Good game, and would've been great if it wasn't so short.
However, the main complaint that I have with Soul Reaver 2 is it's length. The game is just too damn short! I beat it in probably 12-15 hours, and that's the conservative estimate. The game starts moving along at a good space, and the story is starting to unfold, when suddenly it ends. The abruptness with which the game actually ends caught me completely off guard...I sat staring at my screen wondering "Is that it? It surely can't be over, I haven't been playing for that long!" But alas, it was over. Not only that, but during the "final boss fight" (if it can even be called that), you're invincible...you can't lose the final battle. While I understand the move from a plot perspective (and I don't want to give away too much), from a gameplay perspective it just seemed extremely cheap.
The game probably deserves a better rating than I gave it, and it really is a fun game while you're playing it. And it's not the difficult puzzles that I have a major problem with...yeah, some of them seemed annoyingly tough, but that can be overlooked. I just can't give a game that ends so suddenly a high score, however.