2009 - List Wars - X360 vs. PS3 Redux [56K Warning]

st1ka is no longer a member, so here's a continuation of the list he started.

The thread will be separated into several sections (Exclusives, Multiplats, XBLA/PSN, TBA/Rumored, MC/GS Totals).
For the sake of consistency, we'll be using NA release dates only.
Scoring at the end is separated as follows: AAAA/AAA=Gold, AA=Silver, A=Bronze
If MC scores and GS scores both fall under 70, the game becomes disqualified.
If there's anything missing, let me know and I'll add/update it.



[X360 vs. PS3 Exclusives]

X360 Exclusives

Halo 3: ODST
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Halo Wars
MC Rating: 82
GS Rating: 65


Ninja Blade
MC Rating: 68
GS Rating: na


Race Pro
MC Rating: 73
GS Rating: 75


Star Ocean: The Last Hope
MC Rating: 77
GS Rating: 75


Stoked
MC Rating: 73
GS Rating: 75




PS3 Exclusives

Cross Edge
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Data-Fly
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Demon's Souls
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


God of War III
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Heavy Rain
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Infamous
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Katamari Damacy Tribute
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Killzone 2
MC Rating: 92
GS Rating: 90


Quantum Theory
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Strength of the Sword
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Super Car Challenge
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


White Knight Chronicles
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na




[X360 vs. PS3 Multiplats]

X360/PC/Other Multiplats

Age of Conan: Hyborian Adventures
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Alan Wake
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Battlestations: Pacific
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Blood Bowl
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Champions Online
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Divinity 2: Ego Draconis
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Dungeon Hero
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Risen
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Section 8
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Two Worlds: The Temptation
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Velvet Assassin
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Venetica
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na




PS3/PC/Other Multiplats

Mars
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


MLB 09: The Show
MC Rating: 89
GS Rating: 90


Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


SingStar Queen
MC Rating: 79
GS Rating: na




[XBLA vs. PSN]

XBLA Games

Exit 2
MC Rating: 67
GS Rating: 75


Fallout 3: The Pitt
MC Rating: 79
GS Rating: na


Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost & Damned
MC Rating: 90
GS Rating: na


The Maw
MC Rating: 76
GS Rating: 70


R-Type Dimensions
MC Rating: 77
GS Rating: 70


Tomb Raider Underworld: Lara's Shadow
MC Rating: 70
GS Rating: na




PSN Games

Astro Tripper
MC Rating: 76
GS Rating: na


Burn Zombie Burn!
MC Rating: 76
GS Rating: na


Cuboid
MC Rating: 81
GS Rating: 60


Fat Princess
MC Rating: na
GS Rating: na


Flower
MC Rating: 87
GS Rating: 80


GTI Club+: Rally Cote d'Azur
MC Rating: 70
GS Rating: 70


Noby Noby Boy
MC Rating: 75
GS Rating: 75


Savage Moon
MC Rating: 73
GS Rating: 65




[TBA/Rumored]

X360/PC/Other
Age of Pirates: Captain Blood
All Points Bulletin
Banjo Tooie
Black Legions
Dead Island
The Dishwasher: Dead Samurai
Forza Motorsport 3
Huxley
Islands of Wakfu
Kingdom Under Fire II: Dominion
Lode Runner
Majesty 2: The Fantasy Kingdom Sim
Mobile Ops: The One Year War
Ninety-Nine Nights II
The Precursors
Salvation
The Secret World
Shadow Harvest
Theseis
Untitled Lionhead Studios Project
Untitled Rare Project #1
Untitled Rare Project #2
Untitled Wingnut Interactive Project
White Gold: War in Paradise

PS3/PC/Other
Afrika
Atelier Rorona
The Agency
DC Universe Online
EyePet
Final Fantasy Versus XIII
Free Realms
Gran Turismo 5
L.A. Noire
M.A.G.
The Punisher
Uncharted Waters Online
Under Siege
Untitled Team Ico Project
Untitled Twisted Metal Project
WarDevil
Warriors Orochi Z
Yakuza 3



[Metacritic Totals]

X360
82 Halo Wars
77 Star Ocean: The Last Hope
73 Stoked
73 Race Pro

XBLA
90 Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost & Damned
79 Fallout 3: The Pitt
77 R-Type Dimensions
76 The Maw
70 Tomb Raider Underworld: Lara's Shadow

PS3
92 Killzone 2
89 MLB 09: The Show
79 SingStar Queen

PSN
87 Flower
81 Cuboid
76 Astro Tripper
76 Burn Zombie Burn!
75 Noby Noby Boy
73 Savage Moon
70 GTI Club+: Rally Cote d'Azur

[GameSpot Totals]

X360
75 Star Ocean: The Last Hope
75 Race Pro
75 Stoked

XBLA
75 Exit 2
70 The Maw
70 R-Type Dimensions

PS3
90 Killzone 2
90 MLB 09: The Show

PSN
80 Flower
75 Noby Noby Boy
70 GTI Club+: Rally Cote d'Azur

360 list is missing lost planet 2 and forza 3 should be coming 09TX360

what happened to st1ka???tOtalPWNaAe

[QUOTE="tOtalPWNaAe"]what happened to st1ka???Floppy_Jim

[QUOTE="tOtalPWNaAe"]what happened to st1ka???Floppy_Jim

Was Lost Planet 2 confirmed 360 exclusive?aflakian

st1kas list used MC scores, so I'm just sticking with the same.
After I get the other sections setup, I'll add GS scores separately.aflakian

[QUOTE="aflakian"]st1kas list used MC scores, so I'm just sticking with the same.
After I get the other sections setup, I'll add GS scores separately.Tekkenloving

http://www.psu.com/God-of-War-III,-MAG,-Uncharted-2-coming-in-2009-News--a006509-p0.php

360 list is missing lost planet 2 and forza 3 should be coming 09TX360

They confirmed AoC for Xbox? I thought the company couldn't afford it...

