I'm new to Gamespot, so I'm not familiar with Tom Mc Shea, but I don't see why everyone here is bashing the dude. Are you guys actually reading his review? Yes, he gave Bioshock Infinite a rating that would indicate a less than average video game (which is tough to agree with when the game is indeed playable and is quite astonishing even if only on a purely aesthetic level), but his criticisms regarding the game's story, its combat, and why those two primary elements clash with one another are entirely valid. It seems like many of you are simply too hung up on the score, rather than what's being said in the review.