Food for thoughts:
- Graphics can be tied with art direction. Not every game needs to be realistic to be called as good graphics.
- While immersion can be tied with gameplay, there are several people online that place immersion above the other, so I create a whole different category for this poll.
There's plenty of situations, mostly gameplay and story come first for me, raw graphics are just icing on the cake. And it's not that gameplay and story need to be equal for an individual games, but it depends on the game. I couldn't care less about the story in Dark Souls, but the gameplay is great. I couldn't care less about the gameplay in The Witcher 3 because the story is great. So a game needs to have at least one of those be great for me to enjoy it.
Gameplay=Story>Graphics for me.