Which is better UNcharted 2 or MGS4?

POLL.

I would have to say Uncharted 2.

i agree 100% itried mgs4 but didnt like it. the fmv in mgs4 are awful even my girlfriend said when the fmv started was these fmv are gay.those were her exact words no offence to any1 that likes mgs4. deepdown i know its agood game its just not for me

MGS4 is unbelievably overrated, and the story is boring if anything.

Uncharted 2 truly is an epic game though

I liked MGS4 more than Uncharted 2.

I enjoyed MGS4 more than Uncharted 2

I liked MGS4 more than Uncharted 2.

LightR

I enjoyed MGS4 more than Uncharted 2

ElvesOnEcstacy

Uncharted 2 by a mile. I've tried to play through MGS4 quite a few times, it's just too unrealistic, and has some of the worst AI I've ever seen in a video game. The story is good, but the rest stinks. Of course just my opinion.

Uncharted 2 by a mile. I've tried to play through MGS4 quite a few times, it's just too unrealistic, and has some of the worst AI I've ever seen in a video game. The story is good, but the rest stinks. Of course just my opinion.

this topic supposed to be the system war

Uncharted 2 IMO, while both were equal in gameplay, UC2 had better controls, graphics and multiplayer. MGS4 has better music and boss battles though.

Get MGS4, Uncharted 2 is the most over rated game in history !!

MGS4 definitely

MGS4 campaign beats U2's if you know the MGS universe otherwise most people will enjoy U2 more.

U2's multiplayer is tons more fun than MGS4's IMO plus it has coop :D

Well that's my two-cents

I've been a Metal Gear Solid fanboy since the first one came out on the PS1. MGS4 is the reason why I have two PS3's. The game itself will make me jump off the fence anytime, so logically I'd pick MGS4 even if deep down inside U2 was better.

Though I haven't played Uncharted or U2 for that matter, I have ordered both of them and should be recieving them soon.

Uncharted 2 is a different game then MGS4 in the respect that one is a westerner game and MGS is a Asian game Uncharted more action lots of guns women etc. Decent plot, MGS 4 slowerpace more thinking involveld stealth game that is very heavy on the plot but its graphics are not as good as U2

Uncharted 2 is the best PS3 Exclusive by a long shot.

MGS4 is the worst in the series and I can't be bothered finishing it.

Story- MGS4... simply over 20 years of epicness. Gameplay- Uncharted 2.JKnaperek

both games are great, but I perfer uncharted 2, it's more entertaining.

As much as I love Uncharted 2, it is no equal to MGS4, hell.... its not even a match for the PS1 version of MGS.

Its like MGS is wearing a throwback jersey and Uncharted is still a starter.

Uncharted 2 by a mile. I've tried to play through MGS4 quite a few times, it's just too unrealistic, and has some of the worst AI I've ever seen in a video game. The story is good, but the rest stinks. Of course just my opinion.

coasterguy65

No doubt uncharted 2 is more then just impressive but MGS 4 Sums up pretty much the whole mgs series, which just makes it an instant classic. I would have to say mgs4 is better but being a fan of MGS my opinion is obviously bias.

Get MGS4, Uncharted 2 is the most over rated game in history !!

PsychoMantizX

How is this game the most over rated game in history? Naughty Dog has done a fabolous job constructing this game and it achieved its reviews fairly. It also satisfied many people out there with its epic gameplay and story. MGS 4 was fun and everything, but I think Uncharted 2 takes the gold.

[QUOTE="PsychoMantizX"]

Get MGS4, Uncharted 2 is the most over rated game in history !!

Whale_

How is this game the most over rated game in history? It's Damn fun enough so that all the crappy AI, lack of variety and puzzles and character freezing and 10 player matches not seem so bad.

Tough to say

Both games left me w/ my jaw on the floor

It's been nearly a year since i played MGS4, it left a massive impact on me, the microwave scene, damn it was intense

I got Uncharted 2 on my b-day, Blew me the hell away the first time i played it

So i gotta give the nod to Nathan Drake, Uncharted 2 is awesome. I got my first Platinum trophy on that game

little side-note: Where's the trophy patch for MGS4, Konami has been teasing us long enough

They are pretty different so its hard to pick, but I think MGS4 is better if you are more into strategic, tactical play and are a fan of the series. Uncharted 2 has better cinematics and online, and I personally enjoyed it immeidately a bit more though it wasn't as satisfying to beat without MGS4's intense BB Extreme challenges.

battle one on one liquid vs snake epic

that is history making

Uncharted 2 cause i havent played all of the MGS games so i dont know the story that well.
Both legends though.

hard decision but Uncharted 2 had be in till the very end. mgs4 is too great but so many people love to hate it so ill just give it to Uncharted 2.

Uncharted 2

imo - everything: mgs4Crucifier

Uncharted 2 definitely, i liked MGS4's single player, but i hated MGO cause the controls were too tactical for me and i was justflat out terrible in the multiplayer in general, but i'm very good in Uncharted 2's multiplayer, so i'll stick with that