Gamespot GTA 5 second opinion review 8/10

And people though this game could surpass MGS4 as the best game of the gen :P

I bet if GTAIV got a second review it would get a 3/10

It´s a matter of consistency,the game should have been reviewed when the MP was available and not before like many did,and the MP itself should matter for the review in a positive or negative light since it´s part of the game,just in the same way that Battlefield 3 got heavily criticised by it´s SP content even though it´s a MP focused game and most people even argued that the SP was one of the reasons so many reviews were lower than expected,wich is accurate since quite a few of them mention that very fact. Also,the fact that Arma 3 is know to be a MP game didn´t stop plenty of reviewers from docking it for not having the SP portion available at launch,something that oddly enough pretty much none of the major reviewers even mention as a negative for GTA V.

If nothing else, these "second opinions" show that we place too much value on scores.

JC 2 is a lifeless, copy and paste world with ai thats as bad as last gen GTA's. The lifeless and bad ai can be said for Sleeping Dogs as well. Both of those games are way more repetitive and neither even have a mp mode. RDR is great but driving cars is much more fun for me than riding horses.

What multiplayer game isnt repetitive?

JC2 is a much better, do what you want, mess around Sandbox game. There is greater variety in the Environment, more varied side activities, more creative physics and attaching various things with the wire and seeing how they react is always interesting. It's biggest flaw is that in the end game the second you do anything you are lambasted by massive amounts of Heat, leaving you in constant run for your life mode.

Sleeping Dogs Story is much better than GTA's. The vehicles handle better, the combat is better, and the game flows a lot better. It's biggest downfall is it is too short, and there is hardly an end game.

GTAV is frustrating, because there is little incentive for you to engage in any activity since there is such little reward. You don't even make money from half the heists you pull, which are the entire hook of the game. It constantly hand holds you during the good parts, and then you're left looking around, wondering what's worth it to try and do next. Overrated.

And people though this game could surpass MGS4 as the best game of the gen :P

I bet if GTAIV got a second review it would get a 3/10

JC 2 is like GTA V halfway through development. Every mission is the same and almost every main mission has the production values of a side activity in GTA V. It's biggest flaws are the awful ai and complete lack of personality.

Story is subjective. How exactly do the vehicles handle better? I find driving to be much more fun in GTA V. The only thing it does better is hand to hand combat but. GTA V does everything else better.

So a game is only fun if theres a reward? Afaik theres only one heist with no reward. I thought the hook of GTA was being the most advanced open world game.

LOL

TLOU game of the gen confirmed by Amazon, by System Wars

And soon by Gamespot themselves as well.

Deep sea diving? Wasted potential. Heist planning? Disappointingly straightforward. Hunting? Several steps back compared to Red Dead Redemption. Property ownership/management? Vice City did this better, and it was made more than a decade ago.

Underdeveloped, like I said.