Could you explain a bit more about the leader rankings idea?siberian142Well it could be some kind of leaderboard or something that would rank all of Gamespot's top leaders of all time. It would obviously be a bit biased depending on who would end up creating it, but nonetheless it may be interesting and spark some interest. Also you could do something like ranking the current union leaders around nowadays and based on how good of a job they're doing give them ratings. Actually thinking on it, giving leaders ratings on how they're doing with feedback would be a great idea in my opinion! It would be beneficial to them and could help them improve. If you do this however, I'd like to see ratings be brutally honest even if they may seem kinda mean, otherwise it would be pointless since it wouldn't offer proper feedback on what a leader needs to improve on.
-Leader of the month spotlight should return.julian_jr
For guides, I was thinking of revamping the one I made a while ago for use in this union. Not sure I'd be the best pick when it comes to making a guide on how to be a good leader or officer, so perhaps someone else could give it a try if they wanted too?siberian142I'd be up for that. As for my ideas: I'd like to see the union become like an actual council of unions. So for example, the union should facilitate discussion between union leaders on union reforms and the state of unions on GameSpot. As suggested, I like the idea of holding union interviews and perhaps making any union guides that we can think of. As to whether these ideas will work or not, there's only one way to find out: try them. ;)
[QUOTE="siberian142"]Could you explain a bit more about the leader rankings idea?julian_jrWell it could be some kind of leaderboard or something that would rank all of Gamespot's top leaders of all time. It would obviously be a bit biased depending on who would end up creating it, but nonetheless it may be interesting and spark some interest. Without a way to properly rank unions, I don't think it would really be fair to all the other unions if we started to rank them based on total activity or their statistics. I'd much prefer putting unions that do a great job at running things in the spotlight here.
One thing that would be nice is if people were allowed to post comments in the homepage. The way things are currently set up doesn't allow for any conversation in the homepage, hence making the homepage slightly less useful.julian_jrI was actually thinking of making the homepage more of an aesthetic. The forums definitely garner more attention, so I think keeping discussion based solely on the forums is more effective. But if people think otherwise.
That could possibly clutter the entire board eventually, based on how frequent homepage updates are posted.julian_jrUnions need sub-boards. :P
More frequent telegrams and reaching out to unions. Right now let's be realistic, this place is pretty dead, and it's going to remain that way until the union starts to reach out to other unions and gamespot.julian_jrHow would you suggest we do that? I've been thinking of ways to reach out to other unions and become more involved with them, but not many of the ideas I've came up with seemed like they'd work all that well.
I suggest that union endorsements be looked over and reviewed, there are several unions that are dead, or may not be as active anymore and are still endorsed. If I remember correctly, aunion being endorsed means they serve as a useful and reliable resource for the entire GameSpot community. I have seen some unions that are endorsed and are not very active and are not very up to date.
I know people will ask for examples, so here are some:
The Final Fantasy Experience Union was last updated in news in beginning of September. Compared to The Final Fantasy Fans Union, which last updated their news October 4, 2011, and does updates every 5 days or so, and are WAY more active and involve the community more.
The Resident Evil Union has not even been active AT ALL since June and July, their last news update in February! Unfortunately, no other union in that category is active either.
And The Unreal Tournament Fans Union also is a dead union. There is also no replacement for that one though.Â
And these are just the endorsed unions, I don't even want to go into the Official Unions because they also have problems most likely. These endorsed unions really need to be reviewed, because some unions do not deserve them at all, and some unions just can't keep up with other unions that are putting way more effort into their union.Â
This union doesn't have that kind of power to control endorsements though.julian_jrYes I found that out this morning unfortunately, I also sent this message to the admins and staff members and posted it in he Site Feedback baord. But I just wanted to make everyone aware of the situation. :)
As Julian stated, if the union is going to be successful, it is going to take awareness that the union exists, which in turn will lead to involvement. If there is one thing that seriously contributes to raising activity in a slow union, it's recruiting. I'm talking about manual labour, hunting out users in the community, and sending them invites. If a union doesn't already have a strong base of regular members, then you need to bring in new people to diversify the community, and expand the community. This union has such great potential for recruiting, since there is little "hunting" required to find potential members. Just going through unions that are at least somewhat active, and inviting the staff, and even some of the active users of the forum could really inject some life back in here.
