57% of Girls today likes Guys who dress like this. Is this how you dress?

No, I mostly wear t-shirts and jeans that are either blue or black for the most part.

ewww to tucking in your shirt while wearing jeans.

I prefer sweaters and cardigans. Jeans too.

I use to dress like the guy in the 1st picture but with the shirt outside of the pants

Lame. I wear sports shirts and sports shorts. In the winter I wear sports jackets and sports pants, because they're comfortable.

Implying all bronys look like/are shit? What?

I'm more of a graphic tee (band, games, other interests related) and jeans. Though I wouldn't be against that style of dress.

That wasn't the point of the comment, but I can't say I've met any woman who gets moist over a man who is a self-identified brony. Bronies in general are just weird people, and most are the stereotypical trilby-wearing (it's not a fedora) basement-dwelling weirdos who spend most of their free time obsessing over a show marketed to girls 4-10 and has a creepy little (or gigantic) shrine to it. I wouldn't really describe that as the sexiest thing ever, would you?

I'm saying you can be as attractive as humanly possible but if you dress like crap or have no pride in the cleanliness of your clothing, you become as offputting to the average woman as an adult man whose home is covered in little pastel colored ponies.

Yes. i do it.

The way presented, no. I agree very much that the level of fanaticism displayed by some is very odd to say the least as well that many take to extremely creepy levels, and I would be a hard pressed to find a chick that gets revved by MLP. I can identify as a brony, simply meaning I like the show and have a couple shirts; but the levels that you describe would be extremely off putting. However that is generalizing a large portion of the fanbase, and I would disagree vehemently liking a show inherently makes one unattractive.

Obviously though, you're talking along the lines of the basement dwelling obsessive odd duck that incorporates the show into every aspect of their life. In which I agree.

Either way, I also agree with the base statement.

Top pic is how I dress for work. Bottom pic is how I dress casually. Perhaps a bit more t-shirt at home. The wife likes it.

Actually, yeah, I dress almost exactly like the guy in the second picture. My main style consists of jeans, a T-shirt and a plaid over shirt. I didn't know I was being fashionable though, that is just what everyone wears in my area (a small, less than wealthy town).