Okay here's the end of this discussion right here. The reason Trophies are better than Achievements (slightly!) is simple: Trophies show skill. See Achievements are just points that you rack up for doing whatever the game requires. The difference between completing an easy goal and a hard one is that the hard ones will give you more points. BUT a person can be an achievement whore and just play a lot of crappy games or do a lot of the easier tasks and still get a lot of points right? That's not a show of skill.
Trophies on the other hand come in levels. A silver is worth a lot more than a bronze, a gold is worth more than...you get it. That means a person with a few golds (or a platinum) in just a few games will have a higher level than a person with dozens of bronzes across a lot of different games. Your number (level) is still just as pointless as the one on XBL since you don't win anything, but at least this number shows not just that you played a lot of games, but also that you worked hard on those games.
One more thing: Home. First of all, trophies are viewable from the XMB, so you don't even need home to see and compare. Second, Home will have 3D representations of the more prestigious trophies (most likely the golds and platinums). So yes the reward is still pointless but it at least does more than just give you a number, plus it takes your skil at specific games into account. That makes it slightly better.
Log in to comment