Sith or Jedi?

Jolee Bindo walked the dark/lightside tightrope like a boss.

[QUOTE="gaming25"][QUOTE="JediXMan7"]

Tell that to Revan.

wis3boi

You want to see that?

though he is quite off his rocker if I must say

wis3boi

More and more and more. Which would be total disaster and not be good at all.

[QUOTE="worlock77"]

The Jedi had become bloated and dogmatic, while the Sith picked retarded names for themselves*. I guess I'd choose to be a Jedi, but only if it's in Luke Skywalker's new Jedi era.

(*their names were such dead giveaways that there should have been a Sith named Darth Obvious)

JediXMan7

Oh I don't know. If you heard of a guy named Tenebrous, Zannah, Caedus, Sion, Nihl, or Maladi, I don't think you'd automatically think "evil."

PS: Yes, those are all Darths.

[QUOTE="JediXMan7"]

[QUOTE="worlock77"]

The Jedi had become bloated and dogmatic, while the Sith picked retarded names for themselves*. I guess I'd choose to be a Jedi, but only if it's in Luke Skywalker's new Jedi era.

(*their names were such dead giveaways that there should have been a Sith named Darth Obvious)

OrkHammer007

Oh I don't know. If you heard of a guy named Tenebrous, Zannah, Caedus, Sion, Nihl, or Maladi, I don't think you'd automatically think "evil."

PS: Yes, those are all Darths.

Not automatically. They're not as obvious as Bane, Sidious, Maul, etc.

crap i picked Sith, i meant to pick Jedi

[QUOTE="wis3boi"][QUOTE="gaming25"] I hope I never see that occur, because I would have the hardest time facing something like that.gaming25

You want to see that?

[QUOTE="OrkHammer007"]

[QUOTE="JediXMan7"]

Oh I don't know. If you heard of a guy named Tenebrous, Zannah, Caedus, Sion, Nihl, or Maladi, I don't think you'd automatically think "evil."

PS: Yes, those are all Darths.

JediXMan7

Not automatically. They're not as obvious as Bane, Sidious, Maul, etc.

Maybe it's all of the Lovecraft I've read, but Tenebrous was pretty distinct to me, too.

level 37 instance in SWTOR contains Revan. You learn a lot about him in that. Quite the balance indeed, walking on both sides at once. wis3boi

You want to see that?

Sith, because they're stronger than Jedi's..

If I'm not mistaken Luke Skywalker walked that dark/light line pretty well. I mean he was a good guy, but he wasn't necessarily afraid to use powers traditionally attributed to the darkside.

Sith, because they're stronger than Jedi's..

deathtarget04

Sith. All that celibacy and emotional restraint crap isn't my style. Hate and anger FTW!Rhazakna

To be fair once Luke re-established the Jedi Order the celebacy rule was one of the things he tossed out.

[QUOTE="Rhazakna"]Sith. All that celibacy and emotional restraint crap isn't my style. Hate and anger FTW!worlock77

To be fair once Luke re-established the Jedi Order the celebacy rule was one of the things he tossed out.

That's something that never made sense to me. The Light Side was supposed to be about controlling emotion and idle passion, so the Jedi rightly noted that romantic entanglements might lead to the Dark Side. At most, Luke should've made it ok for Jedi to screw hookers. Relationships would just screw everything up for them.

Under those rules Jacen Solo became Darth Caedus. I think Luke just wanted to reestablish the order and still get laid.

[QUOTE="worlock77"]

[QUOTE="Rhazakna"]Sith. All that celibacy and emotional restraint crap isn't my style. Hate and anger FTW!Rhazakna

To be fair once Luke re-established the Jedi Order the celebacy rule was one of the things he tossed out.

That's something that never made sense to me. The Light Side was supposed to be about controlling emotion and idle passion, so the Jedi rightly noted that romantic entanglements might lead to the Dark Side. At most, Luke should've made it ok for Jedi to screw hookers. Relationships would just screw everything up for them.

Under those rules Jacen Solo became Darth Caedus. I think Luke just wanted to reestablish the order and still get laid.

I think the reasoning might have been that if relationships weren't prohibited in the old Jedi then his father could have openly turned to his fellow Jedi with what was troubling him rather than going to the enemy for help. But yeah, he probably just wanted to get laid also.

That's something that never made sense to me. The Light Side was supposed to be about controlling emotion and idle passion, so the Jedi rightly noted that romantic entanglements might lead to the Dark Side. At most, Luke should've made it ok for Jedi to screw hookers. Relationships would just screw everything up for them.

Under those rules Jacen Solo became Darth Caedus. I think Luke just wanted to reestablish the order and still get laid.

Rhazakna

In order to rebuild the order, Luke had to recruit Force sensitives who were already grown adults. Celibacy wasn't viable anymore. That's the reason for the change, in the canon.

[QUOTE="Rhazakna"]

That's something that never made sense to me. The Light Side was supposed to be about controlling emotion and idle passion, so the Jedi rightly noted that romantic entanglements might lead to the Dark Side. At most, Luke should've made it ok for Jedi to screw hookers. Relationships would just screw everything up for them.

