Now that both are out for a while and most got to play either or both.
Which one, in your personal opinion, you think is the better game (overall, i.e. gameplay, story, enjoyment, etc..)?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Now that both are out for a while and most got to play either or both.
Which one, in your personal opinion, you think is the better game (overall, i.e. gameplay, story, enjoyment, etc..)?
I like Dark Souls better, but I voted Skyrim because it was made in America.
DerpyMcDerp
Are you kidding me?
Anyways, I have yet to play either game. I might get Skyrim when the inevitable GOTY edition comes out next year.
boring you say yes so very boring I decided to repeat the so called dungeons three times so far and spend 200 hours on a character.This again?
*sigh*
Dark Souls is a boring dungeon crawler, so I choose Skyrim.
Tikeio
Now that both are out for a while and most got to play either or both.
Which one, in your personal opinion, you think is the better game (overall, i.e. gameplay, story, enjoyment, etc..)?
Mystery_Writer
I think Dark SOuls has no equal, Skyrim is a little better Oblivion, as generic and boring
Dark Souls is the best game of all time imo, there is no comparisson
boring you say yes so very boring I decided to repeat the so called dungeons three times so far and spend 200 hours on a character.[QUOTE="Tikeio"]
This again?
*sigh*
Dark Souls is a boring dungeon crawler, so I choose Skyrim.
parkurtommo
Some people are better at repetitive mindless tasks then others.
boring you say yes so very boring I decided to repeat the so called dungeons three times so far and spend 200 hours on a character.[QUOTE="parkurtommo"]
[QUOTE="Tikeio"]
This again?
*sigh*
Dark Souls is a boring dungeon crawler, so I choose Skyrim.
tenaka2
Some people are better at repetitive mindless tasks then others.
Never before has a game had me FEARING death as much as Demon's Souls. Boring? It's almost a horror game at times that has me on the edge of my seat. Every corner could spell doom if you're not careful.Finished Skyrim yesterday, and the last few hours I was forcing myself to play. It was so extremely easy that I didn't even have to use potions, even though my character is rubbish and below level 20.
Finishing Dark Souls on the other hand was one of the greatest feelings I've ever had in gaming.
Hmm try a fist-only character in terms of damagedealing. I have a khajiit fist-only, with some sneak and illusion, and a tiny bit of restoration. The game started easy, now it remains hard for me, though I have to admit I'm not near the end yet.Finished Skyrim yesterday, and the last few hours I was forcing myself to play. It was so extremely easy that I didn't even have to use potions, even though my character is rubbish and below level 20.
Finishing Dark Souls on the other hand was one of the greatest feelings I've ever had in gaming.
KiZZo1
Dark Souls, I can see why people would prefer the structure of Skyrim more, but I prefer the more compact and action oriented gameplay of Dark Souls.
Dark Souls was extremely addictive for a while, i honestly found the game to be very good...The Elder Scrolls just doesn't attract me as a franchise and Skyrim is no exception, not to mention the bugs.
skyrim easily. dark souls is insanely overrated. its boring, its frustrating and as far as i could tell it had no story. didnt finish it though because i got tired of grinding through the same area for an hour only to make no progress. game is too punishing to be any funmems_1224this.
Wow.. TC makes a thread in a Skyrim oriented community about Skyrim Vs another game. Why are skyrim fans so worked up about it scoring lower than DS? If I would make the same thread in the Dark Souls wiki people would vote for Dark Souls but will respect skirim :| so Dark Souls is more honorable and breeds a better community dark souls win in real life and GS on it's own Skyrim community in YA FACE!! muahahaha ;)
Wow.. TC makes a thread in a Skyrim oriented community about Skyrim Vs another game. Why are skyrim fans so worked up about it scoring lower than DS? If I would make the same thread in the Dark Souls wiki people would vote for Dark Souls but will respect skirim :| so Dark Souls is more honorable and breeds a better community dark souls win in real life and GS on it's own Skyrim community in YA FACE!! muahahaha ;)
Joedgabe
Welcome to SW where 90% of the topics are about things like this
Wow.. TC makes a thread in a Skyrim oriented community about Skyrim Vs another game. Why are skyrim fans so worked up about it scoring lower than DS? If I would make the same thread in the Dark Souls wiki people would vote for Dark Souls but will respect skirim :| so Dark Souls is more honorable and breeds a better community dark souls win in real life and GS on it's own Skyrim community in YA FACE!! muahahaha ;)
Joedgabe
Dark Souls and Demon souls are super popular on gamespot.. you forget the GOTY award?
[QUOTE="Joedgabe"]
Wow.. TC makes a thread in a Skyrim oriented community about Skyrim Vs another game. Why are skyrim fans so worked up about it scoring lower than DS? If I would make the same thread in the Dark Souls wiki people would vote for Dark Souls but will respect skirim :| so Dark Souls is more honorable and breeds a better community dark souls win in real life and GS on it's own Skyrim community in YA FACE!! muahahaha ;)
kozzy1234
Dark Souls and Demon souls are super popular on gamespot.. you forget the GOTY award?
Not nearly as popular as Skyrim and you know it. It's not even super popular because the hate on them is broader than it's popularity :shock: which makes it even richer that it got GOTY ;)
Dark souls is miles better then Skyrim in terms of atmosphere and combat, let's be honest here, the Skyrim combat is horrible and the atmosphere is dull because the game is extremely easy. Adding to that we have a Lulzworthy Ai and huge lack of opponents with specific skillsets. After spending quite some hours in the game the combat feels like dull clickfest. I'd rather have the Dark Souls grindfest over that.
Furthermore using crappy builds as a excuse to claim that the game isn't easy doesn't make sense, crappy builds should be crappy en good builds should be good. Sorry, but I find it sad that anyone who uses a decent build gets punished with boring, imbalanced combat.
I personally made a paladin type build, focussing on heavy armor and restoration, with the intent of using 2 handed weapons. I ended up punching my enemies to death to make the game even remotely challenging.
However!!!!! the troublesome aspect about Dark Souls is that I have to make time for the game as it requires great focus. This is completely opposed to Skyrim that is more of a game to fill the time, it quite easy going. I'm certain that i'll end up playing Skyrim more, things aren't as clear cut as they seem.
Simply said,
Dark Souls is much, much, much, better.
Skyrim is much, much, much, more likable.
boring you say yes so very boring I decided to repeat the so called dungeons three times so far and spend 200 hours on a character.[QUOTE="Tikeio"]
This again?
*sigh*
Dark Souls is a boring dungeon crawler, so I choose Skyrim.
parkurtommo
And? What exactly does that have to do with MY opinion? Not everyone likes what you like.
And yes, Dark Souls is a boring game. I shouldn't have to add "imo" at the end of my opinions.
Skyrim is the worst game of the year and is a poor man's everything. Plagued with bugs, questionable design choices and terrible immersion, VA and level design.
Dark Souls is a finely crafted game. With strong atmosphere, good combat and well designed boss fights (mostly).
Finished Skyrim yesterday, and the last few hours I was forcing myself to play. It was so extremely easy that I didn't even have to use potions, even though my character is rubbish and below level 20.
Finishing Dark Souls on the other hand was one of the greatest feelings I've ever had in gaming.
KiZZo1
lol @ thinking you can "finish" TES games.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment