Fight Club vs. American History X (Poll)

Which one is better? I think Fight Club is much better.

I've only seen Fight Club.

Both were pretty good, but I have an easier time watching Fight Club.

Which one is better?

stupid4

American History X is so overrated. It's only popular because of the "controversial" subject matter.

Wow TC this is a terrific versus one of the best in awhile. Both movies are amazing imo, so my vote goes to neither because I cant make up my mind.

Both ridiculously overrated in my opinion, but I'll go with Fight Club.

I've only seen Fight Club so my vote goes for it.

Btw I'm thinking of seeing American History X, how good is with? In a scale of 1-10, being 1 extreme crap and 10 extreme awesome

I've only seen Fight Club so my vote goes for it.

Btw I'm thinking of seeing American History X, how good is with? In a scale of 1-10, being 1 extreme crap and 10 extreme awesome

zigaum

7.5

It's a good movie, but it's overrated because of the subject matter. I would advise giving it a watch.

Both ridiculously overrated in my opinion, but I'll go with Fight Club.

MetroidPrimePwn

This

American History X hands down.

both are amaxing movies but i think fight club alittle more

American History X gets my vote.

Both were really good films, but I like Fight Club more.

I don't think Fight Club gets overrated. It just has somewhat of a cult following. Frenzyd109

David Fincher is notorious for making cult films.

fight club, the club where we fight :P

i've only seen fight club

I'm sorry, i can't choose. I love them both. Edward Norton is just amazing....*sigh*

Which one is better? I think Fight Club is much better.

stupid4

Well, A Clockwork Orange is one of the greatest things to be committed to celluloid.... or so I heard...Jazz_Fan

You are correct, good sir.

:P

[QUOTE="Jazz_Fan"]Well, A Clockwork Orange is one of the greatest things to be committed to celluloid.... or so I heard...sammyjenkis898

You are correct, good sir.

:P

A Clockwork Orange = my second favorite movie.

[QUOTE="sammyjenkis898"]

[QUOTE="Jazz_Fan"]Well, A Clockwork Orange is one of the greatest things to be committed to celluloid.... or so I heard...stupid4

You are correct, good sir.

:P

A Clockwork Orange = my second favorite movie.

[QUOTE="Jazz_Fan"]Well, A Clockwork Orange is one of the greatest things to be committed to celluloid.... or so I heard...sammyjenkis898

You are correct, good sir.

:P

[QUOTE="stupid4"]

[QUOTE="sammyjenkis898"]

You are correct, good sir.

:P

sammyjenkis898

A Clockwork Orange = my second favorite movie.

Lol

Post your top 5. I would like to compare. Mine is

1. Taxi Driver

2. A Clockwork Orange

3. Pulp Fiction

4. Platoon

5. There Will Be Blood

Lol

Post your top 5. I would like to compare. Mine is

1. Taxi Driver

2. A Clockwork Orange

3. Pulp Fiction

4. Platoon

5. There Will Be Blood

stupid4

Honestly, it changes constantly. The first two films always stay in the same position. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind ends up there a lot.

Glad you mentioned There Will Be Blood. One of the best films of the decade.

:D

Fight Club. I honestly don't see how its overrated. Its one of the few movies I really loved after my first viewing.

1. Taxi Driver

2. A Clockwork Orange

3. Pulp Fiction

4. Platoon

5. There Will Be Blood

stupid4

Just for the hell of it, I'll raise you my top 5 :D

1. The Godfather

2. 2001: A Space Odyssey

3. The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly

4. Pulp Fiction

5. Taxi Driver

American history x, because I havent seen Fight club yet

The plot in American History X is fantastic. But both are dark, evil movies.

Its hard. Norton is my favorite actor. I guess i'll go with American History X just by a little.

Both were good, but I only own Fight Club on DVD, so you know were my vote went.

Also, fight club told the truth about a lot of cultural subjects, mainly stepping on Generation X's heels just to watch them trip. American history X was an Anti-Nazi movie and it made a lot of sense, it was the cold and out there clear subject movie and it was still good.

I'm in the tiny minority of people who didn't like Fight Club, so American History X by default, since I did like that one. :P

I'm in the tiny minority of people who didn't like Fight Club, so American History X by default, since I did like that one. :P

GabuEx

American History X is way better.

American History X. Although they are both great movies

My vote goes to Fight Club.

See, American History X was just plain too overtly preachy. While Fight Club was not only more subtle and thought-provoking, but just generally hilarious and more entertaining.

I haven't seen American History X, so Fight Club by default. I really do wanna see American History X.

Which one is better? I think Fight Club is much better.

stupid4

The Shawshank Redemption

because i haven''t seen the other 2