AWESOME!!
It not often happens that you come across such a beautifully crafted game with a great story and a hit-on-the-head (as in very very positive) plot-twist that you still remember years and years after... A game that makes it hard for you to uninstall it even after you finish it, an experience that you remember years after playing and a milestone for crafting and survival-horror genre in the gaming industry. A game after which you'll judge all others and will find the most out there to be lacking and behind.
Graphics: 8.5 - Good
Atmosphere: 10 - Brilliant
Story: 10 - That plot-twist there, fantastic
Survival/Horror: 10 - just perfect; not too easy, not too hard, always a challenge and as far as the horror go, what more can you desire than to experience going through a pitch black cave full of monsters with only a lighter in hand.
Crafting: 8.5
Sound: 10 - less is sometimes more - Perfect