Descent: Freespace - The Great War Review

It's a noble effort to both cannibalize the best elements of classics of the genre and also provide a number of refreshing innovations.

Over the years a variety of space-combat simulations have been released, but none of them has been as polished or even remotely as interesting as LucasArts' X-Wing series or Origin Systems' Wing Commander series, both of which are still going strong. With the enticing capabilities of 3D graphics hardware support and a general resurgence in science fiction themes, it was only a matter of time before gaming companies would, once again, try to break LucasArts' and Origin Systems' collective stranglehold over the genre. At last a worthy challenger has arrived. Descent: Freespace is one of a number of recently released or announced space-sim titles from developers who are better known for creating successful gaming series in other genres. But while MicroProse's X-COM Interceptor is a fading memory, and little anticipation has developed for Accolade's Star Con (formerly Star Control 4), Volition has carefully crafted Descent: Freespace to provide a welcome mix of compelling graphics, plot, and gameplay.

When the plot of Descent: Freespace begins, the ever-warmongering Terrans are in the midst of a 14-year misunderstanding with the Vasudans. While the Vasudans and the Terrans are fairly evenly matched, they quickly put aside their differences when a third race appears, the technologically superior Shivans. Although a rebel Vasudan faction continues to harass the new Vasudan-Terran alliance, the main threat comes from the Shivans and their monstrous capital ship, the Lucifer. From the opening animated cutscene, Descent: Freespace does an excellent job at maintaining the aura of the Shivans as a mysterious, unstoppable force. When you first encounter the Shivans, you won't even be able to target their jet-black ships, and the weapons that seemed so impressive against the Vasudans will barely make an impression on the Shivans and their seemingly invulnerable shields. At first you have to avoid direct conflicts with the superior Shivans and instead embark on missions to steal their technology in order to improve the capabilities of your ships. In fact, there's a real X-COM feel to the game, as you uncover the mysteries of the Shivans and constantly improve the technology of your ships and weaponry.

Very little about Descent: Freespace is entirely original, but the developers did an admirable job at extracting the best features from previous spaces sims. Everything from the "sink the behemoth" branching plot to the stylish interface, mission briefings, and graphics appears to be plucked from other games of the genre, but improved. In many ways, the graphics closely resemble those used in Wing Commander Prophecy and make especially good use of colored lighting, shielding, lens flare, and engine blast effects. The graphics are particularly impressive in later missions, when immense capital ships patrol through colored nebulas and asteroid fields, swarmed by hordes of attacking fighters and bombers until they are wracked by massive explosions. You won't have time to stand around and admire the fireworks, however, as the shock waves from exploding capital ships are particularly deadly in this game. It's a nod to realism that increases the immersiveness of the game, especially if you're using a force-feedback joystick.

Combat in Descent: Freespace also more closely resembles the fast-paced, missile-blasting, afterburner sliding frag fests of the Wing Commander series than the World War II style of combat favored by the Star Wars sims. Descent: Freespace is probably the most missile-intensive game yet seen in the genre, but fortunately single missile hits aren't usually too destructive to your ship. Afterburners can only be utilized in short bursts, requiring you to tactically reserve them for when they are most useful. You can adjust the power levels of your shields, engines, and weapons, but unlike games such as X-Wing vs. Tie Fighter, which constantly require you to juggle those settings, the ships in Descent: Freespace appear to be admirably powered, and you'll rarely feel the need to adjust settings to boost power in a particular area. Wingmen AI is excellent in some respects but poor in others. You have unprecedented control over your wingmen, and they'll capably respond to an order to take out the weapons system or engine of a capital ship, but they also won't hesitate to mow you down if you happen to fly in between them and your target. One handy feature is that you'll get a communications warning whenever an enemy ship is attacking you from behind. It's a shame you don't get a similar warning when one of your maniacal wingmen decides to gleefully launch a spread of missiles at a target inches in front of your ship.

The customizable interface of Descent: Freespace is outstanding - easily the best yet seen in the genre. The interface was clearly designed to make useful information, such as the status of escorted ships, the direction and the distance of approaching missiles, mission objectives, and the condition of your wingmen, constantly available on your screen. Find some of that information unnecessary or obstructive? Then remove it from the interface entirely, or set it to only appear when there is a change in its status. You can also change the color of the interface and control its relative brightness. Descent: Freespace's interface is among the best I've seen in any game.

