Short, but that's ok.
This episode of Sam and Max sounds, looks, plays and smells exactly like the first episode but it has a different story. Being a fan of the original Sam and Max Hit the Road, I feel they have captured the humor very well. The new voice actors have also grown on me.
If you are reading this you are probably aware that this set of Sam and Max games are sold by episodes. You can purchase them one at a time or all at once with the promise of a CD after they are all out. Episodic content is not for everyone. I happen to enjoy getting little morsels of content every so often. Most reviewers complain that the game is too short. When looked at individually, yes, they are short. But once all of the episodes are put together , they will make for a very reasonable adventure game.
If you are a casual gamer who is looking for a funny adventure game, you should consider Sam and Max.