In defense of our FFE (Final Fantasy Experience) union, I've to confess things were not in the best condition, but now after I've been appointed as COO in the union (Temporary acting as the leader) things is going in right path again, we are still active in all senses, the union is up to date in terms of updates, the discussions are covering most of the FF news, it will take some time to reach our momentum but we are heading there, FFE has reached this elite level with hard work and commitment, the buggy telegram system is killing the unions, but I did the unthinkable and gathered all the users (5367 user) in order to send telegrams with the new method (the @ system) without the users knowing what activities are happening, the unions will get less active, but not anymore I can proudly say that we can send telegrams anytime now, we worked hard to get endorsed by GameSpot, it took years to do so, I'm doing my best to meet the high expectations from FFE, step by step we will reach there, we'll protect our endorsement no matter what, FFFU is nothing compared to what we do at our best, we are a big union lvl 20 at the moment, with 5300+ users we are one of the biggest unions on GameSpot, the next line will sound epic, we will protect our union and our endorsement with our souls.
A plain straight out solemn attack at the FFFU I see... well, I will most definetly be sharing this with my administration team. If it is a competition that you are looking for, than we will give you one...In defense of our FFE (Final Fantasy Experience) union, I've to confess things were not in the best condition, but now after I've been appointed as COO in the union (Temporary acting as the leader) things is going in right path again, we are still active in all senses, the union is up to date in terms of updates, the discussions are covering most of the FF news, it will take some time to reach our momentum but we are heading there, FFE has reached this elite level with hard work and commitment, the buggy telegram system is killing the unions, but I did the unthinkable and gathered all the users (5367 user) in order to send telegrams with the new method (the @ system) without the users knowing what activities are happening, the unions will get less active, but not anymore I can proudly say that we can send telegrams anytime now, we worked hard to get endorsed by GameSpot, it took years to do so, I'm doing my best to meet the high expectations from FFE, step by step we will reach there, we'll protect our endorsement no matter what, FFFU is nothing compared to what we do at our best, we are a big union lvl 20 at the moment, with 5300+ users we are one of the biggest unions on GameSpot, the next line will sound epic, we will protect our union and our endorsement with our souls.
SQUALL20XX
A plain straight out solemn attack at the FFFU I see... well, I will most definetly be sharing this with my administration team. If it is a competition that you are looking for, than we will give you one...maniamsmart
Comparing unions is not attacking them, if so then you have quite attacked FFE, what I'm looking for? Of course a fair competition without campaigning against other unions ;).
[QUOTE="maniamsmart"]A plain straight out solemn attack at the FFFU I see... well, I will most definetly be sharing this with my administration team. If it is a competition that you are looking for, than we will give you one...SQUALL20XX
Comparing unions is not attacking them, if so then you have quite attacked FFE, what I'm looking for? Of course a fair competition without campaigning against other unions ;).
I may have compared FFFU and FFE several times, but I have NEVER said somthing like you said where I completely blatantly downgrade one union:
"FFFU is nothing compared to what we do at our best..."
And NEVER have I solemnly made one post with a huge paragraph bragging about the FFFU and saying that we are the best and better than all others and started listing our stats like you did.Â
How about a compilation of all the most active unions, a list with them all split by genre and linked to the union homepage, that way it could make it easier to find a good active union?uas-2001There is only about 15-20 unions or so that are active on GameSpot, but I like the idea.
Yeah sorry about that, I looked around and there are more than 15-20 lol.
I'll gladyly help out with this project though :DÂ
Well once they've been placed under a category they wouldn't be listed in any particular order, maybe just alphabetic.uas-2001Alphabetical or random order (such as in the order they were added) seems to be the fairest way. Unless we come up with some sort of a rating system, but that too would be biased and would require a lot of work to maintain. Either way, good to see you getting the idea started uas. ;)
This place is dead to the point where it has no posts at all occurring daily anymore. julian_jr
Probably because they hand out 30 day suspensions to one of the few dedicated union leaders that are left. I'll be leaving GS shortly as a result and no doubt my union will die off. Good work GS! *high five*
I think Siberian has officially given up, there is a stickied thread about it I'm afraid.uas-2001If he has given up then he should give up leadership rather than just claim the union is dead and close the place down. He's hurting the union rather than helping it at this point.
[QUOTE="uas-2001"]I think Siberian has officially given up, there is a stickied thread about it I'm afraid.julian_jrIf he has given up then he should give up leadership rather than just claim the union is dead and close the place down. He's hurting the union rather than helping it at this point.
Exactly what I said in the revival thread. :P If the leader gives up, but the officers and some recruits don't give up, then why close it down?
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment