ME or KOTOR??????

to people who have played both which do you prefer?? the bland, horrible ,un-emotional storytelling that is KOTOR? or the new version of that kind of storytelling with shiny graphics?? discuss :D

Hmmmmm... muffins! :)

Im a big fan of both KOTOR games and Mass Effect but with that being said i enjoy Mass Effect more then KOTOR.

Mass Effect is one of the most amazing games ive played in years

I like both... I haven't finished ME yet, but so far it has been pretty great. (only about 17 hours in)

I wish ME had more cities like Kotor, there's really only one city in ME which was disappointing.

I would pick you.Gamingcucumber

I pick me.

I like both... I haven't finished ME yet, but so far it has been pretty great. (only about 17 hours in)

I wish ME had more cities like Kotor, there's really only one city in ME which was disappointing.

Harbadakus

I would pick you.Gamingcucumber

seconded

[QUOTE="Harbadakus"]

I like both... I haven't finished ME yet, but so far it has been pretty great. (only about 17 hours in)

I wish ME had more cities like Kotor, there's really only one city in ME which was disappointing.

Brutal_Elitegs

well really the story wasn't really that involving compared to say a lot of thoer RPG's :S it was a GOOD story to be sure, but it jsut doesn't have the actual STORYdepth you would get from a different RPG. your character not talking helped contribute to detracting from the stories impact on the player.

but just to be sure i might play through it again in the next day or so :D

[QUOTE="Harbadakus"]

I like both... I haven't finished ME yet, but so far it has been pretty great. (only about 17 hours in)

I wish ME had more cities like Kotor, there's really only one city in ME which was disappointing.

Brutal_Elitegs

Graphics: Mass Effect

Story: Tie

Sound: Mass Effect

Voice acting: Mass Effect

Side Quests: Kotor

Combat: ...Probably tie for me

Characters: Tie

ME is really one of the best video games I've ever played. People will say "you haven't played many games then", but they're full of it. It's a Top 10 lifetime game, it's just that good. GS has never been so off the mark with a flop, and I rarely say that.whoisryanmack

[QUOTE="whoisryanmack"]ME is really one of the best video games I've ever played. People will say "you haven't played many games then", but they're full of it. It's a Top 10 lifetime game, it's just that good. GS has never been so off the mark with a flop, and I rarely say that.PBSnipes

has much has i love ME i just love KOTOR BetterPS360Fanboy

MASS EFFECT is RPG of the year and potential GOTY. It's probably my game of the year but won't decide til I've finished it. I heard the endings amazing.

I voted Kotor though. I just loved Kotor I holda candle for that game like other greats Chrono Trigger, FF7. I played Kotor at a time when every RPG seemed the same and was rather dull and boring and at the right time.

ME is amazing but its taken some steps forward and some steps back. But I have yet to finish and maybe my mind will change.

[QUOTE="Brutal_Elitegs"][QUOTE="Harbadakus"]

I like both... I haven't finished ME yet, but so far it has been pretty great. (only about 17 hours in)

I wish ME had more cities like Kotor, there's really only one city in ME which was disappointing.

game_fanatic

well really the story wasn't really that involving compared to say a lot of thoer RPG's :S it was a GOOD story to be sure, but it jsut doesn't have the actual STORYdepth you would get from a different RPG. your character not talking helped contribute to detracting from the stories impact on the player.

but just to be sure i might play through it again in the next day or so :D

Absolute rubbish. I've played almost all the FF, Chrono's, Baldurs, E-Scrolls among other Story based games like Deus Ex.

Kotor's strongest point was its amazing story and depth of story. It paced itself well and had an amazing ending that few games can compare too. Kotor imo could be considered the best story in a game ever. I've enjoyed many delightful stories but Kotor's even with its limited Star Wars realm was fantastic and engaging.

my opinion but seriously Kotor's story was great...

Love M.E. But...

Kotor Baby !

In KOTOR, I thought the end had come about three times before the real end really did come and credits rolled.

M.E., the credits were rolling and I was shocked that the game was really over ! :cry:

Many other things as well but man I can not believe that the game ended without that feeling of:

Wow I thought the game was going to end three levels ago - did they fool me - awesome - kind of thing ! :?

PS: really miss the Light Sabers and all the saber rattling too. :)

graphically, environments, gameplay, and interaction i have to go with ME.you can tell they tried to go over the top and spent a lot of money developing this game.

storywise ME was good but i thought KOTOR 1 was better due to how they portraited darth malak. this is coming from a guy who isnt a fan of star wars.

I have to go with KOTOR.

Much longer and fulfilling quest, better party character development, more amusing characters in the s-tyle of Bioware, like Jolee and HK, better side quests, more cities.

I like the novelties that Mass Effect bought to Bioware's c-lassic s-tyle. Your main character speaking his lines for the first time was really great, as well as the background options were perfectly integrated throughout the game. The adventure is really short though, even though it took me 50 hours, I can see it is possible to finish it on 12, if you so desired it.

Much longer and fulfilling quest, better party character development, more amusing characters in the s-tyle of Bioware, like Jolee and HK, better side quests, more cities.

Panzer_Zwei

yea they had memorable and better developed characters in kotor 1.

to people who have played both which do you prefer?? the bland, horrible ,un-emotional storytelling that is KOTOR? or the new version of that kind of storytelling with shiny graphics?? discuss :D

game_fanatic