Orange Box on PS3 get 9.0 on GS.

[QUOTE="Ragnarok1051"]

[QUOTE="istreakforfood"]what happened to the cows saying we dont follow gamespot anymore we should go by gamerankings :cry: ?leviathan91

Lemmings used it for Mass Effect, why can't everybody else?

Technically, cows used it first but ever since Mass Defect flopped, lems have done the same. Fanboys these days.:roll: (not referring to the persons I just quoted)

Only since what happened to Jeff. After that there is no way you can ask me to take reviews here seriously.

[QUOTE="Ragnarok1051"]

[QUOTE="istreakforfood"]what happened to the cows saying we dont follow gamespot anymore we should go by gamerankings :cry: ?istreakforfood

Lemmings used it for Mass Effect, why can't everybody else?

havent really seen it. mostly saw threads how some suggested to use gamerankings after the gertsmann ordeal or cows mostly using it cause scored higher for uncharted and ratchet.

I saw it and it made me laugh, mostly the night of the flop and the hardcore lemms who bashed the cows for using GR was doing it.

Nice! Another AAA for the PS3! :DRikusaki

how bout this.... another multiplat better on 360 :P

IGN OB PS3 review: 8.4

IGN OB 360 reivew: 9.5

.................................................................

Gamespy PS3 OB review: 3.5 / 5 (70%)

Gamespy 360 OB review: 5 / 5 (100%)

.................................................................

GS OB PS3 review: 9.0

GS OB 360 review: 9.5

.................................................................

I have a feeling this topic won't end with this thread. Who's got the popcorn?

KingOfKonging

I think it's funny. With ME it was the exact opposite. Everywhere they didn't bring down the score because of the technical shortcomings, but GS apperently found it rather significant. Now with OB on the PS3 its the other way around.

I am not shocked. Gamespot only cares about framerate if it is a 360 game.

JiveT

Fantasy land much? Just because one of your games got degraded to a 8.5 due to framerate doesn't mean anything.

[QUOTE="JiveT"]

I am not shocked. Gamespot only cares about framerate if it is a 360 game.

Xolver

Fantasy land much? Just because one of your games got degraded to a 8.5 due to framerate doesn't mean anything.

They gave the PS3 version of Madden the same score as the 360 version even though it had half the frame rate. They gave that Medal of Honor game the same score on PS3 as 360 even though they stated the frame rate comes to a halt at times. So maybe you should speak when you know something instead of living in the cow pasture drinking Kitagari Kool Aid.

[QUOTE="BTBAM127"]ahhhh!! now im even more confused!! haha shoud i get this for my ps3 or pc?!?!?! please helpleviathan91

PC version is the best out of the three and you can sign up for Steam and download tons of games and demos. Plus, Garry's Mod. :D

yeah man haha i have steam as well as CSS garys mod 10 and episode 1 and now half life 2 since a friend just gave it to me as a gift ( over steam) cuz he had 2 for some reason. but i tihnk i will go with ps3 then get TF2 off of steam later on

[QUOTE="leviathan91"][QUOTE="Ragnarok1051"]

[QUOTE="istreakforfood"]what happened to the cows saying we dont follow gamespot anymore we should go by gamerankings :cry: ?TiberiusKane

Lemmings used it for Mass Effect, why can't everybody else?

Technically, cows used it first but ever since Mass Defect flopped, lems have done the same. Fanboys these days.:roll: (not referring to the persons I just quoted)

Only since what happened to Jeff. After that there is no way you can ask me to take reviews here seriously.

It has been done before the Jeff incident a couple of times.Andis being used right now from both sides still. Besides, the R&CF score wasreally low and severly underrated. I mean compared to the other reviews, itshouldof at least gotten ahigh AA to low AAA but instead it had "too much variety" WTF!?

so what of all the EA-bashing threads now? And will Cows buy this AAA game?Dreams-Visions

dv. you know im gonna get i. and if a fanboy not u lol. says it's bias because 360 version got a 9.5 their just stupid. and well a fanboy

[QUOTE="leviathan91"]

[QUOTE="BTBAM127"]ahhhh!! now im even more confused!! haha shoud i get this for my ps3 or pc?!?!?! please helpBTBAM127

PC version is the best out of the three and you can sign up for Steam and download tons of games and demos. Plus, Garry's Mod. :D

yeah man haha i have steam as well as CSS garys mod 10 and episode 1 and now half life 2 since a friend just gave it to me as a gift ( over steam) cuz he had 2 for some reason. but i tihnk i will go with ps3 then get TF2 off of steam later on

i want this game so bad, i need a PS3

[QUOTE="BTBAM127"][QUOTE="leviathan91"]

