Which would you rather have, Fallout 3 GOTY, Brutal Legend, or Borderlands

topic

Borderlands

Borderlands, because I already got fallout with all the DLCs

Probably bordelands, it's more intressting and new at the same time

i am most excited in this order

brutal legend > borderlands > fallout 3 (did not like game at all, everything looked... the same)

But I believe borderlands will have higher production values than either, I am just more excited for Brutal.

Borderlands. Already have Fallout and Brutal Legend holds no interest for me.

Borderlands, because I already have Brutal Legend, and Fallout 3 is terrible.

Borderlands, because I already have Brutal Legend, and Fallout 3 is terrible.

TJORLY

Compared to the previous Fallouts (not BOS!) its terrible.

*SPOILERS*

• By the time you're level 30, your a walking god. Nothing can kill you.
• The story was terrible to the extreme. You dont even need a massive purifier to get radiation out of water for crying out loud.
• None of my decisions had any effect whatsoever. For example, the option to put the virus in the water. What happens when I do that? You can only drink a certain amount of water before dieing. Why aren't most people dead? I left the president alive, in hopes that I could join him in Broken Steel. Oh wait! They made it mandatory he was destroyed.
• The repair skill. It isn't fun to have to fix a gun after every 3 shots. Double so if the gun is unique.
• The terrible storyline wasn't even original. They just rehashed the storys of FO1 and 2, minus the good writing. How hard would it've been to make a new antagonist?

Compared to the previous Fallouts (not BOS!) its terrible.

*SPOILERS*

• By the time you're level 30, your a walking god. Nothing can kill you.
• The story was terrible to the extreme. You dont even need a massive purifier to get radiation out of water for crying out loud.
• None of my decisions had any effect whatsoever. For example, the option to put the virus in the water. What happens when I do that? You can only drink a certain amount of water before dieing. Why aren't most people dead? I left the president alive, in hopes that I could join him in Broken Steel. Oh wait! They made it mandatory he was destroyed.
• The repair skill. It isn't fun to have to fix a gun after every 3 shots. Double so if the gun is unique.
• The terrible storyline wasn't even original. They just rehashed the storys of FO1 and 2, minus the good writing. How hard would it've been to make a new antagonist?

TJORLY

Fallout 3> all other Fallouts

It was hands down the best game in the series.

• In most games, by the time you reach max level you are supposed to be like a God. Ever had a level 20 character in D&D?
• It isn't any worse than the other stories in the franchise. The first one has you galavanting around the wasteland looking for a water purifer chip. Woo-wee, that is epic.
• The other games didn't even have any real decisions.
• It is supposed to make you feel like a survivor struggling to get by. It forces you to scavenge and look for supplies to keep you gear in check.
• You pretty much repeated point 2.

Anyway, I put a pre-order on Borderlands, so there is my answer.

Brutal legend for sure. I havent cheked out borderlands to much, so not sure on that game. I have fallout 3 and all the DLC .

Fallout 3> all other Fallouts

It was hands down the best game in the series.

• In most games, by the time you reach max level you are supposed to be like a God. Ever had a level 20 character in D&D?
• It isn't any worse than the other stories in the franchise. The first one has you galavanting around the wasteland looking for a water purifer chip. Woo-wee, that is epic.
• The other games didn't even have any real decisions.
• It is supposed to make you feel like a survivor struggling to get by. It forces you to scavenge and look for supplies to keep you gear in check.
• You pretty much repeated point 2.

Anyway, I put a pre-order on Borderlands, so there is my answer.

heysharpshooter

• Have you even played any other RPGS before? You're not supposed to be a god like being with all the skills maxed out.
• I wasn't clear on this point. I meant the writing itself was terrible.
• They did actually. Granted, the consequences were extremely minorbut still. The original games were never touted to have consequences for your choices. FO3 was. If I poison a water supply, I expect people to die. Not someone to complain how the water tastes weird.
• What kind of 'survivor struggling to get by' has enough bullets to stock an armoury, and 200 stimpacks with them? And what kind of gunbreaks after ten shots?
• Not really. They could've at least been original with the storyline.
• A new point! There was a pathetic excuse of a final boss.

Borderlands....BL dosnt look interesting and already got all dlc for fallout

[QUOTE="heysharpshooter"]

Fallout 3> all other Fallouts

It was hands down the best game in the series.

