming headset(mine happens to cost $200) doesn't let you voice chat on because Microsoft was greedy as usual and felt the need to milk more money from the headset companies.
That's a huge complaint that keeps it from being perfect for modern games. It's unnatural because your thumb does not naturally rest in that position when gripping the controller like how your thumb naturally rests over the analog stick when gripping a Xbox controller. On the PS4 controller, you have to stretch your thumb out to the right and down to touch the analog stick which leads to cramping after holding it in that position for an extended period of time. It's not nearly as bad as the cramping from the PS3 controller, but I still feel cramping after about an hour of using the PS4 controller which means there is no way I could ever consider it the best controller ever for 3D games (again, it's great for 2D games that use the d-pad as primary).
The base design of the PlayStation controller is based on an 18 year old controller, that was made in a time when the d-pad was the primary control method. Since then, the analog stick has taken over as the primary control method and every other company, Microsoft, Nintendo, Sega, even Ouya have put the analog stick in the primary position. Sony is the only company that keeps the archaic design of having the d-pad in the primary position instead of the analog stick.
There is a reason why 3rd parties have released many PlayStation controllers that copy the Xbox analog stick placement, but I don't think I've ever seen any 3rd party Xbox controllers that copy the PlayStation analog stick placement because there would not be much demand for that. Sony has even admitted themselves that their user test team for the PS4 controller wanted them to try having the analog stick on top, but management decided against it because they wanted to keep the "PlayStation look", which in my opinion was a mistake.
Log in to comment