Under those rules Jacen Solo became Darth Caedus. I think Luke just wanted to reestablish the order and still get laid.

airshocker

In order to rebuild the order, Luke had to recruit Force sensitives who were already grown adults. Celibacy wasn't viable anymore. That's the reason for the change, in the canon.

You seem to know much about this young padawan....LJS9502_basic

I have read almost every single Star Wars book ever written. :P

[QUOTE="Rhazakna"]

That's something that never made sense to me. The Light Side was supposed to be about controlling emotion and idle passion, so the Jedi rightly noted that romantic entanglements might lead to the Dark Side. At most, Luke should've made it ok for Jedi to screw hookers. Relationships would just screw everything up for them.

Under those rules Jacen Solo became Darth Caedus. I think Luke just wanted to reestablish the order and still get laid.

airshocker

In order to rebuild the order, Luke had to recruit Force sensitives who were already grown adults. Celibacy wasn't viable anymore. That's the reason for the change, in the canon.

That really makes no sense at all. Look at actual orders that practice celibacy. Most of the time the people in them aren't born into them (though there are exception). It stands to reason that celibacy would be far more viable if you were recruiting adults, since they would understand the weight of the choice. Recruiting kids who have no sex drive yet, into a celibate order sounds far more problematic than recruiting adults who understand what they're sacrificing.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]You seem to know much about this young padawan....airshocker

I have read almost every single Star Wars book ever written. :P

That really makes no sense at all. Look at actual orders that practice celibacy. Most of the time the people in them aren't born into them (though there are exception). It stands to reason that celibacy would be far more viable if you were recruiting adults, since they would understand the weight of the choice. Recruiting kids who have no sex drive yet, into a celibate order sounds far more problematic than recruiting adults who understand what they're sacrificing.

Rhazakna

It makes perfect sense. Adults who have already experienced sex will most likely not give that up just to become a Jedi.

[QUOTE="lordreaven"]

One who can walk the narrow line of light and dark is truely free.

gaming25

sith most likely.

[QUOTE="Rhazakna"]

That really makes no sense at all. Look at actual orders that practice celibacy. Most of the time the people in them aren't born into them (though there are exception). It stands to reason that celibacy would be far more viable if you were recruiting adults, since they would understand the weight of the choice. Recruiting kids who have no sex drive yet, into a celibate order sounds far more problematic than recruiting adults who understand what they're sacrificing.

airshocker

It makes perfect sense. Adults who have already experienced sex will most likely not give that up just to become a Jedi.

So adults would give up sex for the priesthood, or to be monks, but they wouldn't give it up to be monks with super powers? That doesn't make sense. Also, if you're recruited before you know what sex is, before you even have a sex drive, puberty would be extremely problematic for you. All of a sudden you have urges to do all these things you never wanted to before, but you've already agreed never to do them. That's absurd. Bad Star Wars writing strikes again!

[QUOTE="gaming25"][QUOTE="lordreaven"]

One who can walk the narrow line of light and dark is truely free.

[QUOTE="worlock77"]

[QUOTE="Rhazakna"]Sith. All that celibacy and emotional restraint crap isn't my style. Hate and anger FTW!Rhazakna

To be fair once Luke re-established the Jedi Order the celebacy rule was one of the things he tossed out.

That's something that never made sense to me. The Light Side was supposed to be about controlling emotion and idle passion, so the Jedi rightly noted that romantic entanglements might lead to the Dark Side. At most, Luke should've made it ok for Jedi to screw hookers. Relationships would just screw everything up for them.

Under those rules Jacen Solo became Darth Caedus. I think Luke just wanted to reestablish the order and still get laid.

Jedi. Palpatine was a jobber. He wastoo proud and eventually he lost the battle.

[QUOTE="airshocker"]

[QUOTE="Rhazakna"]

That really makes no sense at all. Look at actual orders that practice celibacy. Most of the time the people in them aren't born into them (though there are exception). It stands to reason that celibacy would be far more viable if you were recruiting adults, since they would understand the weight of the choice. Recruiting kids who have no sex drive yet, into a celibate order sounds far more problematic than recruiting adults who understand what they're sacrificing.

Rhazakna

It makes perfect sense. Adults who have already experienced sex will most likely not give that up just to become a Jedi.

So adults would give up sex for the priesthood, or to be monks, but they wouldn't give it up to be monks with super powers? That doesn't make sense. Also, if you're recruited before you know what sex is, before you even have a sex drive, puberty would be extremely problematic for you. All of a sudden you have urges to do all these things you never wanted to before, but you've already agreed never to do them. That's absurd. Bad Star Wars writing strikes again!

Well even under the old Jedi Order not all Jedis remained celebate. I believe even Obi Wan carried out an affair with another, female, Jedi.

sith

I would be a Sith for sure.

Bounty hunter with force powers and a lightsaber.Lonelynight

Wait.

I want to be a Republic Commando with force powers.

That'd be smart.

sith