Gordon Freeman vs. Master Chief vs. Nathan Drake

In my opinion, from solid, good experience with all game franchises, I just find the silent protagonist to be better than the protagonists of both Halo and Uncharted franchises. Freeman can go through a town, fighting a bunch of zombies when no one could, but he did it anyway. Plus, he has a degree, which is better than treasure hunting skills. The hazard suit is also better than the spartan armor. But hey, I'm a good guy. You can vote who is the best game character out of the three right now.

I hate Freeman, I hate Chief, so I picked Drake.

Chief and Freeman are terrible, at least Drake is entertaining.

So Drake.

Lets see, and everyman scientist with barely any combat experience outside a few days of fighting (HL and HL2 combined are like, 4 days in Freeman's life), vs a treasure hunting thief everyman without any sort of armor, vs a space marine that is genetically enhanced and wearing a combat suit.

Though I love Freeman and Drake much more then Chief, I think Chief would win. He's a freaking Spartan, using tech 500 years in the future against Drake and Freeman.

If its just a "who is better" question though, then I'm torn. I like Freeman for being completely different from other game characters in his backstory. He's a scientist, and at the same time completely immerses you in the HL universe in that he is simply you, pure and simple, in this world. But Drake is much more characterized then either character with more backstory and personality, so I gotta go with Drake.

Lets see, and everyman scientist with barely any combat experience outside a few days of fighting (HL and HL2 combined are like, 4 days in Freeman's life), vs a treasure hunting thief everyman without any sort of armor, vs a space marine that is genetically enhanced and wearing a combat suit.

Though I love Freeman and Drake much more then Chief, I think Chief would win. He's a freaking Spartan, using tech 500 years in the future against Drake and Freeman.

SPYDER0416

[QUOTE="SPYDER0416"]

Lets see, and everyman scientist with barely any combat experience outside a few days of fighting (HL and HL2 combined are like, 4 days in Freeman's life), vs a treasure hunting thief everyman without any sort of armor, vs a space marine that is genetically enhanced and wearing a combat suit.

Though I love Freeman and Drake much more then Chief, I think Chief would win. He's a freaking Spartan, using tech 500 years in the future against Drake and Freeman.

DragonfireXZ95

Yeah I edited my post to reflect that, but I mostly skimmed his post and just answered the title. Probably should have read into it a bit more.

None of them are good characters. Especially Gordon Freeman.

Nathan Drake has the better bod, so he wins.

[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"][QUOTE="SPYDER0416"]

Lets see, and everyman scientist with barely any combat experience outside a few days of fighting (HL and HL2 combined are like, 4 days in Freeman's life), vs a treasure hunting thief everyman without any sort of armor, vs a space marine that is genetically enhanced and wearing a combat suit.

Though I love Freeman and Drake much more then Chief, I think Chief would win. He's a freaking Spartan, using tech 500 years in the future against Drake and Freeman.

SPYDER0416

Yeah I edited my post to reflect that, but I mostly skimmed his post and just answered the title. Probably should have read into it a bit more.

Besides, Drake would just tell a joke and the other 2 would die from that. :P

Freeman. Drake gets on my nerves and Chief just isn't interesting.

The quality of their games not withstanding, Drake has much better dialogue writing. PraetorianMan

Nope, Freeman has WAY better dialogue wrting than those two COMBINED. ;)

The Chief, any other answer is pure fanboyism at its greatest.

[QUOTE="SPYDER0416"]

[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"] The OP doesn't say anything about them fighting. :|theuncharted34

Yeah I edited my post to reflect that, but I mostly skimmed his post and just answered the title. Probably should have read into it a bit more.

Besides, Drake would just tell a joke and the other 2 would die from that. :P

To be honest its still kind of a hard choice. We don't know enough about Drake's past to consider whether or not maybe he does have some insane combat experience as a mercenary or something, and in the Uncharted games he routinely fights heavily armored thugs that require about 5 headshots while they weild powerful 2 hit kill weapons, so that might be something to worry MC about.

