Not hyped.
In my opinion, the smaller scenes: without all the shit going on, such as the introduction of the dwarfs, Bilbo proving himself through courageous acts and the dwarf back story (Oakenshield being very bitter) are the interesting stuff that gave the first movie "An unexpected Journey" an inclining of hart and soul.
Counterbalance to this and while to be expected; the movie is rife with CGI. Rather than economically used; Jackson is out of control. As opposed to what they are trying to achieve: "exhilaration", they amount to boring action scenes like a theme park ride with 0 sense of threat.
In "Fellowship Of The Ring" the Balrog is threatening. The threat already perusing them disburses indicting a much larger threat. Rather than simplly shooting it's guns on all cylinders: the movie holds back from showing the creature until the final moments; making it all the more effective.
In "A Unexpected Journey" it has none of this. It's essentially an inferior escape scene with forced; expected drama (Gandalf arriving). The Goblins themselves pose 0 threat; they cut through them like butter. The scenes hyperactive and overlong; like this post.
The other thing the first movie does better; is that it hints at Sauron giving a very brief gimps. The unknown is inherently more interesting and makes him seem more of a threat.
In "Desolation Of Smaug" he goes from a pragmatic character to what amounts to a video game boss battle. All the mystery built up from "Lord Of The Rings" and "An Unexpected Journey" just flies right out the window. From what I can see from the trailers for "Battle Of The 5 Armies" they appear to be outright talking to a big eyeball.
This also includes the Dragon. "An unexpected Journey" (like the Balrog) builds it up. However in "The Desolation of Smaug" the Dragon goes from something exciting; to a theme park ride that carries on too long. It chases dwarfs around as if it where in a comedy sketch. Everything the first movie built up instantly flies out the window.
While "An unexpected Journey" features hyperactive action scenes; it had good moments peppered throughout. "The Desolation of Smaug" is action scene, after action scene, after action scene. The characters mostly behave (even up until the dragon) as if they are in a video game with no threat towards there life's. Legoman and Kate From Lost jump around as if they have god mod on.
Overall I enjoyed aspects of the first movie but deeply disliked the second. The main problem seems to be Peter Jackson and his cohorts being overindulgent with no sense of restraint.
Log in to comment