[QUOTE="The-Apostle"][QUOTE="frostybanana"] lol hasn't missed yet. Garrison Hearst broke his ankle. Eddie George had a sharp decrease in performance after he appeared. Daunte Culpepper threw 23 picks and set the record for fumbles. Marshall Faulk didn't register another 1000 yard season after his. Michael Vick broke his leg. Ray Lewis injured his wrist and had an off year. Donovan McNabb tore his ACL. Shaun Alexander hurt his foot and his stats declined significantly afterwards. Vince Young sucks ass and he continued to suck ass. Also he got injured the next year. Brett Favre torn his bicep at the end of year and as a result sucked ass at the end of the year. Troy Polamalu sprained his MCL. Larry Fitzgerald is probably the only one whose really escaped the curse. But he did injure his ribs that year. Drew Brees sprained his MCL and threw 22 picks. It's the MADDEN CURSE!!!No_Hablo_Ingles
You forgot Dorsey Levens. Everyone forgets him. OMG!!!!! I CAN'T BELIEVE IT! FOOTBALL PLAYERS GETTING INJURED! And it doesn't even have to be in the same year of when they were on Madden (Eddie George) or if they got injured after the season and only missed the ProbowlSome of those players played through injuries (Drew Brees), and maintained a Probowl year.
The Madden Curse is BS. Every player (except Manning) gets listed for having an injury at least once a season. Tom Brady has been listed with some minor injury for the last few years. Also, people updated their definition of the curse so it would fit about anything. OK, the Cover athlete on Madden usually just had a career year. Odds of them repeating that performance is low, and even lower when teams have an entire off season to game plan for. So a drop in stats is expected.
Many players get hurt a some point through the season (I suspect around 40%), that's a part of Football. I think Vick has played like one full season since he's been in the NFL. Point is, the curse only exist because you/we want it to exist and if you actually look back on it, it only has a 50% curse rate.
It can't be true, it just can't be :(
No, it has a much higher success rate than that. It's not JUST about getting injured. It's about a significant drop off in production the year the player appears on the cover. Eddie George, after appearing on the cover, dipped from 1500 yards to 900 yards. All the while averaging 3.0 yards a carry (which is beyond abysmal.) And after appearing he was never an effective runner again. Fitzgerald is the only one who you can make an argument wasn't affected by the curse, even though he DID injure his ribs. But his production was steady and he played all his games, except the Pro Bowl. The difference is 1) he was on the cover with Polamalu and 2) he is the only cover athlete to acknowledge the existence of the curse. Everyone else dismissed it. So maybe he was just that much more careful. Drew Brees threw 22 picks, had an average passer rating (90.9) and the Saints lost in the first round of the playoffs to the Seahawks. That has curse written all over it. Drops in statistics are expected but not at that level of significance. 50% curse rate is so off. Look at all the players I listed. ALL of them have been affected in some way (besides Fitz maybe). But I guess Troy Polamalu just HAPPENED to play the least amount of games in his career after he appeared on the cover. Everyone one of those players had an off year, there's no denying that. Just look at the stats. You don't have to believe in the curse. It's not meant to be logical. But sports and superstitions go hand in hand. That's why people wear their lucky shirt under their pads or wear their socks inside out.
Log in to comment