Plus Gordon has the gravity gun and the help of the G-Man, which could turn things around.

In a fight though, I'd probably bet my money on MC because of his experience and stuff.

so Battle Rifle vs. Gravity Gun vs. generic machine gun ?

Freeman wins easily.

Gordon Freeman :)

:twisted:

so Battle Rifle vs. Gravity Gun vs. generic machine gun ?

Freeman wins easily.

rasengan2552

Freeman.

Drake is very annoying and Chief is a generic space marine.

Gordon is also the most powerful out of the three.

Freeman is a legend, A LEGEND I TELL YOU!!!

The Chief, any other answer is pure fanboyism at its greatest.

Bardock47

[QUOTE="theuncharted34"]

[QUOTE="SPYDER0416"]

Yeah I edited my post to reflect that, but I mostly skimmed his post and just answered the title. Probably should have read into it a bit more.

SPYDER0416

Besides, Drake would just tell a joke and the other 2 would die from that. :P

To be honest its still kind of a hard choice. We don't know enough about Drake's past to consider whether or not maybe he does have some insane combat experience as a mercenary or something, and in the Uncharted games he routinely fights heavily armored thugs that require about 5 headshots while they weild powerful 2 hit kill weapons, so that might be something to worry MC about.

Plus Gordon has the gravity gun and the help of the G-Man, which could turn things around.

In a fight though, I'd probably bet my money on MC because of his experience and stuff.

Drake should have died at least 100 times, he's made out of some un-earthly metal. :P

Okay, lets just get real here guys. Lets imagine all three starting out mexicna stand-off style with their best gear. That means freeman has GG and crowbar. MC has Halo 1 pistol and energy sword. Drake has an AK-47 and some grenades. It would start all at once, with Drake tossing a grenade and making a mad dash for cover, freeman picks up grennade and tosses it at the cheif with GG, who is charging with Genetically enhanced speed, brandsihing the Plasma Sword. Grenade goes off and pops his sheild down to low, and freeman picks cheif up with GG, who has swiched over to Pistol and taking aim, then about this time Drake would take this oppuertune moment and strike a heavily distracted Freeman down. The cheif drops with sheilds recharnging and fires at Drake, who ducks, back into cover, peppering his shields. cheif then rolls into cover and waits, Drake tosses second grenade, Cheif rolls out of blast radius, and brandishes Pistol and sword and charges, Drake Lights him up with AK. With sheilds decreasing he fire the pistol, as Drake takes a few rounds he stops firing, reacting to the pain. Cheif lunges and plants the sword into his stomach, and heaves him off. Fininishing him off.

While the fight cna go any which way, the fact is, the MJOLNIR armor provides the cheif with a huge advantage and would easily win.

Okay, lets just get real here guys. Lets imagine all three starting out mexicna stand-off style with their best gear. That means freeman has GG and crowbar. MC has Halo 1 pistol and energy sword. Drake has an AK-47 and some grenades. It would start all at once, with Drake tossing a grenade and making a mad dash for cover, freeman picks up grennade and tosses it at the cheif with GG, who is charging with Genetically enhanced speed, brandsihing the Plasma Sword. Grenade goes off and pops his sheild down to low, and freeman picks cheif up with GG, who has swiched over to Pistol and taking aim, then about this time Drake would take this oppuertune moment and strike a heavily distracted Freeman down. The cheif drops with sheilds recharnging and fires at Drake, who ducks, back into cover, peppering his shields. cheif then rolls into cover and waits, Drake tosses second grenade, Cheif rolls out of blast radius, and brandishes Pistol and sword and charges, Drake Lights him up with AK. With sheilds decreasing he fire the pistol, as Drake takes a few rounds he stops firing, reacting to the pain. Cheif lunges and plants the sword into his stomach, and heaves him off. Fininishing him off.

While the fight cna go any which way, the fact is, the MJOLNIR armor provides the cheif with a huge advantage and would easily win.

