dude it tottaly depends on wut u like. if u like blood and lots of violence and buying cars guns ect go with scarface, but if you like the godfather movie,challenging gameplay, and fun and intresting story missions go with godfather. but like some of the other ppls said buy both cus thats wut i did and i play'em both way to much and i havnet gotten tired of either of em. but if you realy want my opinion i would prolly say scarface because you get to buy a but load of stuff like cars, guns, furniture, henchmen, exotics (wich is just realy expensive stuff), investments,boats, and some other things but one thing that i didnt like about the game

you couldnt buy a real tiger

but anyway ya go with scarface