Either way, the game sucks.

They confirmed AoC for Xbox? I thought the company couldn't afford it...

Either way, the game sucks.

TenP

I'm guessing that a lot of the stuff on the 360/PC side will end up being vaporware.
With AoC's poor community support and waning popularity, I wouldn't be surprised if the console release ends up getting canceled.aflakian

Ahh, it really is quite sad, it was amazing for the first week or so.

Then it all just went down the drain.

Halo War :lol:clembo1990

you let Gamespot tell you what to play? :lol:

It's sad how much emphasis some people put on 1 other persons opinion. Or how a large majority will let others do their thinking for them.

[QUOTE="clembo1990"]Halo War :lol:whatisazerg

you let Gamespot tell you what to play? :lol:

It's sad how much emphasis some people put on 1 other persons opinion. Or how a large majority will let others do their thinking for them.

Halo War :lol:clembo1990

[QUOTE="clembo1990"]Halo War :lol:SpruceCaboose

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"][QUOTE="clembo1990"]Halo War :lol:Master-Thief-09

Direct your attention to my sig or my other post. owned.clembo1990

[QUOTE="clembo1990"] Direct your attention to my sig or my other post. owned.Ninja-Hippo

[QUOTE="tOtalPWNaAe"]what happened to st1ka???Floppy_Jim

Well if I'm a fanboy I'm a pretty crappy one for playing Halo 3 so much.clembo1990

Halo 3 Career Statsfor CurbStomp9000

Total Games * 61 *

Matchmade Games * 61 *

Custom Games * 0 *

Campaign Missions * 0 *

Highest Skill * 13 *

Total EXP * 25

[QUOTE="clembo1990"] Well if I'm a fanboy I'm a pretty crappy one for playing Halo 3 so much.SpruceCaboose

Halo 3 Career Statsfor CurbStomp9000

Total Games * 61 *

Matchmade Games * 61 *

Custom Games * 0 *

Campaign Missions * 0 *

Highest Skill * 13 *

Total EXP * 25

[QUOTE="clembo1990"] Well if I'm a fanboy I'm a pretty crappy one for playing Halo 3 so much.SpruceCaboose

Halo 3 Career Statsfor CurbStomp9000

Total Games * 61 *

Matchmade Games * 61 *

Custom Games * 0 *

Campaign Missions * 0 *

Highest Skill * 13 *

Total EXP * 25

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"]

[QUOTE="clembo1990"] Well if I'm a fanboy I'm a pretty crappy one for playing Halo 3 so much.killerfist

Halo 3 Career Statsfor CurbStomp9000

Total Games * 61 *

Matchmade Games * 61 *

Custom Games * 0 *

Campaign Missions * 0 *

Highest Skill * 13 *

Total EXP * 25

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"][QUOTE="tOtalPWNaAe"]what happened to st1ka???killerfist

Bandodging. He made another account (his 3rd) and sent me a PM to tell me he got banned. And then that account also got banned almost straight away. So unfortunately, that's the last we'll be seeing of him.Floppy_Jim

Thats going to be the response. Always is.SpruceCaboose

st1ka is banned? All the good posters get banned, all the alts get to stay. Sad

Its going to be a pretty good year for games.SpruceCaboose

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]Bandodging. He made another account (his 3rd) and sent me a PM to tell me he got banned. And then that account also got banned almost straight away. So unfortunately, that's the last we'll be seeing of him.killerfist

No, his 1st account was "stika". He should have been more careful choosing the name of his second account, he just replaced the "i" with a "1". Shame though, he was one of the few good posters.

[QUOTE="Tekkenloving"][QUOTE="aflakian"]st1kas list used MC scores, so I'm just sticking with the same.
After I get the other sections setup, I'll add GS scores separately.SpruceCaboose

http://www.psu.com/God-of-War-III,-MAG,-Uncharted-2-coming-in-2009-News--a006509-p0.php

Link

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"]

[QUOTE="Tekkenloving"]lol I don't really care dude and sony said GOWIII will release in the fiscal year I don't think there's a big chance it will release before march 2010 so shift that one towards rumored? rybe1025

http://www.psu.com/God-of-War-III,-MAG,-Uncharted-2-coming-in-2009-News--a006509-p0.php

Link

Shame though, he was one of the few good posters.

Floppy_Jim

[QUOTE="killerfist"][QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"] He got banned :( Floppy_Jim

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"][QUOTE="clembo1990"] Well if I'm a fanboy I'm a pretty crappy one for playing Halo 3 so much.Ninja-Hippo

Edit: not that it's important I don't have to prove anything when I know I speant rediculous ammounts on my 360, not that it's anything to be proud of it's just sadly true.

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]Bandodging. He made another account (his 3rd) and sent me a PM to tell me he got banned. And then that account also got banned almost straight away. So unfortunately, that's the last we'll be seeing of him.killerfist

Thats going to be the response. Always is.SpruceCaboose

Shameless bump.
Are there any other games that need to be added?