It depends on what you want. For trading in the XBOX 360 system alone you get $70 no matter what kind it is and then with the 20GB HDD and all the other parts your total is like $140 for trade in. I just reserved the RE5 Bundle yesterday at GameStop even though I already have 4 other 360s( ELITE, 2x HALO 3 Special Edition, Pro). I also have money to burn and I like collecting those special consoles so who cares. Like I said it depends on what you want so you can't get others to sway your opinion because in the end it's all down to you. If you think $140 is a fair trade in and really want the console then go for it. I think it's fair. Red is also my favorite color.MJ_SPARTAN