Which one of two tvs should I stick with?Please help...

Alright so right now on me I have two hdtvs only thing is both of the bulbs went out and they need to be replaced.

Why do I have two tvs?Friend gave me this one:

http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-HLN437W-Widescreen-Projection-Technology/dp/B00009NFEP

Because the bulb went out and he is buying a new tv altogether.

The second tv :

http://www.amazon.com/Magnavox-37MF337B-37-LCD-HDTV/dp/B000OWKIRE

I bought at Target only because it cost me $525 with a 3 year warrenty.Only thing is it was the display one so it went out after a month.

So my problem is should I

A.Fix the samsung and get my money back for the second one?

B.Stick with the Magnavox and keep dust on it?

C.Fix them both and sell one.

D.Be an a$$hole and fix both and sell them both for a profit?

C and D are kinda a joke but I would like to know which tv is overall better for both gaming and movie watching?

Thank you can anyone else give their opinion?

This belongs in the A/V board.