Disappointing when you compare to the console versions, but still the best hockey experience on the PC
Gameplay : The gameplay is actually quite good and it feels more like real hockey than any game in the series in quite a while. Goals are very satisfying when you get them, but it is very frustrating when you accidentally shoot the puck because the skill stick appears to be broken and "clunky". The AI is very challenging at times and manages to make some good plays.
Graphics : The graphics are extremely disappointing. While not that bad overall, in 2009 (or even 2004) they look very bad. The game does not support wide screen resolutions (which is at the very least, unacceptable) and even at the highest resolution at high details the graphics are jagged and aliased. It looks almost like a detailed version of NHL 98 if you can believe it. Of course everything is extremely detailed and well done so it doesn't detract from the game too much, but it is very disappointing.
Sound : The sound effects are very good and makes you feel like you are "on the ice". Commentary is a little annoying at times and seems to repeat itself more often than in previous years (again, regression rather than progression, is at the very least unacceptable), but overall it is not too bad.
Value : At about $10 right now, i would say that it is a better value than NHL 09. Its obvious that EA has focused on making their next gen games on the consoles rather than PC, which is understandable because a lot of clueless people with underpowered PCs would be complaining about the system requirements if they put a next gen game on PC, but is very annoying nonetheless. It is still, however a very fun game if you take it for what it is and the best hockey experience on PC.