Jeez, this sucks.
Story: Why would Sega do this? Sonic doesn't belong in the story of Alladin. Why, just why? I don't remember the evil genie, Jafar being named Erazor, having a giant, freaking sword, and being defeated by a ridiculously fast blue hedgehog. What, Sega couldn't copy freakin' Disney? 3/10
Controls: The controls suck. The steering wheel style of control makes Sonic and the Secret Rings seem more like a driving game than an action-adventure, platformer. 3/10
Graphics: The only slightly good graphics are during the cutscenes when it looks like a tattered storybook. The level designs are tedious and aggrivating. The extra missions are very hard and get extremely repetitive. 4/10
Difficulty: I already told you that the game gets too hard when you get to the extra missions. The main problem with that is the crappy controls! Say you have to go through the levels without breaking any barrels. The crappy controls make Sonic steer to a failed mission. 2/10
Overall, this game needs serious improvement. Sonic has had a lot of crappy games in the past few years. If it weren't for Sonic Rush I would have had all of my Sonic games cremated. This game just plain sucks. 4/10. Jeez, Sega... why?