• In most games, by the time you reach max level you are supposed to be like a God. Ever had a level 20 character in D&D?
• It isn't any worse than the other stories in the franchise. The first one has you galavanting around the wasteland looking for a water purifer chip. Woo-wee, that is epic.
• The other games didn't even have any real decisions.
• It is supposed to make you feel like a survivor struggling to get by. It forces you to scavenge and look for supplies to keep you gear in check.
• You pretty much repeated point 2.

Anyway, I put a pre-order on Borderlands, so there is my answer.

TJORLY

• Have you even played any other RPGS before? You're not supposed to be a god like being with all the skills maxed out.
• I wasn't clear on this point. I meant the writing itself was terrible.
• They did actually. Granted, the consequences were extremely minorbut still. The original games were never touted to have consequences for your choices. FO3 was. If I poison a water supply, I expect people to die. Not someone to complain how the water tastes weird.
• What kind of 'survivor struggling to get by' has enough bullets to stock an armoury, and 200 stimpacks with them? And what kind of gunbreaks after ten shots?
• Not really. They could've at least been original with the storyline.
• A new point! There was a pathetic excuse of a final boss.

I am not going to get into a point by point war with you. IMO, Fallout 3 was hands down the best game of the series. You can disagree if you want, but the points you make sound ridiculous. You even admit that none of the Fallout games decisions had any real bearing on the game world. Also, as far as I know there was no "Boss Fight" at the end.

IMO, the original Fallouts were highly over-rated. But it's whatever.

Brutal Legend.

Or maybe Fallout 3 so I can throw it in a fire.

Borderlands

I have no interest in Fallout 3, so either Borderlands or Brutal Legend.

1) Brutal Legend
2) Borderlands
3) Fallout 3: GOTY

I love Fallout 3 but I need something new like it so Borderlands comes the closest so I'll be buying that this month and maybe pick up the GOTY edition and Brutal Legends later during the holiday sales.

well already got fallout 3 anddont really plan to get the other to but i suppose borderlands looks interesting

Brutal Legend and Borderlands are equal priority. I already have FO3 and I don't care about the GOTY edition.

I've already fully played Fallout 3, and I'm eager to see what Borderlands is like, so I'd go for Borderlands. Brutal Legend doesn't really appeal to me

tough choice. here's my opinion on all of them:

Brutal Legend:

the demo was amazing! I really loved it. but I have yet to see what the multiplayer will be like. so from what I've seen, it's looks like a single player I'll love at first, but get tired of it soon.

Borderlands:

looks to be GOTY. large, open world to roam about in with TONS of loot and weapons! I can make several different characters and build up on all those characters over time.

Fallout 3 GOTY:

one of the best single player games ever. with the free DLC coming with it, I feellike I'm getting an extra 40+ hours of game time added in. although, the world seems lonely and it got a little boring having to game by myself.

of all these, I choose Boderlands. I loved Fallout 3, and this game looks to be all of that with 4 player co-op, and a lot better!

Brutal Legend > Borderlands > FO3 GOTY Edition.

borderlands. but thats bc i already have Fallout 3 n all the DLC.

Well I own the regualr Fallout 3 and have purchased all the DLC so that leaves Borderlands and Brutal Legends. Probably Borderlands because it has so many weapons and 4 player online Co-op, although the Brutal Legend demo was wicked fun.

Borderlands, because I already got fallout with all the DLCs

Dordledum

Borderlands, Fallout 3 GotY Edition(PC), Brutal Legend, Fallout 3 GotY Edition(360)

Already have fallout 3 and is best of the series and should of won GoTY, looking forward to brutal legend.

Fallout 3 GOTY for sure...

Brutal Legends looks crappy and Borderlands is a maybe.

Fallout 3 GotY will be my first non-sports game purchase since Unreal Tournament 3. :)

Borderlands, because I already got fallout with all the DLCs

Dordledum

same here

1. Brutal Legend

2. Borderlands

3. Wont be getting Fallout 3 GOTY

Borderlands

Brutal Legend because I already have Fallout 3 and I need to beat it before I play another game (Borderlands) of the same type.

Fallout 3 GOTY. Already preordered it (which is rare for me).