In my opinion it deserves a 9-10! It has the best combat in any RPG ever!

User Rating: 10 | Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning PS3
This game is amazing! For some reason gamespot didn't give it that much of a good rating, but I though it was brilliant. It has a immersieve world, with a lot of towns, loads of side quests and interesting factions. The story isn't the most memorial, but it's still decent. It probably has the best combat any RPG. It has an awesome class system, which lets you pick a straight forward class like a mage, archer or warrior. Or a hybrid, like battle-mage, nightblade.etc. A lot of people are comparing this against the Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, in my opinion it's not as good as Skyrim. But if your a hardcore RPG player, you should definitely try this! (There is a demo on steam, XBL and PSN). It also has more useful loot than Skyrim, which is awesome!

Rating: 9.5-10 (can't really decide) I only have 10 hours worth of game play and I love it!

Console played on- PS3