Bardock47

Okay, lets just get real here guys. Lets imagine all three starting out mexicna stand-off style with their best gear. That means freeman has GG and crowbar. MC has Halo 1 pistol and energy sword. Drake has an AK-47 and some grenades. It would start all at once, with Drake tossing a grenade and making a mad dash for cover, freeman picks up grennade and tosses it at the cheif with GG, who is charging with Genetically enhanced speed, brandsihing the Plasma Sword. Grenade goes off and pops his sheild down to low, and freeman picks cheif up with GG, who has swiched over to Pistol and taking aim, then about this time Drake would take this oppuertune moment and strike a heavily distracted Freeman down. The cheif drops with sheilds recharnging and fires at Drake, who ducks, back into cover, peppering his shields. cheif then rolls into cover and waits, Drake tosses second grenade, Cheif rolls out of blast radius, and brandishes Pistol and sword and charges, Drake Lights him up with AK. With sheilds decreasing he fire the pistol, as Drake takes a few rounds he stops firing, reacting to the pain. Cheif lunges and plants the sword into his stomach, and heaves him off. Fininishing him off.

While the fight cna go any which way, the fact is, the MJOLNIR armor provides the cheif with a huge advantage and would easily win.

Bardock47

In my imaginary fight, Gordon just knocks out both MC and Nathan with his crowbar :]

As a charectar though, Freeman is out.

Going straight off of games....as much as I like Halo, I have to say Drake wins, I havent played the UC's but he probably is a much more fleshed out charecter. Any charecter the chief has is barley there and the little hints that anyone would get are for people like me, ho dig the universe, and alot more of his charecter is in the books, an unfiar advantage that is thrown out, since we are comparing how they stand in their respective games.

[QUOTE="Bardock47"]

Okay, lets just get real here guys. Lets imagine all three starting out mexicna stand-off style with their best gear. That means freeman has GG and crowbar. MC has Halo 1 pistol and energy sword. Drake has an AK-47 and some grenades. It would start all at once, with Drake tossing a grenade and making a mad dash for cover, freeman picks up grennade and tosses it at the cheif with GG, who is charging with Genetically enhanced speed, brandsihing the Plasma Sword. Grenade goes off and pops his sheild down to low, and freeman picks cheif up with GG, who has swiched over to Pistol and taking aim, then about this time Drake would take this oppuertune moment and strike a heavily distracted Freeman down. The cheif drops with sheilds recharnging and fires at Drake, who ducks, back into cover, peppering his shields. cheif then rolls into cover and waits, Drake tosses second grenade, Cheif rolls out of blast radius, and brandishes Pistol and sword and charges, Drake Lights him up with AK. With sheilds decreasing he fire the pistol, as Drake takes a few rounds he stops firing, reacting to the pain. Cheif lunges and plants the sword into his stomach, and heaves him off. Fininishing him off.

While the fight cna go any which way, the fact is, the MJOLNIR armor provides the cheif with a huge advantage and would easily win.

DragonfireXZ95

Ok Buzz Killington, way to Kill the Buzz.

And ruin our fun.

Jerk.

Freeman.

Drake is very annoying and Chief is a generic space marine.

Gordon is also the most powerful out of the three.

call_of_duty_10

[QUOTE="Bardock47"]

Okay, lets just get real here guys. Lets imagine all three starting out mexicna stand-off style with their best gear. That means freeman has GG and crowbar. MC has Halo 1 pistol and energy sword. Drake has an AK-47 and some grenades. It would start all at once, with Drake tossing a grenade and making a mad dash for cover, freeman picks up grennade and tosses it at the cheif with GG, who is charging with Genetically enhanced speed, brandsihing the Plasma Sword. Grenade goes off and pops his sheild down to low, and freeman picks cheif up with GG, who has swiched over to Pistol and taking aim, then about this time Drake would take this oppuertune moment and strike a heavily distracted Freeman down. The cheif drops with sheilds recharnging and fires at Drake, who ducks, back into cover, peppering his shields. cheif then rolls into cover and waits, Drake tosses second grenade, Cheif rolls out of blast radius, and brandishes Pistol and sword and charges, Drake Lights him up with AK. With sheilds decreasing he fire the pistol, as Drake takes a few rounds he stops firing, reacting to the pain. Cheif lunges and plants the sword into his stomach, and heaves him off. Fininishing him off.

