And the GAME OF THE YEAR IS??? (Poll)

I'm so torn between Mass Effect and COD BO. I know Mass Effect 2 deserves it but we really need to consider the fact about just how much content and value is in COD BO I mean it is like 4 game in one. I mean even the freaking side scrolling zombie commando style unlock game from the computer login is good. Not to mention Nazi Zombies and a good lengh single player for a COD game that is. And then yeah the online is just dope.

To me it's a toss up between COD BO and Mass Effect and i'm leaning towards BO just becuase of how much good qaulity content and value you get with the game.

Oh and yeah HALO REACH but not enough room on the poll list.

mass effect 2 easily.

no game comes close this year so far nor will any game this year

My bet is on Starcraft 2, ME2 is still a lot of ME1 cut and paste, plus the only other candidates I see vying for it are Black Ops and Reach, both of which are packed with content but consequently make them too similar to each other for GS to pick either one outright. Thus, I think SC2 will come out on top.

Out of those, Mass Effect 2.

For me, Metro 2033

Its gonna be Red Dead Redemption.navyguy21

Impossible to decide as the year is not over.

Also, SMG2.

Honestly, and I'm surprised as hell that I'm saying this considering the CoD series and my previous frustrations with it, but right now its Black Ops. :o

Not a single game on that list would even come to my mind when thinking of GOTY. I would think of Super Mario Galaxy 2, Bad Company 2, God Of War III, Red Dead Redemption, and soon either Donkey Kong Country Returns, or Gran Turismo 5. That is a SUPER biased and awful poll.

If I owned a 360 Reach would probably be in that list.

Everyone is already forgetting the obvious winner, Pac-Man.

Don't know why Super Mario Galaxy 2 or Red Dead isn't on that list, oh well my vote goes to Mass Effect 2 anyways :)

Personally: Monster Hunter Tri

Realisticly: Mass Effect 2

mass effect 2 easily.

no game comes close this year so far nor will any game this year

Dead-Memories

Starcraft 2, Super Mario Galaxy 2 and Red Dead Redemption, easily say hi.

Which is funny because all of them outscore Mass Effect 2 here on GS.

SMG2 is GOTY, just accept it.

SMG2 is GOTY, just accept it.

Bigboi500

Personally: Monster Hunter Tri

Realisticly: Mass Effect 2

LegatoSkyheart

Ill follow your lead

Personally:yakuza 3

Realisticly:RDR

Star craft 2

Red dead redemption

Battlefield Badcompany 2

Super Mario Galaxy 2

God of War 3

Heavy Rain

COD Black Ops

Gran Turismo 5

All this games are this year,i wonder how they didnt make it to your list

Man what a horrible list, only ME2 has the slightest chance out of those games.

For me it was probably SC2. In spite of some major issues I have with it it's still a game I could probably recommend to anyone, the community tools are producing outstanding mini games, and the amount of polish on the product is simply bananas.

Red Dead Redemption

I'm not saying that SMG2 is GOTY but it is deffionatly in the consideration

[QUOTE="Bigboi500"]

SMG2 is GOTY, just accept it.

DragonfireXZ95

i dont see a wii game on this list therefor automatically disqualifies you tc

to be fair one big game should be listed from each console

such as

wii-goldeneye 007 dkc 4 metroid other m or kirby epic yarn or smg2

360 -reach fable3 etc

ps3 gt5 -coming , lbp2 uncharted 2 etc

so ya um pretty un balanced list

none of thsoe deserve goty

ill tell you what does though- dkc4

[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"][QUOTE="Bigboi500"]

SMG2 is GOTY, just accept it.

Bigboi500

Red Dead Redemption, Starcraft 2, Super Mario Galaxy 2, God of War 3 are appearing as Fable 3 and Final Fantasy 13 for some reason.....

[QUOTE="Bigboi500"]

[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"] Tell that to Starcraft 2. Seriously, I'm calling it right now. Starcraft 2 will win GOTY here.Arach666

So far for me its Bad Company 2 but I have a feeling it will be replaced by the game in my siggmaster456

you da man! :P

No starcraft2?

Why is Fable 3 and FF13 on there?

My vote would be ME2 or Halo Reach.

wow bad options..seriously FF13? Of course you do have the one I want (ME2) so I can't complain much.

Why didn't you include this game?

Where's Red Dead Redemption and Halo Reach. FFXIII doesn't belong on the list. Black Ops and Fable 3 are questionable as well. Even SMG2 should be on the list before those two games. Front what's given, the obvious choice is Mass Effect 2.