The plot of Descent: Freespace advances through animated cutscenes, periodic "news" updates on the status of the war, as well as through mission briefings and the occasional scripted mission event. Overall, these methods combine to provide a compelling, if somewhat disjointed, storyline. But it's lacking in depth. Your wingmen lack names or distinguishing identities, and you never get to see the leaders or other personalities composing the various factions in the game. Aside from an effective animated introduction and some obligatory ending scenes, there is only a handful of animated scenes in the game, most of which appear fairly early on in the storyline. The remainder of the cutscenes consist solely of panning skylines, while a female narrator provides some additional background mythology on the history of the Shivans and their possible role in the universe. It seems as if the developers didn't quite have the time to finish an otherwise very polished single-player game.

There are approximately 30 single-player missions in the branching campaign and 20 multiplayer missions. The mission objectives are nicely varied and include "kill 'em all" missions, stealthy inspection missions, a mission that resembles a giant game of Asteroids, and some epic capital ship confrontations near the end of the game. Descent: Freespace automatically saves after each campaign mission, and you can't independently save the game, which is a bit disappointing, since it prevents you from exploring the various campaign "branches" without restarting the entire campaign. While the developers may have opted for such a system in order to encourage gamers to replay the campaign, I suspect that most gamers are reluctant to accept unsuccessful mission results and tend to play space sims through in a fairly linear fashion. There's just something inherently unsatisfying about tanking a mission just so you can see a different plot thread.

The list of additional features Descent: Freespace purports to support is unsurpassed, but unfortunately they don't all work very well. A free mission editor is included, allowing you to create your own missions and trade them with other players, which may significantly extend the replayability of the game. Support for force-feedback joysticks is implemented extremely well - the controller will effectively shake when you apply an afterburner burst, each type of weapon has a different feel, and directional hits leave you with no question as to the location of your attacker. You can personalize the picture of your pilot and can communicate with other human players in real time over microphones - provided you have sufficient bandwidth.

Multiplayer support for up to 12 players is included either through a TCP/IP network or the Internet through the free Parallax Online servers. Parallax Online keeps detailed pilot statistics and is an extremely streamlined service, with an intuitive interface and seamless integration with the multiplayer interface of Descent: Freespace. Unfortunately, even after two patches, most gamers will find a multiplayer game of Descent: Freespace over the Internet to be completely unplayable due to lag. Unlike first-person shooter games, where an environment's walls and a player's line of sight will naturally limit the number of objects that a client has to keep track of at any one time, the open areas of space-combat simulations have historically proven very difficult to use as online multiplayer arenas. Multiplayer support was eventually removed from Wing Commander Prophecy because Origin wasn't satisfied that it would work well, and even earlier in that game's development Internet multiplayer support was removed. Even X-Wing vs. Tie Fighter limits multiplayer support to four players over Microsoft's Internet Gaming Zone. In that context, it's astonishing that Interplay and Volition were, almost until the game was released, advertising Descent: Freespace as capable of supporting 16 players online, when in fact the retail version of the game is currently incapable of even adequately supporting two players each using 56K modems. While the development team continues to work on patches to improve the game's online performance (a third was released as this review goes to print), the advertised multiplayer features may have been overly ambitious, and seriously misleading, given the current state of the game.

Still, unless you are only looking for a multiplayer dogfighting area (in which case you'll be doubly disappointed, since deathmatch support was removed late in development entirely, in favor of cooperative and team vs. team missions) there's a lot to like about Descent: Freespace. It's a noble effort to both cannibalize the best elements of classics of the genre and also provide a number of refreshing innovations. While Descent: Freespace isn't quite the standout game it could have been, it's a welcome step in the right direction for the genre. Highly recommended.

The Good
The Bad
About GameSpot's Reviews

About the Author

Descent: Freespace - The Great War More Info

  • First Released May 31, 1998
    • Amiga
    • PC
    It's a noble effort to both cannibalize the best elements of classics of the genre and also provide a number of refreshing innovations.
    Average Rating832 Rating(s)
    Please Sign In to rate Descent: Freespace - The Great War
    Developed by:
    Hyperion Entertainment, Volition Inc.
    Published by:
    Hyperion Entertainment, Interplay
    Sci-Fi, Space
    Content is generally suitable for all ages. May contain minimal cartoon, fantasy or mild violence and/or infrequent use of mild language.
    Animated Violence, Mild Language