Can We Mostly Agree on This List of Best Games This Gen??

Demon Souls > Dark Souls.

Demon souls should replace RDR

Nope I can't agree with that list at all.

you guys are too picky to be a decent judge of gaming.

i have literally played hundreds of games this gen that i thought were good.

my best of list would probably be over a hundred games.

Anytime a thread title has "Can we agree?" or anything close to that I can go into the thread knowing I will not agree. Never fails.

Not really because its utterly a personal taste.blue_hazy_basic

Nope I can't agree with that list at all.

turtlethetaffer

Bioshock games are terrible.

Not a bad list.

Nope I can't agree with that list at all.

turtlethetaffer

Not really because its utterly a personal taste.blue_hazy_basic

yup, tbh I think LOU is getting lots of love right now because there is such a heavy drought of games lately.

Sorry, but Halo 3 definitely makes the top 10 list. Still unmatched when it comes to content. I mostly agree, although I'd swap out Mass effect 2 for either 1 or 3. Oblivion instead of Skyrim. COD4:MW deserved to be there more than the likes of Portal 2.RR360DD

[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"]Not really because its utterly a personal taste.dovberg

yup, tbh I think LOU is getting lots of love right now because there is such a heavy drought of games lately.

[QUOTE="RR360DD"]Sorry, but Halo 3 definitely makes the top 10 list. Still unmatched when it comes to content. I mostly agree, although I'd swap out Mass effect 2 for either 1 or 3. Oblivion instead of Skyrim. COD4:MW deserved to be there more than the likes of Portal 2.N30F3N1X

Nope. Sucky list. Badosh

Mass effect 2 was the worst one :cool: #dealwithitRR360DD

No wonder you have 360 in your name. Still butthurt because ME2 went to PS3 I see.

No forza? No PGR? No Burnout?

No good.

im curious what u think should have made the listms555

[QUOTE="RR360DD"]Mass effect 2 was the worst one :cool: #dealwithitN30F3N1X

No wonder you have 360 in your name. Still butthurt because ME2 went to PS3 I see.

I don't know about the positioning of the games on the lists but I will say I agree that all the games on both lists are excellent.

You are asking a bit too much to get all of these knuckleheads to agree on anything though.

I think its a good list even if its not "my" list. 

Not really because its utterly a personal taste.blue_hazy_basic

Exactly.

You named off several games I either do not like or simply thought were mediocre so thus I cant agree with your list of the best games because I dont think quite a few of them are.

You cant really argue personal taste since no two people have exactly the same one. Just because I like a game doesnt mean others have to, and if other people like a game I dont then thats fine and doesnt make the game actually bad, just means I think its bad.

Any list based on pure opinion is always a waste. Unless you can list something based on facts then a list means nothing.

I actually like that list :P

I might move some thing around, but I mostly agree with it.

So did ME 3 ... and none of the ME's were exclusive either ...blue_hazy_basic

Umad too :cool: ?

1. Last of Us - No
2. SKYRIM - No
3. Mass Effect 2 - No mass effect 1 maybe
4. Super Mario Galaxy 1 - didnt play
5. Bioshock 1 - yeah
6. Portal 2 - i guess
7. Uncharted 2 - no lol
8. Batman AC - ok
9. Red Dead Redemption - meh, its a good game but not one of the best
10. Bioshock Infinite - no lol

Honorable Mentions:
DARK SOULS - demons souls
FALLOUT 3 - no
DEUS EX HR - didnt play
HALO REACH - no lol
BATTLEFIELD 3 - no
MODERN WARFARE 1 - ehhhh i guess, unfortunately everything after it has tainted it.
JOURNEY - no
MGS4 - yes
SUPER SMASH BROS BRAWL - no, this is a bad kids game lol
ASSASSINS CREED 2 - no
WITCHER 2 - yes

[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"]So did ME 3 ... and none of the ME's were exclusive either ...N30F3N1X

Umad too :cool: ?

Demon Souls > Dark Souls.

Demon souls should replace RDR

lowkey254

[QUOTE="N30F3N1X"]

[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"]So did ME 3 ... and none of the ME's were exclusive either ...blue_hazy_basic

Umad too :cool: ?

Why would that make me mad? :? People on this board have peculiar ideas of what upsets people.blue_hazy_basic

If they weren't peculiar this place would be boring and lifeless.

Now I am :evil:blue_hazy_basic

That's the spirit. Feel the dark side of the rustle flow through your jimmies.

Nice opinion....there's my list:

1. TES V: Skyrim

2. Mass Effect 1

3. Red Dead Redemption

4. Bioshock Infinite

5. The Witcher 2

6. Mass Effect 2

7. Super Mario Galaxy 2

8. Left 4 Dead 2

9. Battlefield Bad Company 2

10. Minecraft

Honorable mentions:

GTA 4, Fallout 3, Fallout New Vegas, TES IV: Oblivion, Trials Evolution, The Walking Dead, Uncharted 2, Gears of War 3, Halo 3, Halo 4, Forza 4, Super Street Fighter 4, etc

Demon Souls > Dark Souls.

lowkey254

.

Nice opinion....there's my list:

1. TES V: Skyrim

2. Mass Effect 1

3. Red Dead Redemption

4. Bioshock Infinite

5. The Witcher 2

6. Mass Effect 2

7. Super Mario Galaxy 2

8. Left 4 Dead 2

9. Battlefield Bad Company 2

10. Minecraft

 

Honorable mentions:

GTA 4, Fallout 3, Fallout New Vegas, TES IV: Oblivion, Trials Evolution, The Walking Dead, Uncharted 2, Gears of War 3, Halo 3, Halo 4, Forza 4, Super Street Fighter 4, etc

PAL360

Bad opinion 

Trials Evolution isnt even on the list, easily one of the top 3 games of this gen.

The only way someone could not have that on the top 10 list is either they never played it, or they are filthy casual, which invalidates their opinions.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

Nice opinion....there's my list:

1. TES V: Skyrim

2. Mass Effect 1

3. Red Dead Redemption

4. Bioshock Infinite

5. The Witcher 2

6. Mass Effect 2

7. Super Mario Galaxy 2

8. Left 4 Dead 2

9. Battlefield Bad Company 2

10. Minecraft

 

Honorable mentions:

GTA 4, Fallout 3, Fallout New Vegas, TES IV: Oblivion, Trials Evolution, The Walking Dead, Uncharted 2, Gears of War 3, Halo 3, Halo 4, Forza 4, Super Street Fighter 4, etc

themajormayor

Bad opinion 

I think it's awesome :P

Didn't like mass effect 2.

>Chooses Galaxy 1 over Galaxy 2

>No Bayonetta

Nope. Can't fully agree with the list. Probably not an overall bad one though, and I do give you proprs for mentioning Halo Reach.

Honestly was not too impressed with this Gen Besides

The Last Of Us, Bioshock 1, and Disgaea 4.

Sure there are lots of great games, but these are the ones I remember the most (The ones that. There experiences dont top other PS2 games like ICO or Shadow Of The Colllosus though.

So I guess it was a OK gen. Hopefully next gen will be better.

Demon Souls > Dark Souls.

Demon souls should replace RDR

lowkey254

Started playing Demon's for the first time after LOVING Dark and I don't know why people say that. Demon's is one hell of a game but Dark Souls is overall much better and refined

Sure