This game should receive 10.0 for good concept, but bad implementation. Graphics (even for Wii) is Horrible.
1. I'm Nintendo Wii Fan
2. Tennis Fan
Since i like motion controls, I am very sad to see Top Spin 4 as bad game, it is bad because 2k games could not implement very good motion control concept.
Graphics of the game is just horrible, arenas are fine, but everything else is bad, player textures looks like PSX one. blocky..
There is nothing worse in tennis game when you can not execute or try to execute tennis move you want, if you try tutorial you will figure out what am i talking about.
Let's take example of successful tennis game like Virtua Tennis 4, you got 3 buttons: 3 different moves (slice, lob, ...) but in Top Spin you need to WAVE with your wii mote to execute one of those mentioned... and in 30% of moves you will execute different one you wanted.
CONCLUSION:
-Bad Graphics
-Broken Controls
+Wide choice of game arenas, minigames
+Good concept, when i played Wii Sports Tennis i hoped that
someone will develop advanced version of it, this is a try, but a BAD one.