[QUOTE="BTBAM127"]ahhhh!! now im even more confused!! haha shoud i get this for my ps3 or pc?!?!?! please helpleviathan91

PC version is the best out of the three and you can sign up for Steam and download tons of games and demos. Plus, Garry's Mod. :D

yeah man haha i have steam as well as CSS garys mod 10 and episode 1 and now half life 2 since a friend just gave it to me as a gift ( over steam) cuz he had 2 for some reason. but i tihnk i will go with ps3 then get TF2 off of steam later on

yeah i know but iunno it would be fun playing through all of them on my ps3 and portals will probably look better on my ps3 then my computer since the graphics card isnt the best

[QUOTE="Xolver"][QUOTE="JiveT"]

I am not shocked. Gamespot only cares about framerate if it is a 360 game.

JiveT

Fantasy land much? Just because one of your games got degraded to a 8.5 due to framerate doesn't mean anything.

They gave the PS3 version of Madden the same score as the 360 version even though it had half the frame rate. They gave that Medal of Honor game the same score on PS3 as 360 even though they stated the frame rate comes to a halt at times. So maybe you should speak when you know something instead of living in the cow pasture drinking Kitagari Kool Aid.

take it easy! If you even read the Madden review, they said the frame rate doesn't effect the overall experience.

360 version >>>PS3 version100Gamer

[QUOTE="100Gamer"]360 version >>>PS3 versionermacness

yeah, that's pretty true.

back to gamespot now, cows?CaseyWegner

81% at gamerankings. I smell something fishy. DisPimpin

there's only three reviews.

back to gamespot now, cows?CaseyWegner

lol, you hate ps3 owners period.....just come out and say it.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]back to gamespot now, cows?MikeE21286

lol, you hate ps3 owners period.....just come out and say it.

why do you say that?

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]back to gamespot now, cows?CaseyWegner

lol, you hate ps3 owners period.....just come out and say it.

why do you say that?

uh, casey, it's totally obvious. but anyhoo . . .

[QUOTE="DisPimpin"]81% at gamerankings. I smell something fishy. CaseyWegner

there's only three reviews.

woot better then flop effect :D

ProtossRushX

Orange Box PS3: 81.3%
Mass Effect 360: 91.9%

But wait, lemme guess now Gamerankings doesn't count, right? And 360 owners not only get a solid AAE in Mass Effect, they get a much better version of Orange Box. Ouch, kid.

Oh, and one more tidbit for ya: Orange Box 360: 96.2%

kthxbai

Nice! Another AAA for the PS3! :DRikusaki

Yet the 360 version is again better! No AAA PS3 EXCLUSIVES!

Yes seeing it rated this high here, and severly marked down compared to IGN/ Gamesy (comapred to pc / 360 versions) makes me futher question GS reviews......kcm_117

9.0 vs. 8.4 is a severe difference?

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]back to gamespot now, cows?biggamerhk

lol, you hate ps3 owners period.....just come out and say it.

why do you say that?

uh, casey, it's totally obvious. but anyhoo . . .

then it should be easy to answer.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]back to gamespot now, cows?MikeE21286

lol, you hate ps3 owners period.....just come out and say it.

Nice! Another AAA for the PS3! :DRikusaki

I knew this would happen the game gets a 9.0 and the cow's suddenly forget about all the complaining and crying they did earlier. :roll:

cows get another inferior multiplat :lol:100Gamer

and the pc version is best like usal

well thats still a good score, I think Ill pick this up, it still sounds like a positive review.Star67

and about the shortest review in gs history, half a page for the ps3 review vs 3 pages for the pc/x360 review

Eat it haters.

Keep talking smack about PS3 ports. Gamespot scores say different.

booyah.

I sure hope that doesn't discourage PS3 owners, this collection of games is amazing.

Oh and just so you people know, another patch is coming out before Christmas, that should further alleviate the lag and losing connection problems. And free DLC coming early next year! :D

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]Nice! Another AAA for the PS3! :DGh0st_Of_0nyx

I knew this would happen the game gets a 9.0 and the cow's suddenly forget about all the complaining and crying they did earlier. :roll:

pre-alpha damage control. i mean pre-pre-alpha damage control.

gamespot is teh bias cause 9.0 is not 9.5 :cry:

just wait....

Kaosed

I love the "just wait..." :)

[QUOTE="bigLLL"]No way I would pay a cent for this port, it uses one single core and none of the other processers, it's not a ps3 game at all. just a really bad port.Bansheesdie

AAA 9.0 is a bad port :|

it is a bad port. there's another thread out there in SW that contains a link to a side by side comparison of the game agains the 360. the PS3 shows some framerate problems throughout I think, but I definitely noticed it during the boat portion of the game. its pretty terrible that theres framerate issues for a game that came out during the last generation.