While the fight cna go any which way, the fact is, the MJOLNIR armor provides the cheif with a huge advantage and would easily win.

el3m2tigre

In my imaginary fight, Gordon just knocks out both MC and Nathan with his crowbar :]

[QUOTE="Bardock47"]

Okay, lets just get real here guys. Lets imagine all three starting out mexicna stand-off style with their best gear. That means freeman has GG and crowbar. MC has Halo 1 pistol and energy sword. Drake has an AK-47 and some grenades. It would start all at once, with Drake tossing a grenade and making a mad dash for cover, freeman picks up grennade and tosses it at the cheif with GG, who is charging with Genetically enhanced speed, brandsihing the Plasma Sword. Grenade goes off and pops his sheild down to low, and freeman picks cheif up with GG, who has swiched over to Pistol and taking aim, then about this time Drake would take this oppuertune moment and strike a heavily distracted Freeman down. The cheif drops with sheilds recharnging and fires at Drake, who ducks, back into cover, peppering his shields. cheif then rolls into cover and waits, Drake tosses second grenade, Cheif rolls out of blast radius, and brandishes Pistol and sword and charges, Drake Lights him up with AK. With sheilds decreasing he fire the pistol, as Drake takes a few rounds he stops firing, reacting to the pain. Cheif lunges and plants the sword into his stomach, and heaves him off. Fininishing him off.

While the fight cna go any which way, the fact is, the MJOLNIR armor provides the cheif with a huge advantage and would easily win.

DragonfireXZ95

drake>chief>that one guy i dont care about

Gordon Freeman easily.

The Chief, any other answer is pure fanboyism at its greatest.

Bardock47

[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"][QUOTE="Bardock47"]

Okay, lets just get real here guys. Lets imagine all three starting out mexicna stand-off style with their best gear. That means freeman has GG and crowbar. MC has Halo 1 pistol and energy sword. Drake has an AK-47 and some grenades. It would start all at once, with Drake tossing a grenade and making a mad dash for cover, freeman picks up grennade and tosses it at the cheif with GG, who is charging with Genetically enhanced speed, brandsihing the Plasma Sword. Grenade goes off and pops his sheild down to low, and freeman picks cheif up with GG, who has swiched over to Pistol and taking aim, then about this time Drake would take this oppuertune moment and strike a heavily distracted Freeman down. The cheif drops with sheilds recharnging and fires at Drake, who ducks, back into cover, peppering his shields. cheif then rolls into cover and waits, Drake tosses second grenade, Cheif rolls out of blast radius, and brandishes Pistol and sword and charges, Drake Lights him up with AK. With sheilds decreasing he fire the pistol, as Drake takes a few rounds he stops firing, reacting to the pain. Cheif lunges and plants the sword into his stomach, and heaves him off. Fininishing him off.

While the fight cna go any which way, the fact is, the MJOLNIR armor provides the cheif with a huge advantage and would easily win.

SPYDER0416

Ok Buzz Killington, way to Kill the Buzz.

And ruin our fun.

Jerk.

Chief Generic? Well I read the books and well I say Chief would win,

gotta say Drake, humour and a personality thats human.Just feel chief and Freeman are a tad souless tbh.

Drake is handsome, charming, funny, etc yet people here vote for two mutes over him? What the hell.

As if the answer wasn't gonna be clear cut. Chief or drake over freeman? never

Nathan Drake

Drake is handsome, charming, funny, etc yet people here vote for two mutes over him? What the hell.

Mozelleple112

What some find as charm and wit others can easily find it annoying and cocky. Works both ways for everything :P