I think this is going to have to be one of the times I overlook review scores and just play because I am huge Lost fan. The same thing happened with 24: The Game a few years back, I knew it was a mediocre game that was just a bunch to minigames dressed up to look serious, but I played it once anyways because the story was on par with a season of the show, which is my single favorite one over Lost.

...and I don't watch it for its realism or anything, so don't hate.